Canary, Bad End
Things to know before going into this!
1. If you have any triggers that have to do with violence or suicidal thoughts, please skip this one.
2. Spoilers for Canary. Duh.
3. This follows canon pretty up until the reveal in chapter 49 except Marinette and Adrien didn't clear their names in Paris because that was the original plan and this was plotted ages before I decided to change that, whoops
Anyways, enjoy!
Version One: Tongues and Teeth
Summary:
Oh, I will ruin you
Oh, I will ruin you
It's a habit, I can't help it
I know that you mean so well
But I am not a vessel for your good intent
I will only break your pretty things
I will only wring you dry of everything
~~~~~
Marinette Dupain-Cheng stared at Red Robin.
Or should she say Tim Drake? Because the thing he had just said was not something that Red Robin should have known.
He tipped his head to the side, smiling that same awkward smile he always wore whenever he was a little put off by her… less savory tendencies. Because he was put off by them, that she knew. She could see it in the slight tension in his shoulders whenever she mentioned a tragedy too casually, or the hesitation in his voice whenever she mentioned something from her ‘job’.
He was put off by Canary. But he liked Marinette.
She breathed out a sigh and slowly brought her hands up to cup his cheeks.
“You’re…” She started, only for her voice to catch in her throat.
She felt stupid. She felt stupid, and angry, and relieved all at once.
She gently tugged at his domino. He winced just slightly – whether it was because he had realized his mistake or a reflexive reaction to having someone touch his mask, she didn’t know nor care. She was allowed to pull it away from his face, revealing the startlingly blue eyes that she had fallen for.
“Are you disappointed?” He asked, his gaze flicking away to stare at the sky in an attempt to hide the nerves tinging his cheeks red.
No.
Yes.
She bit her lip. “Our jobs…”
“Are just our jobs. No one should be on the clock at all hours.”
Tears welled in her eyes.
“Everyone around me gets hurt eventually,” she warned.
But Tim just grinned. “You’re worth it.”
Wrong answer, she thought, looking up at him through her lashes. Eyes were the window to the soul, but she was wearing colored contacts and Tim’s domino mask tinted his vision with the color rose.
What a terrible pair they made.
Canary slid her hands into his hair and pulled Tim in for a kiss.
Tim wasn’t Red Robin. This, she realized, was why he was so comfortable kissing Marinette back. Red Robin, for him, was nothing more than a part he played to keep the city safe. Tim was emotional and prone to lashing out when hurt and Red Robin was stoic and paranoid. They were not the same.
Marinette and Canary, however, were less easy to separate.
It was unfortunate that Canary was a part of Marinette. Deep down, she knew this to be true. Canary was a fully fleshed out character, with her own specific behaviors and choices… but all acts needed a little bit of truth to make them work. Canary was her anger, given a name, made to be more than just the fire burning beneath her skin that always screamed for more. Canary was the part of Marinette that didn’t bat an eye at murder no matter whether she was a bystander or the one doing it, the part that hesitated to trust anyone, the part that needed to get revenge on anyone that had ever wronged her.
The part that put survival above all else.
And it was unfortunate that Marinette was a part of Canary. Because it made surviving difficult at times.
Marinette held the device in her hands in a death grip.
Canary handed it over when asked.
“This is the feed from a tracker on Red Robin. He spends all of his time at Wayne Manor and Wayne Enterprises. He’s Tim Drake. The bats are all Waynes or close family friends of them.”
Cobblepot watched the tiny red dot on the screen for a moment before setting it down on the table in front of him. Even though the sound of the metal touching the mahogany was quiet, it echoed around the empty, soundproofed room with ease.
He pulled his phone from his pocket and started typing.
Her gaze fell on the tiny dot currently at Wayne Manor. Tim was probably sleeping, or eating, or playing a video game… blissfully unaware that his new girlfriend had betrayed him so thoroughly.
Her phone dinged in her pocket. Not the familiar sound that meant money was entering her account that usually came when finishing a job – god, how she missed that sound, how she missed normal jobs – but the sound indicating that someone she followed on Twitter had posted something.
Not unexpected… outside of the fact that Cobblepot had used something as informal as Twitter to announce ‘his’ findings.
Tikki was still and quiet in her pocket. She disapproved, Marinette knew. But she understood.
Or, at least, she would. Eventually.
It was all necessary, after all. The bats knew the risks, her parents were just innocent bystanders.
“Call off your men,” she said.
Cobblepot’s lips curled into something like a sneer as he dialed a number and then brought his phone to his ear.
It didn’t take long for the people on the other side to pick up. It was 22:00 in Paris. Most normal people would be awake.
“Go ahead,” he said simply.
She was still as she watched the man click off his phone.
His eyes lit up with cruel amusement at the face that had gone slack with horror.
“I’ve been thinking about what you said. About how it was dangerous to string you along because, given time, you would find a way to defeat me… and I agree! So, I’m setting you free, little birdie.”
Canary’s hands went to where her knives usually were, but they had been confiscated before she had gone in the room with Cobblepot.
He laughed. He leaned back in his chair, hands on his stomach as his hearty chortle started rising in pitch and volume. As if this was the funniest joke he had ever heard. As if she was a joke.
She slowly rose to her feet.
Calling her parents would be useless. It was 22:00 in Paris. Her parents would be dead asleep (would die asleep), because they were bakers and bakers live on a completely different schedule than normal people did… and no one would ever notice or care. No one would help. Because, as nice as the Dupain-Chengs were, they were Marinette Dupain-Cheng’s parents. One of the two most hated people in Paris. They were dead… or would be soon. And there was nothing she could do about it.
She grit her teeth, the laughter ringing in her ears.
And then her lips pulled upwards, teeth flashing in a horrible grin that split her face into something that looked quite horrifying – inhuman, even.
“You know, Oswald,” she began.
His glee faded slightly, but he still wasn’t scared. Why would he be? She had no weapons. She would have to leave to plan and scheme and work her way to his eventual assassination, which would give him plenty of time to work around her and hire help to make sure no attempts could ever succeed. He had won.
But the use of his first name had thrown him off.
“I think your name really fits you. ‘Oz’. Like the Wizard of Oz. I’m sure you’ve heard the story. A normal man, in over his head, with an empire based on nothing but lies doing his best to maintain an image. A smart man, sure, but a normal one.”
He raised his eyebrows slightly, but it was rude to interrupt a monologue and he clearly was curious as to where she was going with this.
“And, well, Oz,” she said, hopping over the table and perching herself beside him, eyes glimmering with something that wasn’t quite glee. “There’s no place like home, and you just destroyed mine.”
She heard the familiar click of a Swiss Army Knife flicking open.
She leaned until she could rest her elbow on his chair, effectively caging him in on one side.
“And, just like that other ‘Oz’, you’re a normal man,” she said, her tone a lazy drawl, as if she had all the time in the world.
A knife found its place between her third and fourth ribs.
She took the hand twisting the knife and slowly pulled it out.
But she didn’t keel over. Barely even coughed.
Cobblepot’s eyes widened just slightly as she dragged his hand up and away, far too strong for someone that should have been bleeding out, until the knife was pressed against his own throat.
Blood dribbled from the corner of her mouth and, when she smiled again, her teeth were stained red. Canary didn’t seem to mind, though.
She leaned in close. In the dim light of the room, dark eyes gleamed with something that wasn’t quite human.
“But let me tell you a secret: I’m not.”
~
They were too late.
Canary didn’t look up as Adrien and Emma approached her. Even when Adrien caught sight of the body she was currently carving into bits with a Swiss Army Knife and started to retch, and even when Emma purposefully splashed her foot in one of the many pools of blood, she didn’t so much as flinch. They didn’t want to know whether she was ignoring them or just too engrossed in what she was doing to notice.
Emma rested a hand on her shoulder.
She paused. Briefly. Her eyes slowly traveled up his arm to squint at her adoptive mother’s face.
Emma let the hand drop, revealing a black spot on what they had previously assumed to be a pure red bodysuit.
Now, Adrien was actually throwing up. He keeled over next to the table and unloaded his stomach.
Plagg zipped out of his jacket pocket and yelled for ‘Ladybug’ to transform.
She did transform, after a moment’s consideration. Tikki dropped from her earring, and Plagg could only barely catch his fellow kwami. He dragged Tikki away from her. As if that could stop her.
Marinette let it go, though. The kwami looked faint, eyes barely open. She was exhausted.
She looked down at the stab wound that had carved its way into her chest. That was probably why. But it was funny, she didn’t really feel it. Which was unfortunate, she could really use the distraction right about then.
The world did not provide one, but Canary found one anyway in the form of a slowly recovering Adrien.
“I never should have given you the horse miraculous,” she said. Her tone was conversational, the hand that had gone back to cutting open Cobblepot’s corpse was not. “I could have saved them. Things could have been different.”
Adrien didn’t bother asking who ‘them’ was. But his face, previously tinged green, drained of color as he realized what exactly had happened. The Dupain-Chengs were dead, were already being referred to in the past tense. There was no hope left for them.
And then the blood rushed right back to his cheeks, tinging them bright red in his anger. “You could have called me for help!”
She considered this.
A grin cracked across her face. “I guess you’re right. How about you help now, then, instead? This body is heavy.”
~
They pushed the tub into the harbor.
