Hiya traffic folks!

I wanna do an AITA styled stream where the prompts / scenarios are from different life members POVs of any season

If there's any you'd like to submit feel free to comment on this or use the tag trafficaita

I realised too late that twitter wasn't the best place to ask as they could only do the title and not elaborate with the proper story

Fire away, it should be fun 😁

woah crazy story

(text version below)

AITA for killing my boss even though he asked (before anyone comes for me he’s fine now)

so i (33M, green) got hired by this guy (45M, green now red) running an enchanting business because i accidentally used his things when i saw his stuff laying around as he was still working on his shop. i was just in it to sort of repay the service i used but then we became friends. thing is he also had these really sketchy guys from the desert that wanted to undercut him hard by taking over the business and all his enchants, and they would keep perstering him about it, breaking and entering, etc etc (my boss wasn't the type of guy to stick up for himself very much so it kind of happened a lot).

but the big thing was when they planted a bomb at the entrance to the building where the shop was. this pissed my boss off a lot because they made him go from green to yellow, and he said he had a plan, but he wouldn't tell me what it was.

and then one day he comes out with a really nice axe that he gifts me (i thought it was cool) but then it turns out he'd basically built a sacrificial altar in the patio outside the shop (not cool). then he turns to me, and asks me to kill him. i didn't want to do it because i'm green and he's yellow but he's also my boss and im supposed to listen, and then he's also my friend so i decided to trust him on this and so i just went along and cut off his head.

and now EVERY friend of my boss is blowing up my messages asking why i did that. i tried to say that i had no choice because he literally told me to do it and he's just on red now, not permadead, but nobody wants to believe me and i think there's someone already coming over. they're my boss' friends but also if they try to get at me i will fight back. but also it would make my boss upset and he trusts me a lot. i feel bad for killing my boss but he told me to do it so i don't think it's wrong?

aita?

AITA for celebrating my friend's wife died?

I swear its not what it sounds like!

So a year or two ago I(27M) was put into a sort of hunger games type of death game along with some other people. We have 3 or more lives and once we lose our last one we're out, however every new season we come back and have to play again.

The thing is, I'm out first every single time! It's not funny anymore, I feel cursed, and apparently I am? The eldritch angel beings that watch over us and plan the games seem to have gotten angry at me after a couple friends and I tried to rebel agaisnt them in season 0.

That was until recently, when, in the current season, my friend(30M)'s wife(31F) was eliminated before I was! Apparently she was trying to lure someone into the End with her to push them off into the void? But ended up falling in herself. A bit of an L if I'm being honest :/

Like you could imagine, I was ECSTATIC, it meant the curse was broken! So I was celebrating around, chanting "[friend's wife] is death!" over and over again, and everyone seemed to be happy for me too!

I announced I'd throw a big party next week to celebrate, and thats when I realized my friend wasn't happy at all, in fact he was quite pissed... I think I upset him even worse with my reaction. But no one else seemed to really care anyways! Still, he hasn't talked to me ever since, and I don't really know what to do... Should I go on with the party to celebrate my victory anyways? This is a big thing for me...

AITA??

AITA for accidentally killing a depressed woman?

Now, I know how the title sounds, but hear me out. For context, we are all in a death game and everybody gets three lives. I (27M) was on my third life. I was just hanging out with my friend Martyn (33M) when we saw a skeleton horse that clearly had an invisible rider on it. We were curious as to who was riding the horse, and so I figured the best way to find out was to punch the invisible rider. So I did just that, but apparently the rider was on two and a half hearts. They died. It turned out to be Lizzie (31F). She had been on her second life, but I had just accidentally put her on her third. That isn't even the worst part. It turns out she had thrown herself a birthday party, and invited the whole server to it (including me), but only her husband had shown up. After that disaster, she was miserable, so she decided to take an invis potion and ride on a skeleton horse to not only cheer herself up, but to make others laugh, too. I ended up killing a woman who had been at her lowest. I feel awful. It truly was an accident, but what do you guys think? AITA?

AITA for not realising who my soulmate was?

To preface this, I don't think I'm the AITA, but my soulmate seems to.

