Take My Hand (Part Six)
Summary: rafael returns and things only get more complicated as the Davis case begins
Pairings: Sonny Carisi x Reader, Rafael Barba x Reader
Word Count: 8,240
Song: There's an ache in you put there by the ache in me / But if it's all the same to you / It's the same to me (coney island by taylor swift)
Warnings: T, swearing, the angst is back, lot of soft parts, but a lot of difficult emotions to detangle, “sightless in a savage land” (22x04) is used as background (but i also f*cked with the timeline to make things easier for me), also the v*rus doesn’t exist b/c i don’t want to live in reality.
A/N: ok, things are happening, and i want to saw those of you who spot all the little parallels w/i the fic i love you. thank you to those who have stuck with the series and have reblogged and commented!! as always, thank you to @laneygthememequeen and @bucky-of-the-opera for being the best beta readers!!
You would be lying if you said you didn’t imagine this moment.
The moment you saw Rafael again. It was a thought that haunted the recesses of your mind — stuffed away with all memories of him — one that wriggled to the forefront when your thoughts had quelled in the silence and stillness. And you wondered what he would say. And what you would say.
And now you didn’t have to wonder.
"What are you—" the question deflates on your lips — stupid question — so you ask another, "when did you get back?"
"A few days ago," Rafael jerks his head to pull you aside, an easy smile on his lips, too easy. It wasn't easy when you both started dating. It wasn't easy when you left. It wasn't easy when he proposed. And it wasn't easy to say no. Nothing was easy when it came to this. But there he was, "my mother is moving down to Florida."
You raise your eyebrows, "Finally retiring? Did you have to pry the keys of her charter school out of her fingers?"
He gives a wry smile, "No, but helping her find a replacement and helping her pick out a place down there made it easier. That and promising to help her move."
"You're a good son," he was good — a good son, a good friend, a good prosecutor—
But he wasn’t good for you.
"Well I am a man of many talents," he crosses his arms, “with a few notable exceptions.”
And you know where this is going — to a place you don’t want it to.
He opens his mouth to speak again, but you cut him off, “Are you representing Davis?”
The words stuck in his throat, his mouth opening and closing, before he swallows them, “I am,”
“I didn’t know you did defense work,”
He tilts his head, “Well, there’s a first time for everything, isn’t there? I assume you’re here because Noble-Gordon wants the case?”
You raise an eyebrow, “Keeping tabs on me?”
“You’d like that, wouldn’t you?” the teasing is so routine — the banter clicks into place — picking up right where you both left off, smoothing over broken hearts and hurt feelings. Hiding behind quick witted barbs because it was easier than untangling ensnared feelings.
“Rafael—”
“I met with Jack,” he admits, holding his hands up, “I asked about you. Can you blame me for being curious?”
No. No, you couldn’t — not when you had asked Jack about him.
“I can try,” you want to bite the inside of your cheek when he smirks, “why do you want this case?”
“Off the record? Liv and Fin,” he slides his hands inside his pocket, “I suspect they didn’t know your firm would want the case for themselves, but,” he adds, “there’s a way this could work for both of us.”
“How?”
“How about a partnership?”
“A partnership?”
“Your firm gets their name on the case, and I need financial support,” and you furrow your brow, “but I have some terms.”
“Of course you would,” you sigh, “what are they?”
“One, I do the actual defense work in court, two, your firm’s involvement is limited to only a few employees — I don’t want your partners’ politics to be running the case — and three, you’re on the case with me,” and you raise your eyebrows, “before you say no—”
“Before I say no?” you repeat, “Rafael with everything that happened—”
“Before anything happened, we worked cases together, and even after everything happened, we did,” he shifts from foot to foot, “we know how the other works, we know our strengths and weaknesses, and I need someone I trust to work this case on — so I can walk into that courtroom for the first time since—” he sighs, biting his lip before speaking again, softer, “I want your help, and I know I have no right to ask for it, but I am. And that term is negotiable, but I’m pretty sure your firm will agree. You’re the best person to work this case.”
“But—”
“And before you ask,” he says, gaze soft, “this isn’t a ploy to win you back.”
You blink, “I know,”
Did you? You wished you could tell your heart because now it’s thumping against your ribcage, “I know I missed my chance, and I don’t want to cross any boundaries,” he reassures you, “this will be professional.”
“‘Professional,’” you repeat, the taste of the word disconcerting with just how unprofessional this felt, “Rafael—”
“Just think about it,” he tilts his head, “meet with Davis — trust me, he needs our help,” and then he pauses, “and you know that we’ll be facing—”
“I know Sonny is the A.D.A. on the case,” and he’s also my boyfriend. The words want to leave your tongue, but the sheer awkwardness is as disconcerting as working with Rafael — “Look—”
“Don’t give me an answer yet, just talk to your firm,” he checks his watch, “I have to go, but I’ll email you.”
“And where’d you get my email?” he shrugs.
“You can blame your firm for that one — firm’s website lists you,” and he begins to walk past you before pausing to look back, “it was nice to see you...counselor.”
