Favorite girl part2? I beg
𝐅𝐀𝐕𝐎𝐔𝐑𝐈𝐓𝐄 𝐆𝐈𝐑𝐋 𝟐
𝐄𝐑𝐄𝐍 𝐉𝐀𝐄𝐆𝐄𝐑
You can read Part 1 here.
In which you and Eren have known eachother for ages & were bestfriends until he got into a relationship, out of respect you decided to distance yourself from him, but it seems like he’s got other ideas.
C/W: Toxic Eren, Smut, Fem-bodied reader, Oral, Fingering, Penetration, Anal, Mentions of infidelity.
You forced out a smile at Marco, your date who was currently siting on your couch and had been interrupted multiple times by the sound of your phone vibrating. Of course it was Eren, who you had blocked around an hour ago considering he would not stop bypassing your do not disturb, and he was making it extremely awkward for you.
You hadn’t even had the time to check what he was saying, probably something along the lines of threatening you to answer him and stop avoiding him after what took place between the two of you at his frat. After the two of you had finished in the kitchen things had gotten even crazier in the bedroom, this man had an ungodly amount of stamina, or maybe he was just pushing himself so he could enjoy you as much as he could.
Regardless, you concluded that it probably shouldn’t have happened. Eren had literally cheated on his girlfriend with you, it was shameful. You couldn’t help feeling guilty so distanced yourself even more than before, now it was time for you to move on which was why your eyes were surveying Marco’s freckles. You had a rough estimate that in around half an hour you could probably get him in your bedroom, get laid, and move on.
Now that Eren had been blocked for a while the awkwardness was not dissipating considering you no longer had to keep apologising every moment, fumbling to silence your phone which was not working for whatever reason.
“—Did you hear me? Y/n?” Marco waved his hand in front of your face, effectively catching your attention.
“Oh yeah sorry I’m just thinking of whats going to happen later.” You shook yourself back to reality with a smile, hoping you could manoeuvre your way out of this smoothly.
“Later?” He raised an eyebrow clearly not catching your memo, “What’s happening later?”
“You’ll find out.” You gave him a mischievous grin, it was entertaining watching the way his eyes lit up once he realised what you had actually meant, it was enough for you to break into a chuckle before you stood up. “Want something to drink?” You asked knowing that this was the perfect opportunity to dish out the few expensive wines you had been gifted.
“Sure.” He was blushing lightly, laying back on your couch a little, he began surveying the room as you made your way to the kitchen. “You’ve got a really nice place by the way.” He complimented.
“You think so?” You raised an eyebrow, poking your head out of the corner of the kitchen door, “I think you’ll like the bedroom even better.” At that he laughed while you opened the bottle.
Before he could respond there was a knock at the door. Finally, your order had arrived, you had planned to go on holiday soon and would be needing the clothes. You were glad that it came now before you got into the bedroom, getting the door during sex was not ideal.
You put the bottle down, opting for opening the door instead but Marco waved you off, “Don’t worry I’ll get it, you’re pouring us drinks.” He stood up enthusiastically, for some reason he felt the need to impress you. He’d always found you pretty, well who hadn’t? He had finally worked up the courage to ask you out and was elated at your response. As much as sleeping with you would be a dream he wanted more, he had feelings for you and he hoped he could soon make you his girlfriend.
“Thanks.” You smiled, going back to pouring the drinks. It only took seconds for your smile to fade at the sound of a jarringly familiar vote, that was not the delivery you had anticipated.
“What the fuck are you doing here?” You could practically hear Eren seething from the door, you sighed before rushing over to see him with the most disgusted look on his face, it’s like he couldn’t fathom the thought of another man being with you alone. “Wheres y/n?” He didn’t even give him a chance to respond. Well, this was awkward to say the least, not only did Marco and Eren know eachother but they lived in the same frat.
“What are you doing here?” Your attention caught his comment, he watched as you uncomfortably shifted, crossing your hands over in a standoffish manner. “I’m busy if you didn’t notice.”