Cobblepot was dead.
This was it.
Tikki sat on her shoulder. She could feel the kwami practically vibrating with excitement.
Canary had achieved her goal.
Cobblepot was dead and gone with no one to mourn him.
She watched red swirl upwards, mixing with the inky blackness of Gotham’s water. They hadn’t taped off the tub properly, it seems.
She had gotten her revenge.
She had watched his eyes widen with fear. Watched him choke on his words, watched him struggle to breathe beneath her hands. Had let him go to watch him scramble away, had listened to him beg.
She was supposed to be done.
She had let him pray to a god he didn’t believe in. She had informed him that he was currently looking at a god, and that they weren’t looking down upon him kindly.
This was supposed to be it.
And yet there Marinette stood. Watching the water. Waiting for the burst of serotonin that came with accomplishing a task, something to tell her she was done.
She found nothing. Years of work, and Marinette felt nothing.
Not even sadness. Or grief. She knew she should be feeling those things, her parents were dead, and yet she couldn’t even feel that.
No. Just…
Nothing.
Marinette swallowed thickly.
She turned back around. Found Adrien, Emma, and Ara. Adrien was looking at his phone, his lips pulled into a thin line – she could see the home page for Twitter reflected in his glasses, and figured he was likely staring at Cobblepot’s tweet again. Ara was watching the water beside her, eyes welling with tears. Emma stood a while away, watching her children with an expression that even Canary struggled to read.
She rested a hand on Ara’s shoulder and pretended she didn’t notice the younger girl’s flinch.
Cobblepot’s downfall had been too quick. That was the problem… probably. Well, she could still spite a dead man, could have the man tossing and turning in his cold, damp grave. Who said the person you were angry at had to be alive for you to continue to be angry at them?
Yeah. That’ll make it better. Revenge was sweet, or so she had heard, and god did she need to get this bitter taste out of her mouth.
“Let’s head back. I need to pick out color swatches for my new lounge.”
Tikki’s excitement faded, the sparkle in her eyes dimming. She looked at Canary for a long time, as if expecting her to laugh and say it was a joke, or maybe she was looking for ‘Marinette’ as she once knew her.
Marinette didn’t have any interest in looking back at the kwami.
Emma sighed. “No rest for the wicked, I see.”
“Yeah, maybe, but I’m thinking maybe I should get into a new kind of wicked,” she said, bringing her free hand up to cradle her chin. “I’m getting too old for the whole ‘informant’ thing, I think I’ll upgrade to being an actual mob boss.”
“As long as you’re paying,” Ara said, though she still wouldn’t meet her eyes.
“Of course, I’m not Cobblepot.”
~
She looked around the Iceberg Lounge, blue eyes more striking than usual when compared with the splash of dark red on her cheek.
She twirled the key around her index finger.
The Lounge was hers, now. The bats would be too busy doing damage control for the next few weeks (before they inevitably gave up, because they would have to be stupid not to) to look into the building that had come into her blood-stained hands.
“I’m thinking I’ll just do red. Easier to hide blood that way,” Canary said.
Edward grinned. “This is your one chance to rebrand and you still refuse to do it?”
“Don’t talk to me, Mr. Neon-Colors-Will-Definitely-Come-Back.”
“They never left!”
She grinned at him before turning to Jonathan. The ex-therapist was watching the both of them with an odd expression that she couldn’t quite interpret.
“What do you think?” She prompted.
“About neon colors or you choosing red?”
“Either or.”
“I think red suits you,” he said after a moment’s thought, as if it were something profound.
She gave him an odd look. “I’ve been wearing it for years.”
“It suited you in a different way then.”
She stared for a moment, her eyebrows furrowing.
She turned to Edward. “He’s been spending too much time with you.”
~
Tim found her in the alley behind the lounge.
Not that she had been hiding, exactly. If she was, she would have tried harder to keep her involvement in revealing their identities a secret or, at the very least, she would have chosen a less visible casino to run.
But he hadn’t wanted to find her as Canary. He wanted to find ‘Marinette’.
She leaned back against the wall, eyes on the stars stretching above her as she smoked a cigarette.
“Why?”
Unlike the first day Red Robin had confronted Marinette in an alley, she didn’t turn around when he made a sound.
“I told you that everyone around me ends up getting hurt.”
“Why?” He repeated, unwilling to accept it.
Marinette swallowed thickly.
It would be so easy to tell him the truth, it would be so easy to manipulate him. He was practically begging for her to do so, to give him a good reason why she had done what she had done, to give him any reason to forgive her.
“You need to leave,” Marinette said instead. “Get away. Go anywhere but here. You’re not safe here anymore.”
Because of her.
“I just wanted to help,” he said, and his voice was strained with the effort to hold back tears. “I still want to help.”
What a sorry sight. Two people that had never fully broken up – that debatably should have never dated in the first place – still holding on to some sort of hope when they couldn’t hold on to each other. Some sort of hope that he would leave the city he cared about so much for his own safety, some sort of hope that she would finally allow someone in.
What a terrible pair they made.
“You can't.”
A hand grabbed hers.
He gently tugged on her, trying to get her to so much as look at him.
Marinette wasn’t going to.
She couldn’t.
He was definitely crying now. She could hear the start of the telltale hiccuping breaths, the slight sniffles, the slight scraping as he brought his hand up to wipe away the tears rolling under his mask.
“I thought you cared.”
“I do, Tim,” she said against her better judgment. Because Marinette did care, and she didn’t want him to think otherwise. She wasn’t honeypotting him, this had just been an unfortunate happenstance. “You’re the closest I’ve ever gotten to ‘true love’.”
His breath caught.
She tugged her hand from his.
“You just weren’t close enough.”
She let the metal door to the Lounge slam shut behind her.
~
The first bat to fall had been Stephanie Brown. Someone had gone to the dojo she worked at under the guise of being a customer and had proceeded to stab her during what should have been a regular sparring match.
This had happened four months and three days after the day Cobblepot had tweeted their identities.
The other bats were still in Gotham as well, going about their daily lives as if their identities hadn’t been exposed to the entire world.
Marinette had stared at the headline for a good thirty minutes in silence.
They should have left.
Why had they chosen to stay?
Marinette shook her head and pressed the end of her cigarette to the paper. Smoke joined the wisps spilling from between parted lips, the fire blacking out the woman’s face, and then flames spread along the page. She tossed it into her trash can, allowing the flames to eat away at the memory of the person she had once sought out every time Rogues held family functions.
Maybe this was the wakeup call that the bats had needed. Maybe they would leave now.
They had to, right?
~
Dick paid her a visit. Strode right into her casino as if the bright blue on his suit wasn’t an eyesore compared to the deep reds and blacks of the building.
She leaned back on her hands, crossing her legs lazily.
Canary motioned, vaguely, with her head for him to sit at one of the barstools beside her.
He did so, however reluctantly.
“What would you like to drink?” Emma asked, carefully tilting her head to hide her face among her hair.
He raised an eyebrow.
Canary smiled at him. “It’s on the house, promise.”
“... water,” he said after a moment.
“Boring,” she teased, but she told Emma to get it for him anyways.
The sound of the glass being set on the hard wood of the counter was deafening.
She smiled at Emma and waved her off, leaving the two of them alone at the bar. The next closest person was at a table a good twenty feet away, so she didn’t bother keeping her voice down:
“Something I can do for you? I should warn you now, though: the prices of my services are a little steeper than you might remember them being.”
“I’m not here for a job,” he said, his voice so low and cold it was practically a growl.
As if to directly contrast him, her own tone was high and bright as a bird’s chirp. “Oh? Here for a fight, then?”
He glared at her over his untouched water.
She met his gaze and, though her expression didn’t change, the affection bled from her face between blinks as she allowed her facade to slip away. Canary could do that with Nightwing, for he was just as bad as her. He knew just how easy it was to turn looks of contempt into those lined with love, knew that a smile could be just as cold and unsettling as a glare, knew it was easier to get things from those who thought you their friend than those who knew you were their enemy… and she was more than willing to let all of those pretenses go, if only for a moment.
In turn, he rested his chin in his hands and looked up at her with a bored expression.
“You’re the reason my family is dead.”
“Debatable,” she said nonchalantly. She pulled a cigarette box from her pocket and shook one out. “You should have left while you had the chance,” she said. She brought the cigarette to her lips and lit it. Her eyes darted to him as she put the lighter and box away, and when she exhaled the words “You still can.” lingered in the air in the same way the smoke did.
“We can’t leave,” Dick gritted out. “Not when the city still needs us.”
“That’s noble of you. I’ll be sure to cry more at your funeral.”
“You won’t be invited.”
She snickered. “Wouldn’t be anything new,” she said easily.
Only for him to reach down and pull a notecard out of who knows where and throw it down on the counter.
She picked it up, an eyebrow quirked, and then almost dropped it when she recognized the address line.
He pushed himself out of his seat. “She liked you. God knows why, but she did. She would have killed me if I didn’t at least tell you where she was.”
And, just like that, he left Marinette alone.
~
Marinette sat at the grave, fingers entwined in the fresh dirt with a strange kind of desperation. As if she would float away and join Steph as a ghost if she dared to let go.