How was it that he walked into your life as easily as you had left his? How was it that you wanted to hate him, but it was so easy to like him? How was it that everything was so easy — when it was him?
“It was nice to see you too,” and you spared one last glance at his retreating back, as the guard buzzed you in.
And that wouldn’t be the last time you’d see him.
Sonny was beginning to doubt any of this would ever get easier. Checking his watch, it was well past 3:00 PM and he hadn’t even eaten yet — typical. He spares a glance at the whiteboard — littered with schedules, case numbers, and statuses of cases.
But there was still so much to do.
He checks his phone — you had texted him, the messages bunched together, but his eyes fall back to the files stacked on the conference table. He begins placing them in a case box. It would have to wait.
“Carisi?” and he pauses at a voice — a voice he hadn’t heard in quite a while. He’s grizzled — different from the clean cut A.D.A. he once was, but he’s also lighter — again, different from the broken man who left his city with his reputation in shambles.
His words, not Sonny’s.
But now Sonny knows, knows that he wasn’t only broken because of the case, of having to leave his city, but because of you — the you that Barba had been with for years, the you whose heart he broke, the you who said no when he proposed.
And now you were dating Sonny.
Him, not Barba.
He stands in his doorway, “How’s the eighth floor treating you?”
But this was the same man that was his mentor, his friend — so he smiles.
“No differently than any other junior A.D.A.,” and Rafael gives a knowing smile, as Sonny continues to put away the files.
“They want you to cover their ass all the time? Never lose a case?” he knew it well — because he had lived it.
“Pretty much,” Barba crosses his arms, as Sonny grabs the box and brushes past him, “it’s good to see you, Barba. If you came to taunt me, I got all day.”
And it was good to see him — why wouldn’t it be? He would be lying if he didn’t wish before that Rafael was his boss instead — it would have been easier if nothing else. But not now.
“Huh, they gave you an office,” Barba remarks, glancing around his shoebox of an office, peering out his window to look at the paralegals at their desks, “nice view.”
Sonny places the box down, snorting, “I had to move the xerox machine and four filing cabinets just to get the desk in,” and then move them back. It wasn’t much — but it took him this long to get it — glorified closet or not, it was his.
“So you caught the Mickey Davis case?” He’s standing by the window, and Sonny sighs — the case had been all over the news, the media were having a field day, and so were his bosses upstairs. These were different times — and this was a dangerous case — vigilantism wasn’t something to be taken lightly. But it wasn’t something that was simple — not in this case.
“Oh, yeah,” Sonny sighs, leaning against his desk, “horror story.”
“What are you charging?”
Sonny almost scoffs, “The guy brought a gun to court, he followed the vic to transport, and shot him at point-blank range. What do you think?”
“I think the guy's got a Purple Heart, titanium leg, and PTS,” Sonny blinks — what was this?
“That doesn’t change what he did,” Sonny says slowly — Barba knew that — killing is still killing, no matter how justified it may seem.
He said it himself best — otherwise we might as well let the blood flow in the streets.
“He was betrayed by the V.A. and A.C.S., even the eighth floor has to know this is a dog,” Barba says, stepping forward, a ghost of a chuckle on his lips.
“Maybe,” Sonny admits, “but they still want him to do time.”
“That has to be negotiable,” and that’s when it clicks.
Sonny pauses, his mouth parted, as Barba meets his gaze, “Hold on,” he says slowly, “before we continue—”
“Mm-hmm,”
“Are you representing Mickey Davis?” And it’s Barba’s turn to pause, and he’s searching Sonny’s gaze — and he doesn’t know for what.
“I am,”
Sonny scoffs — that would have been nice to know from the start, “Okay,” Sonny gets to his feet, shutting his door and rounding the table to sit behind his desk — time to get down to business, “What kind of deal are you looking for?”
“No way you want to put this guy on trial,”
“Three and half years? No, but thank you,” Barba sits across from him, and Sonny knows he’s playing hard ball — he always played hard ball, but this time, they weren’t on the same team.
“Barba, we both know this wasn’t heat of the moment,”
“Maybe to you, not to Mr. Davis,”
Sonny raises an eyebrow, there was defending your client and then there was plain hubris,“There's security cam video. There's multiple eyewitnesses. Mickey broke the law—”
“A jury might see that as defending his daughter when no one else did,” Sonny narrows his eyes — jury nullification — did he get that strategy from Calhoun or Buchanan?
“Get the jury to ignore the law?” Sonny knew he wouldn’t make easy on him “That's a slippery slope, Rafael.”
He smiles, he’s almost proud, “You really have become a lawyer,”
Sonny wrinkles his brow, “What does that mean?”
“Mickey Davis is a human being. So are the jurors,” Rafael rises to his feet, as Sonny calls after him.
“You going for insanity?” He half-expects him not to answer — that would be the smart thing to do — but Rafael’s pride always trumped any strategy.
“I'm going for straight-up not guilty,” Rafael opens the door, turning, “and my co-counsel may be in touch as well.”
“Co-counsel?” Sonny leans back in his seat — he didn’t know Barba needed a second chair, “who’s that?”