So I (M) am in one of those death games, but that isn't really important. In this death game, we are all partnered up with another player. I wasn't interested in finding my soulmate as I wanted to prioritise other things, such as a good base. I ended up travelling with 3 of the other players, J (M), E (M), and G (M). It may be important to note that J and E are soulmates.

After a trip to a pillagers base, I gained a new allay friend (F). Later on, this friend ended up flying away. I had started taking some damage, but I brushed it off as J joking along with others. Then I heard G screaming. At the time, I didn't realise it was due to him realising he was my soulmate. However, in hindsight, I can realise that I should have realised what was happening. G ended up sticking with me after J and E went their own separate way, but we ended up going a different way, too. I ended up finding some pandas that looked identical to my cat (F). Of course, I got attached to these and wanted to keep them. G ended up finding me again and was trying to tell me something. However, the cat-pandas were taking my attention, which G could clearly see. He asked for my attention, which I tried to give him, but those cat-pandas ended up distracting me again. G yelled at me, causing me to pay full attention.

G dropped a rock onto my head. This is what caused me to realise we were linked. G couldn't believe that I had no clue, but I genuinely did not know. He seems to still not be happy with me because of this.

So, AITA? If so, what can I do?

Edit 1: For anyone asking if G would have a reason for not wanting to be my soulmate, I can only think of one thing. In the first death game, G tried to play a prank on a group of me and our friends. However, this backfired and killed me. This put me down to my yellow life, and it was the first death in the server. G felt bad and apologised. He ended up apologising and giving his first life to me (EDIT 2: why is everyone saying this is gay?). I ended up in an accident, which put me down to my red life. We ended up in a war, but that's irrelevant right now. Even after he lost his first life, he stuck with me (EDIT 3: guys why is this also gay) Later on, I ended up killing him, putting him down to his red life. G felt betrayed (rightfully so), so I offered my life to him. He refused to kill me. However, the eldritch horror gods demanded a fight between us. So we ended up fighting in a cacti ring with no weapons, armour, or anything. He won and killed me. He then ended up killing himself. G ended up telling me that he wanted nothing to do with me in the next game. To be honest, that hurt. But that can be the only thing I can think of.

UPDATE: Hi guys. Sorry to say, but this is not a happy update. G had been very distant recently, and I didn't know what I could do to help. I didn't know if it was me not knowing we were soulmates or me slipping up with the paper sales we had been doing.

While on my horse (Horse), I ending up passing G and another friend, whom I will refer to as B (M). They were passing items between each other and were really close. This was odd due to B being a red life. Through the knowledge of some other players, I figured out that G, MY soulmate, was baking bread for another man. G and B were self-proclaimed secret soulmates.

I don't know what to do now. Any advice would be appreciated.

AITA for committing mass arson after my ship was burned down?

I (age is irrelevant, M) spent a lot of time building a ship for my soulmate (age is irrelevant, M). We aren't soulmates by choice, exactly, but we've grown to like each other and we work pretty well together. But anyways, the ship was built entirely out wood planks and I made it all by myself. I named it the Relation Ship because I'm just so witty like that. So clever and tall and handsome, but I digress, that's not the point of this post.

I put a lot of my blood, sweat and tears into that ship—not literally, though, that's disgusting—and somebody decided to burn it down!

Well, I came up with a new motto: "ship burns, everything burns" and I pulled out a flint and steel and started lighting everything ablaze. Very quickly, the world became nothing but a scorched wasteland! And, well, people are upset about it. But I doubt they're even half as upset as I am now that my ship is gone.

I've yet to find the person who burned for my ship, but once I do, I'm showing them no mercy...

But am I really the asshole here? Personally, I think that they're getting what they deserve.

Am I the asshole for not dying?

I (M, 27), am a pretty clumsy guy, and tend to be the butt of the joke since I keep dying first in my friend group’s death games. In the last game, I didn’t die first- yay! Some guy’s wife went first, and the guy got mad at me for celebrating my life? I literally did nothing wrong, my friends are just mad that they can’t keep making fun of me, I think. Everyone wants to see me lose, but I kind of think I might win this thing! Wish me luck.