Maybe this was the way things had had to go. If Tim was Marinette if she had been found by a better role model, Steph was Marinette if she had chosen to rebuff Riddler’s influence – or, even more, had chosen to go to Batman for help instead of him. Steph was proof that Marinette had had a choice.
She had simply made the wrong one.
So, maybe it was fitting that Steph was the one to face the consequences of her actions. Steph and Marinette were mirrors of each other, perfectly identical and yet undeniably backwards, so maybe Steph was the Canary in this scenario. Gas had leaked, the canary had stopped singing, and it was time for the miners to get out of there as quickly as possible before they ended up just as dead as the bird.
The miners just had to… listen to the warning.
She took a shaky breath in and then untangled herself from the dirt to pull herself to her feet. She tried not to think about how Steph would never be able to do the same. She forced herself to wipe at the dried tears that stuck to her cheeks, smearing dirt over her skin.
She wasn’t sure when she had started crying, but she had long-since stopped, for she had company.
She turned to face the person that had been standing there, watching, for the last five minutes.
Adrien looked as if he had seen a ghost.
Maybe he thought he had. She looked deathly pale in comparison to the dark dirt sticking to her face and hands. And, with how much was caked under her fingernails, she must have looked like she had clawed her way out of a coffin.
But wasn’t that what Canary did, anyways? Survived at all costs, even when she had nothing to truly live for anymore? Made sure that, no matter how much kicking and screaming it took, she would continue on to struggle for at least one more day?
She had always been a dead girl walking, maybe it was time she actually looked the part.
Her lips pulled back from her skull in a skeleton’s smile. “Adrien! Hi.”
He seemed to finally steel himself enough to rush forward. She stayed unflinching. He might hurt her, but he wasn’t going to kill her. That wasn’t his style.
And, indeed, he did nothing more than grab her by the collar of her shirt and lift, forcing her to look into his eyes.
The first thing she noticed was that they were rimmed red.
“Ah. I see. Skipping the pleasantries, then,” she said, her voice determinedly even. As if Marinette hadn’t just been choking on her own tears. As if they weren’t standing on the grave of her old friend.
“Shut up!” He snapped. “I trusted you!”
“A horrible decision, really.”
His grip tightened on her collar. Her neck started to ache where his knuckles pressed against her skin. She didn’t know if he could tell – tears were welling in his eyes, which would definitely make it hard for him to see that he was only a step away from strangling her.
“You said that they would leave! You said no one would die!”
His words echoed across the empty graveyard, thudding against her on all sides until Marinette felt, somehow, even more constricted than before. It was strange. Her throat was tight, and yet he still hadn’t committed to wrapping his hands around her neck.
Which is why it was even stranger when Marinette felt as if she was choking on her words when she said, “Yeah, well, I didn’t think it was going to go this way either.”
His grip loosened and then fell away, but Marinette’s breathing remained ragged.
“Do you think I just wanted to put the guy I had a crush on in danger? Fuck off, Adrien. Even I’m not that awful.”
He sighed and backed up a step, the tears that had been welling in his eyes beginning to fall. “We have to help them.”
“How?” She snapped. “Give them miraculous? Not when they’re currently pissed as hell at us. Make them leave? They’ll just come back, Nightwing made that abundantly clear when he came to visit the other day.”
“We could watch over them,” he said, and she could tell that even he knew he sounded desperate.
She almost laughed. “Please, Adrien, even if they would let us – which they wouldn’t – there’s like seven hundred of them and two of us.”
Tears rolled down Marinette’s face to match his, cutting lines through the dirt on her cheeks.
She was annoyed. Annoyed that Adrien hadn’t thought that she’d already gone through all of this in her mind as it became more and more clear that the bats weren’t skipping town. Annoyed that the bats were too stubborn to give up.
Didn’t they want to survive?
… she wasn’t sure whether she wanted that answer.
She took a step back from him as well so she could lean against the gravestone. It was nice, but it had already been defaced in the three days since Steph had been buried.
It was silent as the pair looked down at the way that the name ‘Stephanie Brown’ had been coated in purple spray paint and then written over as ‘Spoiler’ in yellow.
It was the kind of thing that Steph would have found funny, for impossible to understand reasons, and that just made her chest ache all the more.
Adrien groaned and threw his hands up, frustration and surrender and sadness all rolled into one quick motion.
Marinette closed her eyes.
“I didn’t sign up for this!”
Her eyes snapped open.
This was, in all technicality, Adrien’s first real murder. He had played a large part in giving Marinette the tech needed to pinpoint the bats. Their blood was on his hands as well. And, as much as Canary would deny it, she still remembered how awful she had felt when she had killed someone for the first time.
She remembered the way that Marinette had stood over the body long after it had gone still. Had etched the corpse of what had once been her friend into her mind's eye. She had beaten his chest in with the crowbar, as Cobblepot had told her to. It had been for the sake of her own survival, he had been the unfortunate first person to take the fall for her. And even then he had been begging for togetherness. He promised that they could leave together, figure this all out together, that they were supposed to be together. His yells echoed in her mind even years later, but never had they been so loud as in the moment after he had gone still. And, in that moment, she swore that that was all she would ever hear. She thought that she would remain just as motionless as his body, remain staring at him until the cops inevitably came and then continue clutching the crowbar until it was forced from her grip. Some not-so-small part of her wanted to stay there and wait for death to take her, too.
But, then, Marinette had been forced to turn away from the body to throw up. She had actually eaten the day before, paid for by Riddler, and somehow that made throwing up even worse. Now she actually had something to lose.
Having something to live for was amazing, right up until the moment it’s gone.
She couldn’t afford to lose anything else.
She had forced herself to keep moving.
Adrien didn’t look like he was going to be able to do the same. He looked like he wanted to bury himself in the dirt with Steph, looked like he might actually follow through with that idea.
She shoved her hands in her pockets. Kicked a chunk of rock that she thought might have once been a part of a gravestone. It hit his leg, forcing him back to reality.
Adrien ran a hand through his hair, tugged at the roots as if he was tempted to pull his brain out and throw it on the ground like a morbid offering for the deceased.
He said “I didn’t sign up for this.” again, his tone little more than a whisper that he allowed to get carried away by the breeze.
But she heard – just as she seemed to hear everything, just as all information in Gotham always seemed to find its way back to her eventually.
She sighed.
“If you want out of the game, Chaton, I’m more than willing to take you out.”
His shoulders slumped in slight relief.
If only he could see the way Tikki clawed at her hand in her pocket, desperate to free herself so she could warn him of what was to come.
Adrien thought he knew Ladybug. Thought that he knew Marinette. And maybe he did.
But he didn’t know Canary.
He didn’t know that Canary never allowed for loose ends.
This was what she thought as she carefully knotted the rope in her hands. The hotel room was dark, save for the dim blue light of the computer on Adrien’s lap, casting a ghostly glow over his face.
Canary didn’t allow for loose ends, so it was fitting that she chose to hang him by his own rope.
The moment the rope closed over his neck, the air left his throat in a wheezing cough and he was stuck desperately writhing. His chest rose and fell as if he was trying to force his lungs to breathe in air that refused to get past the rope crushing his windpipe.
The ring on his finger lay useless even as Plagg zoomed around, finding a place on her neck – still tender hours after Adrien’s near-strangling of her – to sink his jagged teeth into. He couldn’t call to transform with his voice dying in his throat just as much as he was.
She had critiqued his ability to fight that day he found her at the police station. For once, she was glad that someone had opted not to take one of her insults too much to heart.
He looked up at her. Marinette refused to look directly at him, not wanting to see the fear or betrayal there. Refused to read the lips that were desperately trying to tell her something.
Life bled out of him. His struggles became weaker and weaker. His eyelids began to droop.
Her ears ached with a high whining that made her want to let go so she could cover her ears. Everything ached in a strange way that made her body feel ridiculously heavy. For a moment, she started to fear that killing him would kill her, too.
He went slack.
His chest stopped moving.
It all stopped. There was a snapping feeling in her chest and she found herself able to breathe again.
She tied the rope tight around his neck to make sure Adrien wouldn’t be able to do the same.
She set him back down against the bed and pulled the ring from his finger.
Plagg let go of her neck instantly.
Marinette stared down at the ring in her hand. Even just holding it with her earrings on was deathly tempting. She could fix all of this. Go back in time. To when everything was simpler. Before she had made the decision to screw over the bats, or even back to the start so she could choose not to become Canary in the first place.
(Who would she be if she had never become Canary? If she had never become Ladybug?)
But Tikki’s old whispers of karma came back to her, her voice clear in her mind even though she hadn’t heard the kwami speak in what felt like years.
Canary had never liked making decisions without knowing all the facts. She didn’t know what karma would take from her, but she wasn’t going to take that sort of chance.
She wrapped the ring in a hotel towel and then stuffed it in her pocket.
Then, she turned to Adrien.
It was rough work, stuffing him into a tub not unlike the one they had all thrown Cobblepot into. Cobblepot had been in pieces already, so there hadn’t been a lot to lift. Adrien was lanky and yet somehow also insanely heavy. He almost refused to fit, stubborn even in death.
But she had experience getting rid of bodies, so eventually she managed to slam the lid down and tape it shut. She made sure to wrap it until her entire roll of ducktape had been used up.
There. That should keep him firmly trapped while he was shipped off to France.