“No you’re not.” He scoffed.
“What—“
“Because Marco was just leaving, weren’t you?” He clasped his hand over Marco’s shoulder in an almost threatening manner sporting a look that was practically compelling him to comply or else. “He just told me actually, go on Marco, tell her what you told me.”
“Yeah..” He turned to you, scratching his head shyly, in return you pouted. “I do actually have to go.” He frowned, not wanting to run into any conflict with Eren, he had no clue that the two of you were like that, in-fact he thought Eren had a girlfriend.
“Marco you don’t have to—“
“Great that’s settled then.” Eren interrupted you, stepping to the side to allow Marco space to exit through the front door. You sighed deeply knowing that you couldn’t convince him to stay after this encounter. “I’ll text you okay?” You said before mouthing sorry, he didn’t blame you anyway, there was a clear apologetic tone in your voice.
He smiled at you sadly, but you only got a flash of it before Eren completely shut the door in your face. You didn’t even bother looking at him, rather you turned for the kitchen to finish pouring your drink, he was hopeless.
“You ruin everything.”
“I did you a favour.” He raised an eyebrow, following you into the kitchen. He knew your apartment well, he had helped you pick out even with meant he felt more than comfortable here, it was practically his second home. Perks of being best-friends with the guy you fucked on a counter.
“What are you here for?” You side-eyed him, not offering any form of hospitality, you weren’t happy at all that you had been interrupted and he could tell. If you were lucky maybe you could convince him to leave in ten minutes.
“First you avoid me, then you block me, now you’re asking why I’m here? Why do you think I’m here?” You give him half your attention, grabbing your glass and making your way to the living-room, you wouldn’t offer him one, besides he could get it himself anyway.
“So I don’t answer you and you come to my home? You’re a fucking creep.” You raise an eyebrow, grabbing the TV remote while you took a seat on your couch.
He looked at you for a moment, not even knowing what to make of your comment. “Are you mad at me?”
“Am I mad at you—?” You laughed bitterly in disbelief, “You literally ruined my fucking date, of course I’m mad at you.” You scoffed, taking a sip of rosé, not even this could satisfy the way you were feeling right now.
“A date? You’re joking right?”
“Why do you think he’s here? We’re not having a gossip session.” You rolled your eyes, you had no clue the effect your words had on Eren. The thought of another man with you on a date, in your bedroom, it was enough to drive him crazy.
“Why the fuck are you on a date?”
“Why the fuck do you care?” Your patience was wearing thin as you brought out your phone to text Marco a second apology, you thought you were about to combust any second now.
“Stop messing around y/n.” Eren grabbed the phone out of your hand, you reacted fast, standing up to try and get it back but you were no match for him. To make matters worse his handsome features were so much sharper up close, he was so beautiful, so desperately beautiful, but right now he was walking a thin line.
“Give it back.”
“No what’s wrong with you? You’re not gonna text another guy in front of me.” He scoffed like you said something ridiculous, he had half the thought that perhaps you had forgotten what took place last week considering the way you were behaving.
“Are you out of your mind? Give me back my phone and leave.” You said sternly, your best guess was that Eren must be intoxicated because he had never acted this strange before.
He just glared you down, not moving to oblige to your request at all, “Eren I’m serious.” You pushed him but he hardly moved, he was much stronger than you after-all and the fact that he budged at all was out of his own choice to give you some breathing space, he could tell that him coming her was perhaps crossing a line but he couldn’t help it. “I will fucking call the cops.”
He raised an eyebrow at you before taking a seat on your couch, “No you won’t.” You felt like he was refusing to take you seriously and all you could do was stare at him in disbelief at his completely nonchalant manner.
“If you’re mad at me then sit down, let’s talk about it.” He tapped the space next to him. You hated when he did this, when he got you so worked up and then acted so mature so you felt like you were crazy or overreacting.