And your name leaves his lips, “Excuse me?”
“Looks like you’ll be facing both of your mentors, Carisi,” and he knew that Rafael hadn’t seen the picture of you on his desk — “I’ll make sure to relay the offer as well. See you at arraignment.”
Sonny stares at the closed door, before his phone vibrates again, and he glances to see another text message from you: Hey, checking in on you. Can I drop by?
And Sonny knows, he knows you would never cheat. He knew this doesn’t change the year you had spent together, he knew it doesn’t change that you loved him, he knew it didn’t change anything, but — another text comes through: I miss you — it was complicated.
Not right now. Busy.
And he sighs, but it also didn’t change how he felt about you.
I miss you too.
The lights in the D.A.’s office had long ago dimmed — the barely lit fluorescents flickering as you passed the empty line of desks before finally reaching it. You knock at his office door, leaning against the doorframe, watching him work, his brow furrowed in thought, pen flicking as he scribbled notes.
“You forget about me?” Sonny barely looks up from his work, tight lipped, and your smile begins to slide off your lips, “Sonny?”
“Sorry, got caught up in work,” he leans back in his chair, just as you step forward, “what time is it?”
“Way past dinner,” you round his desk, leaning against it as you tilt your head, “you okay?”
You reach for him, but he moves away, crossing his arms, “Barba dropped by,” and his eyes fall on you — and you wonder if this was what it felt like to be interrogated — the pages of the book snapped shut, his cards resting against the table, and his face blank, “He wanted to discuss the Davis case—”
Your heart drops, “Sonny—”
“—and apparently you’re his co-counsel?” he shakes his head, sighing, his eyes falling to his desk, “When were you going to tell me that you met with Barba?”
You frown, “I wanted to tell you, I was going to tell you before I went to meet him — but I couldn’t reach you. You know my partners wanted to score some points—”
“Because of the Thompson case, I know—” but his brow is still furrowed, “but how did you end up calling point on the case?”
“I had to meet with Davis to discuss the details of the case,” you explain how your partners were too busy to go down and handle it nor did they trust any of the associates to do it, “we need this case — it’s a high profile case involving a vet? We had to jump on it, but when I got to Rikers, it turned out someone else got the jump on it first.”
He scoffs, “Barba,”
“He had already met with Davis, he offered to work in partnership with my firm, granted I handle the case and he gets to be in the courtroom,” and Sonny raises his eyebrows.
“He asked for you specifically to work the case with him?”
“Because he knows how I work,” your hand reaches for him slowly, “nothing more than that. Sonny, please don’t be mad — it was a coincidence.”
“I’m not mad,” he sighs, eyes finally meeting yours, his fingers intertwining with yours, “Would have been nice to know you two decided to work the case together,”
“I was going to tell you — I was just about to—”
“I know,” and he’s pulling you into his lap, “Just don’t let me find out you’re working with your ex from your ex,”
“I won’t,” you whisper, pressing your lips to him softly, “I promise. I didn’t mean for this—”
“I know,” he kisses you again, his arms wrapping around your middle, “what about us?”
Your lips purse, “What about us?”
“Our relationship — will we have to disclose?” it hadn’t been a problem since the cases you handled fell out of Sonny’s jurisdiction most times and when it didn’t, you delegated the work to someone else, “it seems like professional responsibility 101,”
“Well, I already told Mr. Davis, I got his written consent in writing when I met with him, just in case I end up handling the case,” you bite your lip, “as for the judge, it shouldn’t be a problem as long as we have the consent of my client.”
Your hand runs over his cheek, and he turns his head to press a kiss to your palm, “Are you going to work the case?”
“I have to talk to my firm, see what everyone wants to do,” your fingers run over his face, “but if they do want me to handle the case, are you okay with that?”
“You know I can’t make that call for you,” his hand rests on the small of your back, “it’s yours to make, sweetheart.”
“But I don’t want to make it without knowing you’re okay with me working with him—” you lean down to press a kiss to his temple, “are you okay with it?”
“I am,” he says softly, “are you?”
“The firm needs the case — and this could be my shot at making partner,” his lips press butterfly kisses to your neck, and you sigh, “I don’t know what to do.”
“Sleep on it?” he murmurs against his skin, “always how the best decisions are made.”
“Says who?”
“Me,” he replies.
And you chuckle, noses brushing, as you lean closer, “As long it’s from a reliable source,” and your lips meet again, he pulls away, but you give chase, until you’re pressing him into the seat, fingers sliding along his shoulders, your hand finding the back of his neck, swallowing his moan with ease.
“Doll,” his lips are kiss ruined, eyes fluttering, and you trail kisses along his jaw, “you’ll be the end of me,”
And the double meaning isn’t lost on you — “I would be happy to end with you,”
He smiles, and it’s enough. For now. You rest your forehead against his for a moment in the relative silence, only broken by the hum of the fluorescents and the quiet sound of your breathing.
Until his stomach growls.
And you blink, a grin breaking across your lips, “Hungry?”