She didn’t know what would happen when he got there. Didn’t know who would find him, nor what they would do to him once they did.
Maybe he wouldn’t have to deal with it, thought Marinette. Maybe all of the miraculous magic would be gone by then and he would suffocate in the tub by the time he reached the mainland. Maybe he would never have to deal with the atrocities that the angry citizens of Paris would do to his body once they figured out who he was.
But, at least, he wouldn’t be her problem anymore.
She didn’t care either way.
She didn’t.
~
It took hours for her to find the pocket dimension Adrien had stuffed his miraculous box into. Hours of murmuring the same words with slight variations, of peeking into every crevice of hundreds of pocket dimensions, of checking out anything and everything that might have had the miraculous box hidden inside…
Eventually, she came across a shoebox.
She had absently kicked it open, already preparing to hop out and try the next, only for a bunch of jewelry pieces to tumble out.
Maybe, had Marinette not been so drained, she would have wondered why a shoe box of all things… but, instead, she just scooped all of the miraculous back into the box and left.
Now, she sat on the counter of one of her safehouses. She forced herself to focus on making chocolate chip cookie dough. She acted like it was the most difficult thing in the world – and, indeed, some tiny part of her ached for her parents to be over her shoulder critiquing her for stirring counterclockwise instead of clockwise (it didn’t matter, but they insisted it was strange) – but, in actuality, she was just doing all of this to ignore the many tiny eyes boreing into her.
The kwamis were not happy. Plagg had disappeared into the fridge about an hour previously and had yet to reemerge. Tikki sat still and heavy in her pocket, still and quiet and heavy as a rock. The rest poked their heads out from the shoebox to glare at her.
She had told them to quiet, to sit still and stop trying to run away, but now the silence was starting to get suffocating.
She stirred harder, relishing in the quiet thumping of her spoon scraping against the side of the bowl with every turn. It wasn’t a good sound, but at least it was a sound.
A sound that was eventually forced to stop so she could set the dough on the tray and pop it into the oven.
Which left them with nothing except for the dull thrum of the old appliances.
“I had to. He knew too much.”
Never had a silence been so loud.
~
The kwamis had been hard to ignore, but at least she could force them to leave her sight.
Edward Nygma and Jonathan Crane, however, had no ‘off button’.
They had found out about Adrien. Maybe she should have tried more to hide the fact that she was involved in his murder, but in the end she had decided it was merely delaying the inevitable – Edward wasn’t the type to leave a mystery unsolved, and Jonathan would gas the entire city until he found the culprit.
So, she had laid back and waited for them to figure it out.
Now, they were at her safehouse and they were more than pissed. Edward’s anger had always been explosive, full of high cries and insults and the occasional threat, and all of the man’s normal eloquence fell away until he was red in the face and cursing everything under the sun. Jonathan’s anger came in a more quiet form, something cold and calculated, as if he was waiting for the exact right moment to get his revenge. Neither of them were fun to deal with when peeved off, but they were even worse when angry together because the full contrast pushed down on her on all sides.
She watched Edward pace back and forth, the long green trench coat he loved flapping with every exaggerated hand motion.
“– don’t even have a good reason!” He yelled, his fists clenched as if he was seriously considering punching her.
She raised an eyebrow at him. “I happen to think it was a very good reason, thank you.”
“I. Was. Not. Done. Talking,” Edward gritted out.
She rolled her eyes and fought back the childish reply of ‘well, I was done listening’ that threatened to bubble out of her throat.
“I thought you two cared about each other! How could you just do that?!”
She opened her mouth to respond, to explain herself once again, but he cut Marinette off with a glare.
And then something seemed to dawn on him. His hands fell to his sides. He stared at her. “Would you do the same to us?”
She didn’t even know what to say. A part of her screamed no, screamed that Adrien was different because she could just force herself to think about Chat Blanc and disassociate her way through murdering him… but another part of her knew that this wasn’t completely true. Even if it made her sick to think about, she knew herself better than anyone else ever could, and she knew that she would follow through if she really thought them a threat.
Adrien would never hurt her directly, but he had always been frustratingly loose-lipped. Had always been ready to join a cause if there was a smiling face and a warm hug telling him to. She didn’t want to risk it.
As for Jonathan and Edward… well, they were all Rogues. They weren’t going to be winning any ‘best friend’ awards.
Edward took her silence for the confirmation it was and his expression twisted further.
He crossed his arms over his chest. “You remember what happened between Oswald and I, yes?”
She stiffened. Of course she remembered. It was the reason Edward had been just as determined to take the man down as she was at the beginning of her time as his personal informant, though she didn’t learn about their more intimate relationship until many years later.
But, the story went that the two of them had been unofficially dating for a while, neither willing to commit… maybe that wasn’t necessary, anyways. They did things for each other, with each other, and to each other. They were in love, as much as two Rogues could ever be. A label might not have been something worth caring about… and then Edward had found a woman that liked riddles as much as he had. He had loved her, too. And Cobblepot, the personification of greed, had never taken well to not getting what he wanted. He had killed her in a fit of rage.
She thought she might have understood the feeling, though she didn’t like what that pointed to. In that moment, anger burned under her skin, threatening to consume her in the flames. And part of her relished in the idea of letting it do so.
“Do not compare me to him.”
She understood. She knew what Edward was trying to say, she knew he was implying that he would invoke the same kind of vengeance that he had with Cobblepot. That he would now be working to make her life a living hell. He wouldn’t kill her, Rogues never really bothered with killing each other over fights because they all knew that fights were simply their state of being. He would simply make her regret ever crossing him in whatever way he felt fit.
But that wasn’t what Marinette cared about right then, surprisingly, because all she could think about was how the man that had once saved her from Cobblepot was now comparing her to the man that had ruined their lives.
His jaw set. He knew he had crossed a line, but she had done so first. Now, they were standing directly in front of each other, daring the other to make the first move. To back off and apologize, to try and meet each other on the other side, to walk away entirely.
Edward was the first to do something. He turned and walked right out of the apartment.
She watched the green of his jacket get pulled out of sight. Heard the door slam behind him, so hard that it rattled the complex.
She knew that he wouldn’t kill her, he would prefer to watch as she suffered, and she wasn’t going to kill him. Not necessarily out of love for the man, but because she wasn’t completely sure she could. He was smarter than Adrien, had known Canary for as long as she had existed, and he would know better than to make himself an easy target. He had money, power, and the ability to leverage it.
She ran a hand through her hair. The rough fabric of her gloves scraped against her scalp. She closed her eyes.
Well, it wasn’t like she hadn’t expected that.
Marinette exhaled slowly, one long sigh, and then forced herself to look at Jonathan.
“So, you going to go, too, or…?”
The man looked at her. His expression was still icy, but he was still firm when he said, “No.”
~
She knew that her gloves threw people off. It wasn’t particularly uncommon to see henchmen wearing them, for they couldn’t afford to get caught by the police, but a Rogue was expected to be out and proud about who they were. And, even if they did wear gloves, it was solely for show. Solely an aesthetic choice – and, as committed as Rogues often were to their aesthetics, they were all willing to take off their gloves when push came to shove.
Well… all of them were willing, except for one.
Now, as Canary rested her hand on her cheek, sure to leave a red handprint thanks to the man she had just gutted for snitching on her current plans to Riddler… she couldn’t help but remember one of the more popular theories:
That she did it to hide the fact that her hands were permanently stained with blood.
When she had first seen the theory in her Twitter feed, she had merely scoffed. There were many reasons for her to wear gloves – touch aversion, identity reasons, and an homage to her time as a henchman to name a few – but none were quite so dramatic as that.
But, now, as Marinette peeled her hand away and fought back a grimace when her gloves tried to stick to her skin… she couldn’t help but wonder if they had had a point.
She pushed herself up in her chair and turned her head to look at Emma. The woman stood on her right, with Ara beside her.
They were her right hand men… but, considering what had happened to her last partner, this wasn’t a particularly good position to be in.
But Emma refused to leave, and Ara had nowhere else to be, so in that position they stayed.
She grinned, waving them off. “You guys can go home early. I can deal with one measly rat.”
Emma hesitated.
Ara made the decision for her, grabbing the woman by the hand and dragging her away to the locker rooms.
Canary turned back to the man.
He lay, writhing on the floor. His skin was remarkably pale, though she didn’t know whether that was because he was bleeding out or if it was the general shock of having your organs outside your body.
She knew there were far easier and more accurate ways to get information – confessions – out of people, but she wasn’t particularly concerned with that. Canary had already known what was going on, she had just been concerned with the message.
He was still alive, but only just.
She twirled her hand and a knife slipped from her sleeve, finding its place in her palm.
It was time to fix that.
~
She raised her eyebrows when she saw all of the kwamis glaring at her. This wasn’t particularly new, but the signs they were holding were.
Apparently, they were going on strike. They wouldn’t be eating, which meant that she wouldn’t be able to use their powers.
Nevermind the fact that she could make them eat with a few simple words.
Instead of pointing this out, though, she just laughed in their tiny faces and brushed past them.
“I haven’t used you guys’ help in years, why would I start now? I don’t need your powers, I’m only holding on to you so no one else can.”
Marinette didn’t look back.
Because looking back would mean seeing Tikki with her own sign.