“I don’t want to talk to you Eren, what don’t you understand?” Instantly he gave you a look, a warning look and you could perfectly understand it. It was one that said ‘We’ve already spoken about this, don’t call me that.’ but he ended it there, he could accept you were upset so he would let it slide this time.
It made you feel smaller and the confidence you had to challenge him was starting to fade away. He grabbed your remote, changing over from TV browsing to netflix, “What do you wanna watch? You don’t have to talk to me right now, I’ll give you time but we will talk.” You wondered how he was so good at that, being so dominante with merely one look and then suddenly being Mr Considerate guy.
You slumped onto the couch in defeat, it didn’t take long for your hands to be brought to your face as you broke out in tears. “Hey hey, come on baby don’t do that.” If only you knew the way it broke his heart when you cried.
“Please don’t call me that ‘Ren, please.” Maybe you were being dramatic but you couldn’t help it. You simply couldn’t understand why he came here to talk to you like you were his girlfriend when you weren’t and he had a whole girl at home waiting for him.
He sighed deeply, moving to crouch in front of you so he could get a better look at your face. He moved your hands out of your face, replacing it with one of his own on your cheek. “Why are you crying? If you tell me what’s wrong then—“
“I feel like shit, you make me feel like shit, why are you coming here when you have a girlfriend who loves you? Why? Do you have any idea how that makes me feel?” You have half the mind to swat his hand away but you couldn’t deny that you enjoyed his touch more than you should.
He stood up slowly, his face slightly darkening. Were you just the most clueless person on this planet or what? Did he have to spell things out for you? “I don’t love her.”
“But you should, I don’t want to feel responsible for her being cheated on.” You shook your head at the thought, it was the first time you said it out loud and it put into perspective what a horrible person you were.
“Ask me.”
“What?”
“Ask me to break things off with her and I’ll do it, I promise.” He leaned downwards again, getting you to face him by moving your chin up with his hand.
“No, I don’t want you to do that.”
If you weren’t so sensitive he would scoff in your face right now, “What are you afraid of y/n, last week I told you—“
“Forget about last week ‘Ren, that shouldn’t have happened and you shouldn’t be here.” He was unbelievable, completely an utterly unbelievable. Coming here because you didn’t respond to his messages, getting rid of your date, forcing you to speak to him, taking away your phone, he was unhinged, you knew that.
“Last week was the best night of my life.”
“Yeah, because you like sex.”
“No, because I like you. Everything I said was true it wasn’t just to fuck, I think about you everyday, why else would I be here?”
“So why?” You pleased with him, praying that he could see the hurt in your eyes, “Why did you bail on me for her?”
“Is that what you think?” He was about to laugh, if this is what you had perceived the situation to be this entire time he was sure he would lose his mind. “You never showed any real interest in me past our friendship so I tried to get over you with her but last week — I don’t know, I just couldn’t pretend anymore.”
Hearing those words you finally gathered yourself together, you couldn’t be vulnerable like this because then you’d let Eren’s words get to your head, you didn’t need that right now. You cleared your throat, standing and hoping to match his level of intimidation, which failed miserably. “You can pretend and you will.”
“Don’t make me laugh.” He glares you down, wondering where this newfound confidence has come from.
“You should know better than this.”
“What are you so afraid of?” He asked, your eyes held each-other like they were afraid to let go, looking at you now he realised you were everything he ever wanted, everything he ever needed, he couldn’t let things go this way.
“Ruining our friendship.” You responded flailing your arms, hoping that now that he’s gotten the truth he can let things go. Of course you liked him when you were friends, you just couldn’t admit to that, what if things went left, he was the most precious thing to you.
“I guess we’re lucky that I’m not.” He hardly gave you a second to register his words before grabbing onto your shirt and pulling you against his lips, you should probably pull away now, right? But it was hard, it was so hard with him, he kissed you like the two of you were made for eachother, if he had told you he’d crossed an entire universe for this you’d believe him.
So you kissed back, big mistake.