“It depends,” and you slide off his lap, offering your hand to him, and he cocks his head, “did you cook?”
You huff at him, “You’ll be glad to know I ordered takeout right before I got here,” and he gets to his feet, taking your hand, “but just for that, I’m cooking for the next week.”
“Oh, we’ll see about that,” he wraps his arm around you, grabbing his bag, before flicking off the light.
And after you got back to the apartment, eating dinner, and slipping into bed, you lied awake, his quiet snores filling your ears, and you turned to look at him — barely illuminated in the moonlight that peeked through the parted shutters. His eyes shut, his breathing steady, his freshly washed hair falling against his forehead.
You turn away, reaching for your phone — finding the email from Rafael, disclosing the details of the case — a question ending the email: Are you in?
And you glance back at Sonny — only you didn’t know the answer.
He was okay with you taking the case, right? You scoot a little closer, nestling yourself beside him a moment, he said he was okay with it.
You shut your eyes. He was okay, and you would be okay.
Right?
“Wow, this is a nice upgrade from your office at the D.A.’s,” Rafael remarks at your office door, taking a moment to examine the room.
You barely look up from your work — a dozen cases, associates’ work to check, and several arraignments to do, “That’s because someone took the only nice office, and stuck me in a closet off of yours,”
“Bureaucracy at work,” he replies, shutting your door and taking stock, “how’s defense work treating you?”
“The same way it has been I left the D.A.’s office,” you spare a small smile, “wonderfully.”
“Found your calling?” you shrug.
“You could say that,” you sigh, placing your pen down, “what about you?”
“What about me?” he raises an eyebrow, and you roll your eyes. Always had to work for it when it came to Rafael Barba.
“What have you been up to?”
“Looking something I lost a few years ago,” and you furrow your brow, and he smiles, “don’t flatter yourself, counselor — I meant a calling,”
Your cheeks burn, “You came to talk arraignment? Thought you could handle that yourself, Mr. Innocence Project,”
“I wanted to talk deal,” Rafael crossed his arms, “there was one thing I didn’t disclose to you in that email and that’s my meeting with Carisi,” and you blink, only you knew about that already, “I met with him yesterday — he offered man 2.”
Sonny didn’t mention that, but then again it was better that he didn’t, “But you don’t want to take it?”
“I don’t,” he slides into a chair, pulling a legal pad out, leg folded over his knee, “I think we can do better — I think we can get not guilty.”
You raise your brow, “Do you want to—”
“I want to go for jury nullification,” he crosses his arms, shrugging, “we have a strong case for it.”
“And we have a man who literally shot another point blank on security footage, and who brought a gun with him to court,” you shake your head, “we have to at least consider it,”
“What’s there to consider? Mr. Davis doesn’t want to take the deal,” and you pause, and Rafael nearly wavers, adding, “I may have discussed it with him—”
“Before asking me about it?”
“You only told me this morning you were on board,” Rafael holds up his hands, “I had a duty to relay it to him,”
“And what did he say?”
“He said he didn’t want to deal — he wanted his day in court,” he tilts his head.
“Did he? Or did you?”
“What are you implying?”
“Did he come to this conclusion on his own or did you help him along?” and he pauses — all the answer you needed, “Rafael, this is our client, we have to be realistic—”
“He’s a vet with—”
“Awards and a prosthetic leg I know, but he also could go to jail for murder — and never see his daughter again,” and he opens his mouth to speak, “so I’m asking you, are you taking this to trial for him or for you?”
His lips are a thin line, “First of all, this is for him — I wouldn’t take this trial if I didn’t think there wasn’t a good chance of winning and if I knew this wasn’t what he wanted,” and he sits up, “and what about you?”
“What about me?”
“Your firm probably wants this to go to trial — need the publicity of a trial for this to work — for you to get the break you need, isn’t it?” Rafael argues the same way he does in court — his words pointed and true, aimed for the chinks in someone’s armor, “sounds like we’re on the same page.”
You glare at him, “Don’t question my motives,”
“Then don’t question mine,” the words are terse, a period at the end of a paragraph that is still left hanging, until he chooses to start a new one, “Is this about the case? Or is this about us?”
You scoff, “So much for keeping it professional,”
Your name leaves his mouth soft, but firm, and your eyes meet his, “Is it going to be like this?” he asks, crossing his arms, “throughout the entire trial?”
“Like what?”
And he sighs, running a hand over his bristled chin, “I know I’ve made mistakes, I know, you know, but I can’t change what I’ve done,” his voice grows soft, “and I’m sorry, I wish I could — I wish I didn’t hurt you, but I did, and I take responsibility for that,” your gaze falls and he continues, “but if this is too hard, if you don’t want to do this, if you’re still angry, like you have every right to be—”
“I do,” the words leave your lips, “I do want to work with this case with you — it’s just—” you break off. You had meticulously tucked away any feelings for Rafael Barba away along with any reminder of him, including the man himself. It was easy, it was clearcut, but this wasn’t easy — because now your feelings were leaking, slipping from your careful control, and where there was a leak, there was a flood. And you were bound to get hurt.