She knew the kwami didn’t approve – the kwami never had – but it still felt like a betrayal.
Not that she would ever give the kwamis the satisfaction of knowing she thought this.
No, she would adapt. Just like she adapted to everything.
~
The silence was killing her.
Her life had never been a quiet one. Her parents were soft, but not particularly soft spoken, and they had always filled the house with the sounds of pots and pans and laughter. At school, she had friends. In Gotham, she had had her fellow henchmen. And then she was a Rogue, and a Rogue’s life was almost too loud, especially when the Rogue in question had befriended Scarecrow and Riddler.
But, now, Marinette didn’t have any of that. Her parents were dead and gone. Her friends from school hated her for something that she had been manipulated into. Adrien had died by her own hand. Emma and Ara were scared – they cared, but that didn’t mean that they didn’t shiver minutely under her watchful eye or determinedly look away when she got down to business. Edward hated her. Jonathan wasn’t intent on leaving her but he wasn’t particularly happy with her, either, and avoided her more often than he sought her out.
And where did that leave Marinette?
Part of her wanted to release the kwamis’ voices. Even if they would berate her, at least there would be something to hear.
But Marinette couldn’t bring herself to listen to Tikki’s disappointment, so instead she found the best alternative she could get:
Talking to herself.
It was an old habit. Leftover from years of having a kwami hovering on her every word for the call to action that was ‘spots on!’ (or even just because the kwami was fond of her holder, but that hadn’t been the case in years). But, she had noticed, as her words curled around her tongue and her own voice hit her ears, there was a strange sense of relief.
It was her own voice, but it was still a voice. And she could make it say whatever she wanted to without having to worry about the emotions that came with forcing others to speak.
~
She rested her chin on her arms, one of the many, many people watching the sky that night. A large, purple blimp took up what felt like the entire sky, a large screen affixed to the side displaying something that was somehow both expected and completely out of nowhere:
It was Bruce Wayne, sitting in a chair. His head lolled just slightly, but it had been pointed carefully at the camera nonetheless to show off the bright red paint carving a large crescent from cheek to cheek. There was a gun sticking out of the side of his head and, poking out the other side, was a tiny flag with the word BANG! emblazoned across it – it looked like a goofy little headband you might find in a gag store, but the red dripping from the pointed end of the flagpole and blank look in the man’s eyes screamed that it was real.
And all that anyone could hear was his killer’s horrible, high-pitched laughter as he celebrated a war finally won.
It had been inevitable. Every Gothamite had known for years that the bat’s life would end at the hands of the Joker, that eventually the No Kill Rule that Batman preached would one day be his undoing… for how can you truly win when your opponent can keep coming back? When your opponent was not extending the same courtesy to you?
Bruce’s lifeless eyes bore into the camera, and she couldn’t help but peer into them. There was no stress lines on his face, they had slackened in death, and there was no hint of anger on the body… but she couldn’t help but wonder if it had been on purpose. Whether it had been the kind of self-destructive recklessness that he had once exhibited upon Jason Todd’s death that had finally done him in…
And, if so, what Jason would think.
The laughter petered out. Slowly but surely.
And, for a long moment it was completely silent, save for Joker’s ragged breaths.
She thought he was just out of breath at first (how could he not be after all that laughing?) but then the breaths got quicker. And quicker. She listened intently for something – footsteps, another voice, the sound of a door opening or a bat screaming bloody revenge – but there was no indication that the man was anything but alone.
Maybe it had finally dawned on him. That, with the bat gone, he no longer had any purpose.
Canary understood the feeling.
She heard a click, so much quieter than anything else that the blimp had blared but still deafening, and she couldn’t bring herself to look away as a gunshot rang through the air.
A body crashed into the camera, and the screen rolled across the floor a few times before coming to a stop on its side. An unnaturally pale hand stayed stubbornly in frame, perfectly still. Red began to creep in.
And it was silent.
~
As if to make up for the silence, the next morning was so loud that she considered finding some headphones to block out sound so she could fall back asleep.
It wasn’t like there was much reason to get up today, anyways. No one good was going to be out.
Batman had been an important figure, but Bruce Wayne had been vital.
Without him… well, the city was quickly falling to chaos.
Everyone in the city knew that the place was corrupt, that Bruce Wayne was the only pillar holding Gotham up. That even if his kids continued to try and help the city, they were grieving and unable to leave the house under threat of death – they would ultimately not be of much use.
Marinette said her silent goodbyes to welfare systems, to charity donations, to the city’s last hope. To the many who would die desperate and hungry and alone, to the many that would be killed by the aforementioned people.
And to Bruce Wayne. Though she would never admit to this one.
No, Marinette would much rather cover her ears with a pillow and pretend to not hear all the screaming and fires and gunshots.
~
She didn’t know the exact day when Cass and Babs disappeared.
There was nothing in the papers, no acknowledgement of the women and their lives or even acknowledgments of their deaths. There were no bodies, no graves to mourn over.
They had simply disappeared. Leaving behind nothing but shadows that felt less whole and stationary security cameras.
Marinette hoped that this was someone finally taking her advice. Finally, some bats were skipping town.
But, since she knew the women weren’t the type to leave a city in need, she opted not to look into it. Opted to continue thinking that they were simply gone, out living their cottagecore dreams somewhere far away from – far better than – Gotham.
~
Marinette swirled a drink in her hands. The best part about owning what had once been the Iceberg Lounge was that alcohol was never far.
Jonathan leaned back against the counter, his head tilted back. He stared at the ceiling as if he was looking for answers among the red velvet draperies.
Or, maybe, he was looking for a familiar shadow.
“I can’t believe Black Bat is…” He started, only to trail off. As if saying the word aloud would suddenly make it true.
She nodded her agreement. Even if she was going to pretend to think the woman was fine, she was willing to entertain the thought of her being gone if had had enough alcohol to take down a bull.
“She was supposed to be invincible,” she sighed.
Though Marinette was obviously not all that happy about the fact that two more people she had once considered friends were gone, Cass’s death meant a lot more symbolically. Because Black Bat was easily the best fighter in the entire family, and if she could go down then the rest of them were definitely on their way out.
Jonathan closed his eyes. “She was so smart.”
“Of course you would think that, she’s like…” She trailed off, her muddied mind struggling to explain it. “An expert in your field.”
Despite the fact that she had nodded to herself as if to confirm that the words made sense, Jonathan made a questioning noise. She huffed and mulled it over for a moment.
“Well… first time I met her, right? I’d heard about her whole… ‘mind-read-y’ thing.”
“Obviously.”
“Obviously. Everyone knows,” she agreed. “And, so, I had to be all smug about it and question her on it.”
He snorted. “Yeah, that sounds like you.”
“‘Cause it was,” she said, nodding once more. “And so I go and I say: ‘think you’re so good? Tell me about myself’.”
Jonathan grinned over at her. “Oh? That was stupid.”
“I just wanted to see,” she complained, her voice a whine that did not at all fit the rumors that floated around her like the ghosts that she left in her wake. “But, anyways, she looks me dead in the eye and she says ‘scared’. She just knew. Looked at me and saw exactly what I was.”
He makes a thoughtful noise, his eyes returning to the ceiling. “Was this before or after I did the same thing?”
“Before,” she sighed. “It’s why I was so quick with a response on yours, with the whole ‘Got that much faith in yourself?’ thing.”
His lips twitched. “Aw. You did that thing where you think about how you should have won an argument in the shower afterwards.”
“Fuck off,” she mumbled, pushing his shoulder until he gave in and fell off the barstool.
He stayed on the floor, pulling his knee to his chest and turning his gaze onto her. He seemed to be looking for something in her face, but she didn’t know whether he found it.
“Can’t believe everyone thinks you’re greedy,” said Jonathan. “It’s so obvious you’re just scared.”
She blushed and looked down at her drink. Maybe it was the influence of said drink that prompted her to say, “Well, you never would have taken an interest in me if I was anything else.”
He hummed his agreement. His head tipped to the side. All traces of a smile left his expression. “It’s less fun now that I’m attached.”
She shrugged and brought the drink to her lips.
“You’re destroying yourself, I hope you know.”
Marinette’s hand shook ever so slightly as she lowered the empty glass back to the counter. Smiled as best she could. “Destroying myself? I’ll survive anything, that’s kind of my thing.”
He wasn’t having it, for once. “You and I both know that’s not what I meant.”
Marinette couldn’t bring herself to disagree. All she could do was pour herself another glass.
~
She could survive anything.
Jonathan, however, could not.
Marinette stared at the phone in her hands, the hospital’s number still bright white on her screen. The nurse was trying to talk to her, but she couldn’t make out a word they were saying.
Honestly, when you’re semi-immortal, it is sometimes hard to remember that those around you get older.
And getting older was never a good thing in their line of work. Not for people that had many enemies, many people with grudges just waiting for an opportunity for revenge.
It had been inevitable.
She hadn’t been ready.
She clicked the end call button. Buried her face in her hands. Many thoughts ran through her head that night, but only one repeated itself in Marinette’s head like a mantra:
She was his emergency contact.
~
Duke Thomas was dead.
That was what the headline had said.
Marinette couldn’t bring herself to read past that. Couldn’t even bring herself to flip to the crossword, because Duke loved puzzles and doing them when he couldn’t felt like a disservice. So, she had simply tossed it out the window to join all of the rest of the trash that littered the streets nowadays.