AITA for gaslighting an entire server for no real reason?

So it all started at the beginning, where I got a secret task to quote "dig a big hole, all the way down, at least 3x3, make it your base if you want"

So I do as I'm tasked and begin to dig, when my friend (who I will refer to as Big Dog) found me in the middle of my hole. He asked what I was doing and I panicked. I didn't want him to guess, so I flat out lied and said I was just mining. Then my other friend G came along and I told him that I was digging a tunnel to the secret keeper.

After that, it all just spiraled out of control. Any questions asked of me I would lie about. If Big Dog asked for an ally's location, I'd send him the opposite way. If someone needed materials, I'd lie that I was fresh out. I started putting signs in G's egg base that said I was watching him.

I kept digging holes, and made an underground series of tunnels with no purpose other than to confuse and unnerve those who entered.

I think I even began believing my own lies...I'm starting to suspect Bartholomew and Bob are just armor stands with pumpkin heads...

AITA for gaslighting everyone for an entire series? Or was I just playing the game?

AITA for murdering my best friend and some other random dude in cold blood?

So I (33M) am besties with this one guy (27M) who I think is a fish- but that's not really relevant. Let's call him S. Anyway, S and I had been living together for a couple weeks, and I think he was really starting to trust me. I mean, to be fair, I'm a pretty loyal guy- or at least, that's what my old boyfriend (41M) used to tell me all the time. I guess we're technically still dating, but I haven't seen him in a while...

Anyway, so I glommed onto S, and we became best friends pretty quickly. There's a bit of context needed for the next bit- see, we've all kinda been tossed into this hunger games-esque death game thing a couple times now, and this was the fourth run. S had already won one of the past death games, and I'd almost won a few at this point, so I was going to do whatever I could to win. And in this one, the deal was that we got 24 hours to live. Every time we died, we'd lose an hour off our timer, and every time we killed someone, we'd gain thirty.

So we killed a lot of people, right? Killed a lot of people a lot of times. S and I made a great team, I'll admit it, and I kinda did enjoy having him around. But it got to the point when he, the random dude mentioned in the title (42M, let's call him V), and I were the only ones left alive. S proposed an honorable duel, because that's just kinda the vibe he tends to go with- he's really into the idea of fairness and sticking it to the man and that kinda thing, so where these death games are supposed to be chaotic and bloody, he tries to make them as neat and orderly as possible. Which I'll be honest, isn't really my thing.

So I agree. But then, as soon as S and V have taken their armor off, I pull out a bucket of lava from behind my back and burn them alive. I feel kind of bad for betraying S, but it's a death game, and he honestly shouldn't have been so trusting- in my opinion.

But yeah, I really need to know.

AITA???

AITA for ditching my soulmate?

About a year or two ago I (28m) entered this hunger games type of thing where we all battled to the death. We had like, three lives and each time we died we went down another color. The catch was that our lives were linked to another person, like a soulmate situation (we all ended up agreeing to call each other soulmates so I'm gonna keep using that throughout this post).

So, at the start of the game, we all went around looking for who our soulmate was. Any group I went into, we tested if they were my soulmate, and every time it was no. I did end up pairing with my friend who we'll call ZC (42f), but we weren't soulmates. I ended up getting really worried about how everyone else is getting paired up. But, I kinda thought that I would just stick with ZC anyways, unless they found her soulmate and wanted to stick with them.

Eventually me and ZC figured out who our soulmates would've been, P (27f) and M(33m). Both of them went to the nether and since everyone else had found their soulmates except us, we assumed they were our soulmates. I was just so upset, they had left everyone to go off into the nether, not even caring to try to find who they were soulmates with.

Then P and M came back to the overworld and called everyone who hadn't gotten a soulmate (which was only me and ZC) to a specific area. M had us play a game to figure out who's as who's soulmate, and when P jumped and I took damage, we already knew. But me and ZC had decided to just stick together since we were both upset about P and M leaving, so we both ditched them to live on our own.

Then a little later, I get news that M had left P and now she was posing as a red name, and people were calling her scarlet [name]. She would also force me to take damage by putting herself in snow or up to a cactus, and it was just torture to have to deal with her. It wasn't my fault that she couldn't care less about finding a soulmate!