“It’s hard,” he swallows, and you blink.
“It’s hard for you?” the words leave your lips harshly, and he flinches, “I didn’t mean—”
“No,” he gives a rueful smile, “I deserved that, after everything I put you through,” he shrugs, pressing his lips together, “I did love you, I did, I was just afraid.”
“What were you so afraid of?”
And he shakes his head, “I saw so many relationships fall apart around me — my own, my parents, our cases—” he breaks off, “I didn’t want us to hate each other, I didn’t want to regret you,” a bitter chuckle leaves his lips, “but you ended up regretting me.”
You frown, “I don’t regret you,” and his brow furrows, “You’re surprised by that?”
“If I were you...I’d regret me,” and you sigh, hands wringing under your desk.
“Rafael, I loved you, even though it hurt, I can’t regret that. Do I wish things turned out differently? Maybe, but,” your voice softens, glancing at the picture of Sonny on your desk, and you gesture around you, shrugging, “it also got me to where I am.”
And you know you should tell him — you should tell him that you’ve moved on, you should tell him that you’re with Sonny, but the words are lodged in the back of your throat, and you can’t bring yourself to say them before he’s already speaking.
“Well,” he clears his throat, licking his lips, before smiling, “I’m glad, for that much at least,” and he sits back again, “So—”
“So?”
“Are we taking this to trial?” and you bite your lip — jury nullification was a risky move — for both the policy ramifications and the risk involved — but, that wasn’t your responsibility anymore, your duty and your only duty is to your client.
“Are you sure this is what Mr. Davis wants?” and Rafael nods.
“I would give you his exact words, but there are some obscenities,” and you snort, shaking your head.
“And you’re sure about putting him on the stand?”
“Not at all,” he scoffs, “he’s questionable at best, and a loose cannon at worst.”
You rub your temples, “That’s going to play well during cross,”
“We’ll prep him well — let’s just get through arraignment,” he sighs, flipping to a fresh page, “Carisi is going to ask for remand, how should we play it?”
“We ask for R.O.R. — he’s a father of a young girl who was just raped and impregnated, he’s a decorated veteran who needs physical therapy, and he’s not a flight risk.”
Rafael chuckles, “And when we don’t get it?”
“Honestly, I’ll take anything over remand,” you pinch the bridge of your nose, “we should schedule a psych eval, start on gathering information on his tours, interview character witnesses and especially those who can testify to what he saw—” your words fall short when you see Rafael is smiling, “what?”
“Nothing,” he waves you off, pressing the tip of his pen to his lips, “Go on.”
And you blink, before going on — not noticing the way his smile returned when your eyes fell away.
Running late from the office — be there soon. Your text comes in just as Sonny’s food arrives at the table, and he’s about to order for you when a voice draws his attention away.
“Mr. Carisi,” Sonny’s head snaps up his phone to find Jack McCoy smiling at him, “am I interrupting?”
His mouth is dry, and he shakes his head, “No, not at all,” he gestures for him to join him, and Jack does, not bothering to look at a menu, “so I suppose this isn’t a social call?”
“I wanted to ask your progress on the Davis case,” he crosses his arms.
And he blinks, wondering why he hadn’t bothered to ask whether you had told his boss if a) you two were dating, and b) if he knew you were on this case, “Discovery is ongoing — I’ve handed my materials over per the new discovery rules within 15 days, and now I’m waiting on the defense to turn over their evidence.”
Jack shakes his head, “New York law catching up with the modern days — a damn fine day for defense attorneys — before we could sandbag the day before, not that I ever did that,” he gives a wry smile, before his eyes fall to Sonny’s phone, vibrating, “you need to get that?”
“No, sir,” Sonny waves it off, “What’s your interest in the Davis case?”
“Well, I am your boss, I’m interested in all your cases,” he replies, before smiling, “I did hear who the defense attorneys for the case are.”
And Sonny picks at his food, “Oh?”
“I am just curious how prepared you are to tackle a case against both of your old mentors,” Jack says, as Sonny chooses then to sip at his drink, “and your partner for that matter.”
He chokes, “Who—”
“It was obvious — at least to me,” Jack shrugs, “don’t pretend you haven’t heard the rumors about me,” he adds, furrowing his brow, “one piece of advice, son—”
“We are planning on disclosing to the judge—”
“Not that,” he says sharply, “you’ve been good together — the two of you. But it’s easy to let a case get between you,”
“Is this about Diana Hawthorne?”
And Jack raises an eyebrow, “Did—”
“Rumor mill isn’t just about me, sir,” he shrugs, “I heard it a while ago, that case was tough,”
“Made tougher by our relationship,” he sighs, “I think sometimes if we hadn’t been together, maybe things—” he cuts off, “my point is, you two have done a good job of keeping professional and personal from mixing so far, but when you both start bringing this case home—”
“We won’t,” Sonny says, and Jack raises an eyebrow, “we won’t.”
And Jack relaxes, before shoving his hands in his pockets, “How long have you two been—”
“Over a year now,” Jack smiles softly.