(And wasn’t that funny? Litter, in Gotham? That’s how you know the city had gone to shit, because no one was scared of Poison Ivy anymore. They were all going to die, at least the woman might make it quick for them.)
She shut the window quickly to keep as much of the stench out as possible, and wondered if the bats still believed in the inherent goodness of people.
She had always thought that ideology flawed.
Marinette didn’t know how she felt about the fact that she had played a direct hand in making them realize that, though.
~
No time was safe in Gotham. Crime ran rampant through the streets, too much for the few remaining bats to handle.
Red Robin tried to take over for Signal, aware that leaving crime during the day wasn’t an option, but he was adapting poorly to the new schedule and the fact that he could no longer hide in the shadows. Red Hood was too busy struggling to maintain order within his criminal empire to even bother helping the rest of the bats. Nightwing had left Bludhaven to help, but that still only left him and Robin to deal with all of the crime that took place at night.
The city was big, and Gothamites had come to the realization that they couldn’t stop everyone.
Benny died. A mugging gone wrong on his way to school.
They couldn’t do anything but pour one out for a kid who never even got old enough to drink.
~
The crime rates went up, and so did the prices.
Especially pharmaceutical prices. An already predatory industry looked down on Gotham, aware that people were already scrambling to survive, and figured that they would be willing to pay.
And some were.
Most… would have. If they could have.
Canary paid well. She had a good benefits package.
It still hadn’t been enough to keep up with the insane insulin prices, which were needlessly high even when inflation wasn’t trying to level an entire city.
Polly held out as long as she could with the little insulin that she and Lorenzo could afford, but, ultimately, there was little that they could do in a system set up to make people like them fail.
Lorenzo was inconsolable. She didn’t know his ‘lore’, but she had gathered that Polly was all he had left family-wise. He wasn’t taking well to the fact that he was alone, now.
Aaron took the grieving man under his wing, slinging an arm over his shoulders and forgetting all about his dreams of leaving the henching business. He claimed that he had already tried for long enough and it surely wasn’t going to happen if it hadn’t already.
Marinette quietly moved them both away from bartending in favor of setting them up in the kitchens.
… there was something morbidly relieving about seeing other people struggling with the crippling loneliness and hopelessness about never being able to leave the criminal underworld that she had been struggling with for months. That it was weirdly calming to be able to lead them away from the unhealthy coping mechanisms she partook in, that it gave a strange sense of control in a life that she felt had spiraled well beyond the point where she felt like she could fix things.
Those feelings settled horribly in her stomach. She knew that they were wrong.
But, her resident psychologist was dead and gone, and she had no intentions of untangling and understanding those complicated emotions without him.
So, she said that she moved them away from bartending because she was worried about her stock. Self-destruct all you want, but not on her dime.
~
Dick came for her.
It was inevitable, really.
The bats all cared about each other, that was obvious, but Nightwing had always been the one most invested in his family.
It was a little strange to see the man. His mask was abandoned – it was pretty much useless now, the entire world knew who he was at this point – which revealed deep bags lining his eyes. His cheeks were sunken and hollow. His hair was greasy.
Canary, of course, had never looked better. A healthy shine to her skin, a slimy smirk on her face that even she wasn’t sure was fake anymore, and a suit that was almost impossibly crisp.
Dick Grayson looked sickly, she looked sick.
Her smirk pulled wider. “Nightwing! Back for drinks?”
His fists clenched at his sides.
“I mean, obviously, right, since you didn’t bring the little Robin,” she continued on, waving the cigarette in her hand vaguely. “Good on you to be a responsible pseudo-parent. He really needs a father figure right now.”
He bared his teeth in a snarl.
“Aw, no fun quip?” She teased in a lighthearted tone even as her eyes narrowed in silent, cold calculation. “And here I was thinking you were the fun one.”
She dropped from the roof and took one last, long drag from her cigarette before tossing it aside.
Tim and Steph represented what she could have been, but Dick was her.
The main difference between the two was that Canary wore her true colors on her sleeve – a Coral Snake, meant to catch out the unwary or those dumb enough to mistake her for a harmless King Snake.
But, if Canary was a Coral Snake, then Nightwing was a Boa Constrictor. He crept up on his victims, winding around them in a comfortable, settling weight that could easily be mistaken for a stray vine catching around your leg, and waited until his victims were fully ensnared before pulling tight. They wouldn’t even be able to scream for help.
Now, the two snakes eyed each other. Neither of them were really in their element. Canary was far too careful to ever disregard anything that might ever hold her down, and Nightwing had never stopped paying attention from the moment he had first discovered what she was. Fighting each other was counterintuitive – stupid, even.
And yet.
She blew smoke in his face, an obvious taunt, and he was more than eager to try and punch her in retaliation.
She rolled out of the way and knives flicked to her hands. He pulled out his escrima.
Blue electricity crackled around the glorified police batons.
She rushed him.
It wasn’t a quick or pretty fight.
Neither of their weapons were made for that.
Beating a person to death was a slow process, and the knives she hid on her were often made for slashing rather than outright stabbing unless in particularly soft parts. The only ways to end it quickly were if Dick managed to get a lucky shot at her head or if she got to gouge out his neck – which, of course, meant that they were guarding those areas especially hard.
Too hard.
She yelped a curse as Dick feinted that he was going for her head and then made contact with her right shoulder. Her entire arm went numb and the knife in that hand clattered to the ground.
She backed off quickly, taking quiet note as he kicked the knife away, and her back hit the wall.
He went for her head.
She ducked under the swing, which he expected, but he didn’t expect the knife she buried in his wrist for his troubles.
A strangled scream left him.
She grabbed the escrima held in limp fingers and then stumbled away, hugging her tingling arm to herself. Eyes frantically scanned the empty streets for any hint of silver.
A blow to her back had her crashing to the floor and she gasped out as hands and knees scraped against asphalt.
But he was coming after her soon enough, weight dropping into her stomach the moment she turned around and knocking the wind out of her.
Tears sprang in her eyes and she switched the escrima to her numb hand in favor of catching the hand that came straight for her head.
And then it was a desperate struggle on both sides, escrimas flashing with dangerous light. Both of them trying to get any sort of upper hand.
Desperate blows were traded. Well-manicured nails scratched the skin of his face. A knee drove itself into the squishy part of her thigh. Backs and shoulders scraped on cold, unforgiving concrete as they rolled on the ground. A well-placed punch cracked his nose. A chunk of hair was ripped from her head.
Water and blood dripped onto her face.
Neither of them knew if they were really only crying because of the pain.
Electricity sent tingles up her side.
Her mind stuttered and he drew himself up to throw his entire weight into one last hit.
She darted up to press the end of the stolen escrima to the metal of the knife still lodged in his wrist.
Light flickered in Dick’s eyes and then disappeared.
The body slumped against her, fried from the inside out.
The escrima slid out of limp fingers and rolled across the ground.
She allowed herself to slump as well. Exhaustion lingered in every limb. The body was heavy where it pressed on her. Blood dirtied her suit. Electricity scars were sure to litter her skin and the area where the escrima had made contact were hot to the touch.
Her eyes and throat burned the worst, though she didn’t have an excuse for that.
~
Guess I really did end up going to your funeral, she thought, and it pulled a dark laugh from her lips.
And then she kept laughing. She planted the hand that wasn’t holding her cigarette against the wall as she doubled over.
Tears spilled down her cheeks, she was laughing so hard.
She swiped a hand across her eyes, but all it did was smear more of his blood over her skin.
She tossed the cigarette over her shoulder, and laughed even harder as the petrol-covered body went up in flames.
And then Marinette keeled over and threw up.
~
Her henchmen… were not happy with her.
Nightwing was a favorite among henchmen. He usually let them off with minor injuries, and even then the injuries were only done so they weren’t at risk of being murdered by aggravated Rogues. He was a good guy.
He had tried to kill her.
She wasn’t sure how to conflate the two ideas in her head.
Sure, he had lost a bunch of his family at once… but so had she, and she was fine.
She.
Was.
Fine.
Even when Lorenzo and Aaron left, yelling about how they were going to go and work for Riddler, she was fine.
~
She had bigger problems to deal with, anyways.
Namely: Robin. He was also not taking well to the fact that Nightwing was dead now. And he had decided to make his grief everyone else’s problem.
Especially Canary and Red Hood’s.
She wasn’t quite sure why Jason had been included in Damian’s wrath. Maybe he felt that the man hadn’t done enough, maybe he was mad that Jason had been focusing on his own empire rather than helping people, maybe Jason was just the first person he saw…
But, while the enemy of your enemy is not your friend, they can be a temporary ally if you’re both desperate enough.
And, as she watched another one of her safehouses go up in smoke on the news, she decided that she was.
Jason seemed to agree, though he didn’t seem too happy about it.
Still, the dramatic bastard insisted on drawing it out, and he tipped his head to the side as he regarded her.
“Are we going to kill him?” Jason asked.
She went still. Even if she knew, logically, that Robin was well over the age of adulthood and that made him fair game, the tiny part of her that was still ‘Marinette’ screamed that he was still just a kid. That hurting him was wrong, that involving him in something like that made her no better than Fu.