We won the game in the end, and I let her win fully by blowing myself up. But I just still wonder, was I in the wrong for leaving her? She left me in the beginning, I was only letting her feel how I felt. I just worry that now I'M the bad guy for leaving her and making her become chaotic. AITA?

AITA for embracing the game masters' implied wishes and becoming the villain of the game?

So, I (30M) am in this game where we have to survive, and do the game master tasks to regain health. We are given 3 lives and as you lose lives, you become a bit more unhinged and dangerous. So far, I've been trying to make friends/allies, to prepare for the oncoming wars, but every time i make some progress, my current task ruins it. the first time this happened, i half to do the opposite of what people told me to do, and the others were all telling me to do things like give them some healing and sparing their cows. the second time, the game master was just blatant about it: "Become the villain of the server... You pass if you are actively disliked by the majority of other players". with that task, i went all out, even going so far as to burn the task book one of the other players was trying to give me. Then my very next task is to sabotage 3 players' , who are on their final lives, bases.

I mean its not my fault right? I'm forced to do what my task tells me. but NOO, even though they know that, I'm still on my own. We are approaching the endgame at this point, and everyone is on their last life, and i still have no allies. so i though "why not embrace the villain role that the game master has been pushing on me". That's what the game master wanted right? I'm not an AH for doing this right? pls tell me, i really need to know.

AITA??

AITA for torturing my soulmate after he ditched me?

I know how the title sounds, but bare with me for a second.

So for context, a couple months ago I (27F) was put in a hunger games sort of death game with a couple friends where we'd have a random amouth of lives assigned to us and the last one standing would win. We could gift eachother lives or trade with them. To make it short, I got 6 lives, putting me in dark green, but my ally (28M), let's call him S, got 2, and was on his yellow life. So we partnered up and I ended up gifting him TWO of my lives this season, and we became best friends.

The problem started about a month ago, after he won last season and we moved into the next one, yet another death game, this time with only 3 lives each, however, there was a twist. Basicly we were all soulbounded to another person there, and when one took damage their soulmate did aswell.

Everyone went on their own separate ways, looking for resources to start off and testing if anyone they met along the way was their soulmate or not. I did this aswell! And ended up sticking around my friend M (33M). We separate for a little bit, and when I find him again M asks me if I wanna go to the NETHER with him. Worst. Mistake. Of. My. Life.

But I thought "Yeah, a quick trip to the Nether cant hurt, as long as we're careful, our soulmates wont mind!", thats where I was WRONG. Once we got back we called over everyone else in the server who hadn't found their soulmates yet, and two people quickly arrived, S and C (42F), both of which were my friends and allies from the first season! M made us play a little game called "Lost and Bound", or would've if we hadn't figured out early who my soulmate was, when a goat attacked S.

Turns out S was my soulbound and C was M's! And they weren't very happy about our little adventure. They called us cheaters, told us we abandoned them, said they'd be eachothers soulmates, and practically broke up with us… in a soulbound way? They also claimed to HATE us for just a small Nether trip. I was heartbroken I'm ngl. My two best friends and past allies, abandoned me just like that, and claimed I was the cheater!

Not only that, but M was quick to ditch me aswell! He even said he blamed me for it. After that I was left alone with my precious dog Tilly (??F), I built a tower alone since I had nobody left with me. But guess what? Everyone started calling me a WITCH and S stared acting like I was some sort of "crazy ex girlfriend".

This is where I feel like I might've been wrong with how I acted. So my other friend, lets call him R(41M), gave me the idea of taking small amounts of damage to "torture" S. I know its bad, but I was very angry at him for what he'd done and said at the time. So I took R up on it and accepted his powdered snow gift, I'd chill on it often to "tickle" S and scare him a little bit. I'd do this almost every day, sometimes standing next to a cactus aswell once I got one.

But in the end, M, C, S and I teamed up together until we all turned red. From then on I kind of went all in at C and might've sent my pack of dogs after her… and of course killed M in the process. Then S told me to meet him where it all started, before blowing himself up with tnt to let me take the win.