“Are you both happy?”
And is he happy? When he’s with you, he feels at peace for once — the world and its horrors slipping away, until he feels nothing but you in his arms. You challenge him to grow — even when he doesn’t want to. And he would do anything for you — he would give you the life you wanted, give the family you want, give you his best — if only he could give you the same peace you give him.
“We are,” Sonny smiles softly, hand slipping into his pocket, thumbing the ring box in his pocket, “in fact—”
“Hey,” you arrive, glancing between him and Jack, furrowing your brow — and he knows you hadn’t told Jack, “Jack, Sonny — what a—”
“Cat’s out of the bag, sweetheart,” Sonny slips his arm around your waist, and you tilt your head, before realization washes over you, relaxing into his touch, “care to join us?”
“You’ll be joining him,” Jack slips from the booth, “like I said, this wasn’t a social call,” he smiles between the two of you, “we should set up a lunch.”
“Will do,” you nod, “I’ll call you."
With a nod, he leaves, and you slip into the booth beside him, "Hi," you kiss him, "menu?"
"I would have ordered for you, but I got interrupted,” and you bump his shoulder.
You snort, “I wouldn’t have ordered if my boss was grilling me about my relationship,”
“You didn’t tell him?
“Should I have?” he’s frowning, and you’re shaking your head, “it’s not that I didn’t want to,” you bite your lip, “sorry, I’m not explaining this well,” you sigh, placing the menu down, “it’s just Jack had me and Rafael figured out from the second we…”
Sonny is shaking his head, sipping at his drink, “Yeah, well looks like not much has changed,”
“Well, he didn’t exactly approve of me and Rafael, which is why I was worried what he’d say to you,” you purse your lips, shifting in your seat, “did he say anything?”
Sonny pauses, “No I don’t think so,” and Sonny’s biting back a smile, remembering Jack’s words — he approved.
And now you’re bumping his shoulder, “Why so smug, counselor?”
“No reason,” and you’re stealing one of his fries, “I’m just glad I’m not on his bad side.”
“No one would want to be,” you say as the waiter comes order, taking your order, as well as the menu from your hand.
“Did you tell him?”
“Jack? I just told—”
“No, I mean,” he licks his lips, “did you tell Rafael that we were dating?”
And he was hoping he wouldn’t see your brow knit together like that, see your fingers wringing in your lap, “I didn’t,”
His mouth is dry, and he’s turning his body to face you, “Why?”
“I didn’t know how to bring it up — to just say, ‘by the way, I’m dating Sonny, just thought you should know,’” and doubt begins to creep in, “we were trying to keep things professional—”
“I understand,” and your lips are twisting and he knows you don’t believe him — hell, he doesn’t believe him.
“Do you want me to tell him?” and he doesn’t know what to say — he wants him to know, but why does he want him to know? You weren’t his property — he didn’t own you, he knew you wouldn’t do anything. He trusted you.
Didn’t he?
“I’ll tell him, Sonny,” and Sonny’s gaze snaps to you, “he’s picking up files from me at the office, and I’ll let him know—” Sonny opens his mouth, but you cut him off with his lips, “we have to disclose to the judge on Monday anyway before jury selection, it’s necessary.”
“I don’t want to make you—”
“I know,” you silence him with another kiss, soft, comforting, and his guilt settles, instead peace seeps in, “I love you.”
“I love you too,” his heart warms, as the waitress brings over your meal, and Sonny’s check, and he checks his watch, “and I gotta go. See you tonight?” and you shake your head.
“I got to work late tonight and I have arraignments early in the morning — but I get off early tomorrow and I’ll be waiting to make it up to you,” you kiss him again, before pressing chaste kisses along his jaw.
“Looking forward to that,” and he wants to ask — ask why you won’t consider moving in, why you brush it off, and the question burns on his lips, until the words are seared into his tongue — but he doesn’t, “call me?”
“I will,” and he kisses you one last time, before slipping from the booth.
And he wonders, fingers finding the velvet box in his pocket — if you won’t move in with him, will you even marry him?
Can you do me a favor? Rafael’s text comes in as soon as you’re leaving from court, and you’re sighing at your phone screen.
And another: Please?
He really must be desperate. What’s up?
Can you drop the files off somewhere for me? I can’t make it to your office today — something came up.
Is something wrong?
Only with my mother’s cable service — they were supposed to be by today to disconnect the service.
You snort, Then sue them.
Civil is not my area of expertise, and then he adds, but I may be willing to learn if they take any longer. Can you please drop the files off?
You raise an eyebrow — ‘please’ — he really must be desperate.
You bite your lip — you wanted to get home early, but you also needed to tell Rafael about you and Sonny. You glance at the time, sighing, before replying to him.
I’ll drop by with the files — text me the address now.
A tax ride later — you had arrived at a place you thought you would never be again. You couldn’t but stare at the door of Lucia’s place. You had been here five years ago — first and last time you had met his mother. And it was the first time you had realized you had to break up with Rafael.
It was over the moment you left here — even though neither of you wanted to admit it. His kisses could no longer patch your heart because it was no longer cracked — it was broken.