But, still…
She gritted her teeth. “Whatever it takes.” To get him off their backs, to survive.
He, somehow, managed to look even less enthused.
But he nodded. And she knew he got it.
So, the two street kids-turned-Rogues got to work surviving.
Finding Damian was easy. He was going after all of their bases – something he knew would hurt, something he knew would mess with them like nothing else because eventually they would run out of homes and they couldn’t go back to the way things had been – and they were nothing if not patient. Eventually, he came to them.
Fighting him was… less easy.
Marinette had had enough trouble taking down Dick, and she didn’t even like him.
But now she was faced with the kid that she had once traded pictures of animals with regularly. The kid that she had nerded out about swords and knives with. The one that complained loudly about her pinching his cheeks but never actually made any efforts to stop her –.
She needed to survive.
For one more day.
One more kill.
So she could continue on to do it all again.
It was sickening. She was ending people’s lives to further her own, and she didn’t even really want to be alive, she just couldn’t bring herself to die.
She was a coward.
But a coward that was going to live to see tomorrow.
Damian stood no match against the both of them when they worked together. The two of them were stubborn in that they always survived, no matter what, and everyone knew that only one side was going home. Add on the fact that the two Rogues had completely different skill sets and fight styles that paired together beautifully and that they were more than willing to fight dirty, the kid – the not-kid – really hadn’t had much of a chance.
And then the two of them were breathing heavily, chests heaving where Damian’s was remarkably still.
They met eyes.
There was only one way partnerships between people like them ever ended. They both knew it.
“Don’t you think there’s been enough death?” Jason said even as he leveled his gun at her head.
Yes, Marinette thought.
Canary’s grip tightened on her knives. “Whatever it takes.”
“Whatever it takes,” he agreed quietly.
~
She watched on as Ara and Emma cleaned up the aftermath. She couldn’t bring herself to touch the bodies. There was already too much blood on her, soaking through her clothes in a way that she knew would leave her skin hopelessly stained.
Ara and Emma were quiet as they worked. Ara wasn’t even phased by murder anymore. Couldn’t afford to be, not when she was one of Canary’s most trusted workers.
But what good was trust, really, when it came from someone so paranoid?
What was trust, really, when it came from someone who had proved again and again that they held nothing sacred other than their own life?
She looked down at the lifeless eyes of the people she had once called friends.
Canary had always been so concerned about staying alive, surviving at any cost.
Now, she was stuck wondering what would happen when she was the only person left alive.
~
Her body trembled minutely. From overexertion, she was sure, digging up a grave was hard enough when she had had help…
But she didn’t now. She couldn’t bring herself to trust anyone with this information.
Hell, the entire reason she was even doing this was because she didn’t trust the kwamis.
She had ordered them into silence. Had made sure they never told anyone, never ran. Had forced them out of sight.
But they were never out of mind.
All she could ever think about was how it would only take one loophole for everything to come crashing down.
It would just be typical for her by now.
So, she was back to hiding everything miraculous-related in a grave. Jason’s this time. It felt fitting, to put the gods that had kept her alive for years with the bat known for dying and coming back.
(Not that he would come back again.)
She got deep enough to feel comfortable that it wouldn’t be found anytime soon, and then she tossed the box and book down into the grave.
Heads popped out, eyes wide and staring. No one said anything, they couldn’t, and Marinette was filled with the urge to fill the silence once again, if only to give them orders:
“Stay quiet, don’t leave your weird little dimension. Don’t tell anyone you’re here. Just –.”
Tikki managed to catch her eyes for the first time in ages and Marinette’s voice cracked. She’d never seen the kwami look so disappointed, and that hurt, but she also looked at her with something she could only describe as love and understanding.
She shakily inhaled through her nose.
“Someone might find you eventually. Maybe they’ll set you free. I don’t know. I just can’t do this anymore.”
And then she was pouring dirt back into the grave.
~
Sometimes she thought that she just might hate Tim.
Because Tim Drake had shown her what it was like to not be completely alone, and it was almost painful to go back now that she had seen it.
But, most of the time, she didn’t regret the year she had spent with him.
Even if the memories were bittersweet, at least there was some sweetness. That was all she could ask for, at this point.
~
When had she started falling for her own act?
When had ‘Marinette’ stopped existing? When had she burned to death in Canary’s burning anger?
She was almost hurt. It felt like a betrayal.
Canary was supposed to protect her.
All she had done was kill everyone else.
But Canary was all she had left, and damn if she was going to lose anything else.
~
The door flung open with a resounding bang.
She gave herself a moment to take a deep breath in through her nose. She looked down at the box she had been inspecting.
“Run,” she told Ara and Emma. “The shipment is fine.”
And they did.
They were allowed to leave. Great.
That meant it was exactly who she thought it was. Great.
And then she whirled around, arms spread wide and welcoming and a smile fixed on her face.
Tim Drake stood in full bat gear, and she scrunched her nose a little at the Batman cowl and stubble on his chin. She hadn’t even known he could grow facial hair and, indeed, it was patchy.
She tipped her head to the side. “Oh, c’mon, darling, what’s a secret identity among friends?”
It had been a taunt. Nothing more. She was not sickened by the separation that the mask provided or the way he wore his father’s old face and gait like it was natural.
To her surprise, though, he actually did reach up and pull the cowl down. His hair was a mess from the cowl, and there was charcoal coating his eyelids to give them that intense depth that the eyes of the cowl always seemed to have.
The charcoal looked streaky. She tried not to think too hard about why that was.
“Marinette.”
She shuddered. She hadn’t been called that name in such a long time. Not even by herself.
“Red Robin,” she returned, only for her smile to stretch wider. “Or should I call you Batman, now?”
“I’m still Tim,” he said.
Marinette’s voice died in her throat.
Luckily, it seemed that Tim was done talking.
He rushed at her, his bo staff extending…
And Marinette…
Marinette can’t bring herself to fight back. Not really.
She knew that when he did a right hook he would leave his side open temporarily. Knew that his stance was just a little too thin and that it would be easy to unbalance him. Knew that he relied too much on his bo to drive distance and that the best way to fight him was to get in close enough that he wouldn’t be able to use it anymore.
She could only let him drive her back, knives flashing in wide arcs. Flashy things that mean nothing – that do nothing other than surface level damage to his skin that would surely heal within a few days.
Marinette couldn’t even bring herself to really fight back.
A well-placed hit to her knee had her crumpling, had her tossing her weapons aside to catch her fall.
And, just like his brother, he was more than willing to follow her to the ground.
But he tossed his own weapon in favor of locking his hands around her throat.
She gasped for air that refused to come.
White lenses glared down at her, lips pulled back in a snarl.
Canary’s hands strained, reaching for a knife that her middle finger could only barely touch.
He pressed down harder.
Marinette’s finger pushed the knife out of reach.
She swore she could feel something in her throat collapse.
She wondered if this was how Adrien had felt.
Maybe that was why she had to go out this way. Maybe soulmates always had to go out in the same way.
Her chest heaved with breaths that never came to be.
Her limbs tired.
It kind of felt like falling asleep. And that was terrifying in its own right.
It would be over soon.
Marinette’s gaze fell away, to the full moon hanging overhead, framed almost perfectly between the tops of the two buildings on either side of them.
It looked like a pearl.
Her eyes found their way back to her pearl.
She supposed she should have never thought that they would last, not with a nickname like that. Pearls were bad luck in the Wayne family.
She let her eyes flutter closed. Her vision had been starting to blur, anyways.
The streets of Gotham would claim another life. Death was owed someone, and she had been evading Him for years now. She would allow Him to take him into her arms, now, if Tim’s hands were the ones to push her into His embrace.
He pushed down.
And then, all at once, his weight disappeared.
She was allowed to roll away, to plant her shaky hands onto the cold concrete beneath her and struggle to force her throat to open again. Tears spilled from the corners of her eyes, irritating her contacts, and all she could do was sob between the gasps for air and coughing fits that wrecked her body.
Her knife skidded across the ground, the metal blade creating a tiny trail of sparks, until it came to rest between her hands.
She forced herself to look up at Tim.
His lips pressed into a thin line as he looked down at her. She must have looked quite the sight – hair falling out of its usual tight bun, three-piece suit rumpled and streaked with blood, tears spilling from her eyes, and the early markings of a soon-to-be bruise littering the base of her neck like a demented necklace.
“If you’re going to kill yourself, don’t use me to do it.”
She swiped a hand across her mouth because choking was not a pretty thing and pushed herself up to sit properly. “What? Still think I can change?” A false pitying expression made its way across her face – her eyebrows drawn downwards and her lips puckered into the most aggravating of the many mocking faces in her arsenal.
“You already have,” he said.
She snorted. “Please, cut the shit. Denial and bargaining are fun parts of the grieving process, but you’ve got to move on eventually.”
He returned her bitter laugh, leaning to scoop up his bo staff from the ground and then turning to give her something that wasn’t quite a glare.
“It’s funny how you can be so good at psychoanalyzing others to a tee, and yet you know nothing about yourself.”
He turned to leave.
“I’m not good at psychoanalyzing others.”
He stilled. Chanced a look back.
She had fixed her gaze on the moon again, watching it intently as if she thought it would disappear if she ever dared to look away.
