Bro I’m laughing so hard at the implications of Witchcraft Shelby and ESMP Shelby being the same person.
Because Scott and Joey are also in Witchcraft.
And I don’t think knowing both Witchcraft and Chromia Scott would be that strange. They’re INCREDIBLY DIFFERENT, in personality and looks. So it’d be like “oh I know another person named Scott” which isn’t that out of the ordinary.
But Joey? Like yeah, he’s not a pirate. But they’re far more similar, and she knew Empires Joey WAY better than Empires Scott.
So, imagine you get called to compete to be the next supreme witch, so you move your house, go to (presumably) a different continent.
And one of the other contestants is looks and acts... exactly like your best friend from home. You ask for their name- and they have the same name.