But it didn’t make it any easier to leave him.
You shake yourself from your thoughts, knocking on the door — but you had.
And so did he.
You hear his voice from within the apartment — a muffled coming — and some stumbling, until finally you hear the telltale sounds of the chain, bolt, and locks.
He opens the door, wiping his face with a towel — and he’s clean shaven. And you blink — he smiles at you, the very same smile he always gave you, “You shaved,”
“And you’re observant,” and he finds you staring at him, “Does it look bad?”
“No, no,” he steps aside, letting you inside the apartment, before shutting the door and locking it, “you look good.”
And his lips are curving in a grin now, “I look good?”
Your cheeks burn — always a dog with a bone, “Don’t push your luck, Barba,”
“Ouch,” he snorts, “you used to be much more accommodating to my self-esteem.”
“That was when I worked with you,” you cross your arms, taking a survey of the apartment — more boxes than apartment at this point, you could barely take a step before tripping, “men work better with their ego stroked,” You find your way to the kitchen table — his makeshift office from the looks of it — complete with two cups of coffee, “Old habits die hard, huh?”
“They often do,” he sips at the coffee, holding it by the rim with the tips of his fingers, “everyone is allowed to have their vices.”
“And here is your other one—” you pull the files from your bag, “I brought everything you asked for — you should be well prepped for jury selection.”
He nods, flipping through the materials, “You’ll be there right?”
“Of course,” you blink, “any reason you ask?”
“I may run a little late on Monday, but it shouldn’t be an issue—” Rafael waves it off, before setting it down, “can I make you a cup of coffee to thank you?”
You offer a small smile, “No, I probably should get home, but I’ll see you on Monday,” and you swallow your nerves, squeezing the handle of your bag, “but there is something I wanted to tell you—”
And that’s when you hear the lock clicking, “Rafi, how many times have I told you to just leave the door unlocked?” heels clicking against the hardwood, arms full of bags. Rafael slips from his chair, rounding the kitchen table.
“And how many times have I told you that’s not safe?” he replies, taking the bags from her arms, and then she spots you, blinking, “Mami, you remember—”
“Oh!” she walks over, pulling you into a tight hug, “it’s so wonderful to see you again, dear,”
“Lucia, it’s great to see you too,” you smile, awkwardness smoothed over the warmth of her smile, as her hands found yours, squeezing, “it’s been far too long.”
“I’ll say,” she shoots a glare at her son, before her eyes find yours and soften again, “I had warned him not to let you get away, and did he listen?”
Rafael is rubbing his temple, “Mami, please—”
“Oh,” she looks between the two of you, raising a brow, “if you’re here does that mean—”
“No,” he clears his throat, the tips of his ears red now, “I told you we’re on this case together. I needed some files dropped off—”
“You must join us for lunch,” and both you and Rafael open your mouths, “I insist, please. This will be the last time for a while I will be up north for a bit. Let me impose.”
And your eyes flicker between Rafael and his mother, before Rafael speaks, “We can’t impose on any plans—”
“I’ll stay,” and his eyes fall on you, as your phone feels heavier in your pocket with guilt — knowing you would be late, “it’s fine, how can I say no?”
Lucia squeezes your hand. And how could you say no to this?
After lunch, you’re helping Lucia clean up, when Rafael is in the bathroom, washing the dishes while she dried, “Are you looking forward to moving down to Florida?”
“I am, even though I’ll miss my work and my students,” she sighs, her shoulders much lighter, “I don’t want to spend the rest of my life living the same — I want to have time for myself, I want to experience new things, not like my mother,” her voice grows smaller, the plates clinking in the dish rack, “I don’t know how much Rafael told you about her—”
“I knew that she had passed, while Rafael and I were together,” he had been a mess — he wasn’t sleeping, he was barely eating, you had to ply him to get him away from the office —- when he wasn’t working, he was drinking. He had blamed himself for his grandmother’s death for so long — and even now you wondered if he had ever stopped, “she was a wonderful woman.”
“I wish you could have met her,” she sniffs, “she would have loved you,” and you nod, silent, and you feel her eyeing you, “what happened with you and Rafi anyway?”
“It just didn’t work out,” you knew she wasn’t going to let it go that easily.
“You two loved each other,” Lucia replies, “that just doesn’t go away.”
And you did — you had loved him, you would have married him, you would have started a family with him — but he didn’t want that. And you did.
“It doesn’t,” you wanted to brush it off, you wanted to tell her you were with someone else, you wanted to say something to make her stop pushing, but you couldn’t, “I did love your son, Lucia. I really did, but it wasn’t the right time for us.”
“You made him happy—happier than I’ve ever seen him, even now,” and you meet her gaze, “you can’t tell me you don’t feel something for him now? Can you?”
And you waver, no words coming to mind, “Lucia, I—”
But then the bathroom door is creaking open, and you jolt, continuing to wash dishes, tongue tied and cheeks burning in shame — why didn’t you mention Sonny? Why didn’t you just tell her you loved someone else? But another question nagged at you, as the object of the question appeared before you — and you turned at the sound of your name to find him smiling at you.