“You were supposed to leave. You had so many chances, you had every reason. You should have left.”
His lips twisted into something that might have looked like a smile to passerby, but it was far too bitter to really be amusement. “Guess we never really knew each other, then.”
“Guess not,” she agreed quietly.
And then he was leaving with a swish of his cape.
Marinette watched him go.
He was shorter and less stocky than his mentor – his father – had been, but the similarities between them are so striking that the only thing keeping her from accidentally thinking him to be Bruce was the fact that his cowl was still pulled back.
She looked at the man who had lost it all. The man with too much money and nothing productive to do anything with it. The man that is scared of new connections and maybe a little too calculating, but likely only as a coping mechanism. The man that is unable to kill even those who deserved it.
The apple never falls far from the tree.
And, with no one to pick it up, it’s left to rot.
She wondered what Bruce would think if he saw Tim like this.
She wondered if it even mattered.
~
“We quit,” said Ara, throwing down their two weeks' notices.
She looked down at the papers in front of her. At the signatures that lay there.
“I can’t watch you do this to yourself anymore,” Emma said, and it sounded so much like what Jonathan had said that it hurt.
She picked up the papers and looked over them, making sure everything was in order.
“It’s like I don’t even know you anymore!”
She wondered if the woman ever did.
“Mari, please,” Emma said, and she was almost begging. “Say something.”
She took a deep breath.
And then she looked up. “How old are you now, Ara?”
Ara blanched. “That’s… that’s all you have to say?!”
But understanding passed over Emma’s face. Something shuttered over her eyes. Her face drained of color. “Seventeen,” she answered.
She nodded slowly and looked at Ara to confirm.
“I mean… yes, I’m seventeen, but does that matt –?!”
Ara’s voice cut off with a scream, because in seconds Canary was on her feet and drawing a knife across the neck of the woman that had saved them both.
It was the quickest thing she could do outside of snapping the woman’s neck. And she didn’t want to try that. Her hands were shaking too much for her to do it properly. It was hard enough to do a quick, clean cut, and even harder to pull the fox miraculous over her quickly lolling head.
Emma’s already pale face quickly turned ashy and blood gurgled in her throat as if to make up for the lack of color.
And then, all too soon, she was still.
Other than the red slowly seeping out of her, of course.
Ara screamed at her. She could barely make out the words through the sobs.
She rested her hands on her hips, her bloodsoaked knife dripping where she held it in a limp grip.
“She knew too much for me to let her go,” she said, matter-of-fact. “Really, you do, too. But you’re still a kid.”
Ara fell silent. Her face was remarkably flushed, as if to make up for the fact that Emma’s would never be again.
“You should go. And don’t come back. Once you turn eighteen…” She shrugged. “I won’t be so lenient.”
Ara gritted her teeth.
A young Asian girl with absentee parents has someone she cared about die right in front of her because of a mob boss with no allegiances to anyone.
“You’re going to regret this,” the girl hissed.
The mob boss can only smile a condescending little smile.
“I’m sure I will. Now, go run off, I’m sure you have juice boxes to drink or something.”
And, with no systemic change, the cycle began all over again.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Version Two: No One Mourns the Wicked
Summary:
Goodness knows
The Wicked's lives are lonely
Goodness knows
The Wicked cry alone
Nothing grows for the Wicked
They reap only
What they sow
~~~~~
A woman in her late twenties pulled herself out of an overturned grave, dirt staining her skin and clothes.
Of course, she wasn’t actually in her late twenties, but what woman doesn’t wish to be eternally 29?
Her, actually. The moment she had woken up at age forty and stared back at her still young face, the realization that she hadn’t aged in years hitting her fully for the first time, she had cracked her mirror.
Immortality was a burden, one that was thrust upon her when she was far too young to ever really understand the consequences. One that she hadn’t even really wanted then. One she couldn’t get rid of. Not without giving up the miraculous box that was still, technically within her possession even if she hadn’t set her eyes on it in years, as she was the only person that knew where it was.
The only person alive that knew that miraculous were more than just a story that their grandparents used to tell them when they were getting ready for bed.
And she couldn’t give up the miraculous. Because, even if immortality was the universe’s way of granting her wish to always survive in the cruelest way possible, she still couldn’t bring herself to entrust them to someone else. Not when humans had proven themselves corruptible time and time again.
No, there was only one person she would have ever trusted with this, and he was long gone.
Or… he was for now.
She pulled the shoebox into her lap, dirt-covered gloves scrabbling over the cardboard in a sound that was both horrible and undeniably relieving.
She was reminded, startlingly, of someone digging up an old time capsule.
The thought brought a wry smile to her lips.
One that quickly faded as she flipped the lid open.
Many eyes flicked to her, wide and interested and so hopeful, only for their faces to fall when they saw who had dug them up.
She paid them as little mind as possible, hands already finding their way to the two that she needed.
Tikki sighed softly.
The kwami didn’t have to say it, she already knew that she was thinking about how bad and how selfish she would be if she did this.
But she was a villain. Villains are allowed to be as awful as they wish.
And, god, she certainly did wish for something.
She held the two miraculous in her hands, squeezing her eyes shut tight.
“Please…” Marinette breathed, and for once her voice matched her true age, dry and cracked and shaky. “Take me back. I don’t care about the consequences anymore. Let me fix this.”
She watched as Tikki and Plagg met eyes for just a moment before the world disappeared in a whirl of color.
She was suddenly thrown back into it.
The couch fabric was soft beneath her but the cushions were still not completely broken in. There was a dull aching in her arm that screamed of an injury long forgotten. The knife beneath her tongue nearly nicked her.
And Tim was sitting across from her. The only lines on his face were tiny stress lines on his forehead. His hands were folded neatly in his lap, body language always polite even when around people he knew. There was a slightly frustrated flush on his cheeks. And he was alive and happy and healthy.
And speaking: “You prefer energy drinks to coffee.”
She looked at him with wide eyes. She was sure that she looked like she had just seen a ghost but, to be fair, she kind of had.
“Repeat that for me?” She whispered.
He sighed and met her gaze. “You don’t like coffee. Your preferred way to get caffeine is through energy drinks.”
A tiny sound escaped her throat, and that was all the warning he got before she was grabbing him by the front of that dumb, ugly outfit that he had used to wear that she had missed more than she ever should have and pulling him close for a hug.
He was still and silent as she tried her hardest not to sob into his shirt, surprise making him stiff, before he wrapped her in his arms.
Disgust and fear curdled beneath her skin at the contact and she didn’t even care because it was Tim and somehow it was still the best – the safest – she had felt in years.
But it wouldn’t last.
Somewhere, deep in her mind, she knew that she only had twenty-four hours in this reality. That she would die soon.
She wondered, idly, why this was her punishment. Why it was exchanging one life for several. Was it because of her extended lifespan? Was she shaving off years and giving them to all of the people she had lost? Or was it because she had proven that it was an equivalent value to her? That she was willing to sacrifice them all for herself?
Maybe it was both, maybe it was neither. The universe would never tell.
It was the knowledge of the time limit looming over her head that had her pulling away from Tim far sooner than she would have liked.
She would have liked to stay there forever.
But, in twenty-four hours, she would be dead.
She had a lot to do before then.
So, she worked.
It wasn’t like she didn’t know what she wanted to do. She had had far too long to think about the way things had turned out, about how she could have done things better.
It was far too easy.
Too easy to toss her earrings into the shoebox hidden in Adrien’s pocket dimension, not to be discovered until it was far too late. Too easy to walk right up to Cobblepot and spit in his face and then watch as he screamed and fell back, clutching his eye as a throwing knife pierced his brain. Too easy to toss his body into the harbor, not to be found until she was already long gone.
She rushed to Paris to get rid of the people Cobblepot had sent. And then she had walked right across the street, stained clothes stashed in her backpack, and ran to her parents to let them envelop her in a hug that was so tight she swore something inside of her cracked.
She took everyone out for pizza. To celebrate, she had said. She grinned around her cup as Jonathan and Edward argued with Emma over who got to adopt her in a way that wasn’t entirely joking. Complained about Adrien drinking milk straight from the carton even though it didn’t really count when the carton was a single serving. Handed Ara her extra slice because, for the first time in ages, she really wasn’t all that hungry.
She went out to get drinks with Tim, sitting on top of the roof with a cup of coffee in his hand and a can of brandless energy drink in her own. Talked with him for hours about anything that he wanted, about nothing and yet everything. Promised him a date she would never be able to attend, a liar until the very end.
Had headed home on her own.
The world would be fine. They would all be fine. So what if she wasn’t around to see it?
She had seen enough.
But… at the end of her time…
Well, who had to know?
Had to know that the two packs worth of cigarette stubs in a trashcan by her bed had been smoked over her last hour? Had to know that she had had to stop writing several times while she had portioned out her will to make sure no tears dripped onto the paper? Had to know that she had screamed and cried her throat raw minutes before?
Had to know that her eyes stayed locked on her computer screen, watching the milliseconds count down in a way that was both painfully slow and far too quick? Had to know that her heart beat in time with the clock ticking down?
Had to know that her last breath was little more than a whimper as her body locked up, every muscle tensing, and she found that she was no longer able to breathe in?
The universe would never tell.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Canary Masterlist
13 notes
·
View notes