It's been a bit since that happened and we're probably gonna start another of these games soon. I've forgiven him for what he did, and it seems like he did aswell, but… I cant help but feel a bit guilty for all that pain I put him through. AITA?

Edit: I also forgot to mention how C tried to burn my dog?? So I was also very pissed at her about it.

AITA for fishing up a pair of soulmates?

Before we start, we share our health with another person and we call them our 'soulmate'. A little more info, I (f26) got paired up with S (m27) but our relationship isn't the best. We keep hurting each other whenever we can. Every morning, he would take an axe crit just to spite me and in return I get reckless with my own health. Now, when I was walking to this party in someone's house, I noticed that S was already there and I wanted to scare him by being reckless, so I jumped from a high place to hurt the two of us. That's when I noticed that someone (m29) is trying to fish me up into the air with his fishing rod. We'll call this man G from now. This gave me an idea, a new way to scare S. I asked G to fish me high in the air and it was very fun watching S trying to soften the blow! We did it over and over until S got tired of saving me. Coincidentally another pair, J (m29) and E (m??), had just showed up and they seemed so keen on playing with the fishing rod. It gave me a new idea. I asked G to connect his fishing rod to me while mine is connected to J so that when I'm up in the air, I can pull my fishing rod and fish J even higher! We tried that trick and it worked, so we wanted to try it again with more people! This time, the chain goes like this: G -> J -> me -> E -> another person (m40). Let me remind you that we were all aware that we share our health with our 'soulmate'. After J got fished up, I fished E up and that was when we all just remembered that J and E's health are synced up, so they'll be taking double the damage. We realized that too late and they died upon impact. Somehow J and E blamed me and G for their death even though J and E chose to participate with no pressure from us! AITA?

AITA for killing my Dad?

I know the title sounds bad, but hear me out.

So I (M) have been put into a death game for the fifth time in a row. In the last game, I teamed up with my family, my mother (Z (for Zombie)), and my brother (M). My father (M) decided to team with some other people. I felt like he abandoned us.

Fast forward to the next game. My mother and father teamed up, but I was all alone and without any allies. The new participant for this game (F) got a task that she had to complete, saying that she was a boogeyman. This meant she had to kill others, and they had to kill others too. I ended up getting killed due to this. Because of that, I needed to kill someone to complete the task. I may have still been holding a grudge from the last season, so I targeted my father. I ended up killing him with a diamond sword. No one really blamed me, but being completely alone made me think about it a lot.

So, AITA?

Update 1: I killed him again.

Update 2: I killed him again for the last time. He won't be coming back. He was begging to go home. Should have thought about that before ruining my own home.

Update 3: Killed my mother, too. Shouldn't have teamed with my father.

AITA for taking off my clothes all the time?

I (2X male) was put into a death game by a bunch of furry gods and it's been fun but holy moly, is it hot out there! I'm a hot, sexy, sexyman with rocking hard abs and a tiny little waist that NEEDS to be flaunted or else I'll perish. My partner for most of the games has been a little gremlin of a pesky bird that keeps on screaming to me to "PUT MY CLOTHES BACK ON" but frankly i dont get why he complains so much, as it is just way too hot, hot damn, call the police the fireman. I make a dragon wanna retire man, it's too hot! Hot damn. Plus, I'm pretty sure behind the scenes everyone is thanking whatever gods are out there that I keep on showing off my pecs. Though, to be frank, I've started to rethink if maybe I'm doing more harm than good by flaunting my magnificence, though I'm not sure. Should I truly listen to my partner's and "Put my clothes back on"?

Am I the asshole for gaslighting other couples to try and break them up?

Title sounds bad, let me explain. Me (M, 42) and my new husband (M, 41) are in a hunger games-style game where our lives and damage are linked to another person. Me and my new husband, let’s call him B, want to win, and B suggested that we gaslight all the other couples/soulmates into thinking the other person said bad things about them. I think it’s justified because we want to win and our house is better then everyone else’s anyway, but everyone seems to be mad at us.

Edit: actually I think no one believes us, and someone made fun of B to his face just now