Why couldn’t you say that you didn’t have feelings for Rafael?
“Ma, we should probably let your hostage go now,” he tilts his head, hands in his pockets, “I’m sorry if we stepped on your plans—”
You clear your throat, “No, no, it’s fine—” And you move to grab your coat and bag, “but I really should get going.”
Lucia holds out her arms, wrapping you in a hug, “It was wonderful to see you dear,”
“You too,” you smiled, despite the interrogation that rivaled your son’s, “if I don’t see you again, please have a safe trip to Florida,”
“Thank you, and good luck on your case,” she presses a kiss to your cheek, as Rafael stands by, arms crossed.
“I’ll walk you out,” he nods at his mom, before slipping out of the apartment with you, as the door clicks behind you, and he walks you to the elevator, “I’m sorry my mom shanghaied you—”
“It’s fine,” you wave him off, as you press the call button, “I enjoy being shanghaied when it involves your mom’s cooking,”
“But still, I don’t want you to think that was my intention—”
“Rafael?” you cut him off, “it’s fine.”
And the elevator dings, the doors sliding open, “Are you sure?”
You smile at him, sighing, stepping in, “If it’s not, I’ll just sue you,” and he scoffs, “I’ll see you Monday, Raf.”
The nickname slips out before you can help it, and the doors close shut, as you step back, back of your head leaning against the wall.
What the fuck were you doing?
~~~
Rafael slips back inside, shutting the door behind him, “So what was that stunt you pulled to get—”
“How much of our conversation did you hear?” Lucia replies, wiping her hands off, and crossing her arms. His gaze softens, “you still have a chance, mijo.”
“Mami—”
She finds her way over to her son, “Do you miss—”
He sighs, “You know I do,” but he shakes his head, turning away from her, “but it’s over, I can’t cross that line again—”
“Can’t or won’t?” she places her hands on her hips, “you heard us — couldn’t deny having feelings for you still, and you — I’ve seen you since you’ve been working the case, you’re happier.”
And he doesn’t want to admit it — it hurt to see you again, after you had rejected him, but more because of the way he had treated you. You were a reminder of yet another way he had failed, but also a reminder that he wanted to be so much better. And he did, and he was.
He wasn’t the same person — he had grown, and so had you.
And maybe, for once the timing was right — your mouth wrapped around his nickname, the way it used to be, still ringing in his ears.
He turns to face his mother, “Now I’ll ask one more time, did you hear our conversation?”
And he smiles, “I heard everything.”
And he knew what he had to do.
“Where is your co-counsel?” Judge Harper asks sharply, and you stand twisting your fingers, “Counselor—”
“I apologize, Your Honor,” you are texting Rafael for the sixth time, asking him where he is, “Mr. Barba is not responding to my attempts to get into contact with him. He had told me he may be a little late—” not twenty minutes late, but— “if you could give us a few more minutes—”
“The People have no objection,” Sonny adds, sparing you a sympathetic look.
“Even so, this is wasting the jurors’ time,” Judge Harper sighs, “Can you proceed without him?”
Fuck — you still needed to disclose to Judge Harper.
Proceeding without disclosure would be a violation of your duties, and your eyes slide to Sonny who purses his lips, not to mention Sonny’s. Well no time like the present, “Yes, but I would like to enter chambers before then,”
Judge Harper blinks, but agrees, rising to enter her chambers, and just as you round the defense table, Rafael arrives through the double doors, harried and rushing, “I apologize, Your Honor, I—”
And he's glancing at all of you on your feet, halfway across the courtroom floor, and Judge Harper speaks first, "You're just in time to join us in chambers, counselor,”
Rafael’s eyes flicker between you and Sonny, a questioning brow raised, but he follows, and your heart sinks.
Fuck.
He needed to know — you just didn’t want him to find out this way. You had opportunities — you had your chance, and you had lost it.
Just like he lost his — with you.
The doors close behind you, as Judge Harper settles behind her desk for a moment, “Now, what is this about?”
The uncomfortable feeling of everyone’s gaze settles over you, and Rafael’s gaze feels sharper than the others.
But why did it feel sharper?
It had been years since you had been together, years since you had ever— and why would he care if you were dating Carisi? Why did it feel like his gaze was carving into your mind and he could see the truth written across your forehead? But you still didn’t know — you didn’t know why you cared.
Why did you care?
Your throat was tight, and you still couldn’t think of an answer to your own question.
“I wanted to disclose something — something that’s already been disclosed to my client with his consent in writing from the very start,” you swallow the lump in your throat, unable to meet Rafael’s eyes,
“We wanted to disclose,” Sonny cuts in, “We were waiting for the trial to start, since we didn’t find any need to disclose to the arraignment judge, since Mr. Barba and I handled that.”
“Disclose what?” And you still can’t bring yourself to look at Rafael.
You hand her the paperwork, glancing at Sonny, “I’m currently in a relationship with A.D.A. Carisi.”
197 notes
·
View notes