Once you had realised that mistake it was then that you decided to pull away. About now you were mentally facepalming yourself, this is not how you expected today to go. Still, you couldn’t help but admire the blown out expression in his pupils, deep with love, lust and need, reaching out to you with a single glare of his eye. And that meant you couldn’t help the way you pulled him back in again.
You can undoubtedly say Eren was the best kisser you had ever encountered, this man made out like he was born for it, you were half convinced he was.
He moved down towards your neck, he loved this, loved hearing the sounds you made when he found that spot that got you to relish in pleasure. Loved the way he could already feel your legs going weak in his presence against his body. Loved the way he would be able to take care of you if you gave him the chance.
“After tonight—“ He began, you could feel his breath against your neck, it was enough to give you goosebumps, and enough to make you want him more, “—Everyone will know you belong to me.”
Those words were enough to send a shiver down your spine, and you had no doubts that the first step he would take towards this was marking himself on your neck. “But first I need you to say it, say you belong to me.”
“Make me.”
He chuckled shaking his head before tapping your ass, a sign to jump on, and you obliged, he was irresistible after all. Your weight was nothing to him, he carried you with complete ease to the bedroom the two of you had spent so much time in laying around beforehand, you would have never thought things would end up this way.
“Oh, I will.” After placing you onto the bed gently he made quick work of getting you wet, honestly his face was enough to do the job but the kisses were all an extra bonus.
“Take this off for me.” He tugged at your shirt, backing away a little so he could get a better view. “I wanna watch you.”
“You’re such a perv, you know that?” You sat up as he got off the bed, pulling out your desk chair so he could watch you take off your clothes from afar.
“I told you, jacking off material for life.”
You chuckled lightly, you couldn’t believe how easily he’d gotten you to switch, to push the thoughts of his girlfriend to the back of your head with one sentence. Him telling you that this was all so he could get over you almost justified it in your head, it wasn’t really cheating was it? You’ve always been his girl, he said it himself.
“Gross ‘Ren” He just laughed at that while leaning into to seat, getting comfortable to watch. He’d dreamed about this more than he could tell you, more than was possible, it was ridiculous.
You fiddled with the hem of your shirt knowing that underneath you had a matching red lace set expecting to be in here with Marco after your date, on the bright side you’d gotten a better bargain.
Slowly you pulled your top off and you swore you could visibly see Eren’s pants get tighter as he gripped the chair, a completely new expression arising on his face. He held back a groan watching you, he’d never seen anyone more beautiful.
“You’re perfect.” He spoke before even thinking, the words were genuine to his heart. You couldn’t help but feel slightly hot under his gaze, you had never done anything like this before, especially not for your best-friend.
“You’re making me nervous.” You folded your arms over a little bit, in return he clicked his tongue over the loss of view.
He made his way over to you and it felt like the longest few seconds of your life, your stomach burned in anticipation, excitement and fear all at once. Only Eren Jaeger was capable of making a girl feel such things.
“I have so many things I wanna do to you tonight.” He grabbed one of your breasts through your bra, “And I’m going to do all of them, while you keep this on.” He just had to see you with it, it was the best sight of his life. He couldn’t comprehend how you could get even more beautiful.
“Isn’t that right?” He asked slipping a hand under your skirt which you hadn’t taken off yet, you were wondering how he would react to seeing the full set. He wouldn’t be happy because he’s the type of man who could connect the dots and fast.
You nodded watching as his other hand began to tug your skirt down. In mere seconds you only prayed that some kind of miracle would occur where Eren would lose maybe half his intellect, enough so that he couldn’t clock on. That would never happen.
He glanced from your now exposed panties to your bra, his expression going blank for a moment out of being completely horny while it fought the other side of his brain telling him that you hadn’t put this on for him. A couple seconds passed before he clicked his tongue, “You were gonna give him all this?”
You had no favourable way of responding so decided on not responding at all, that provoked him even further. The thought of you and Marco, he didn’t even wanna go there, he’d be sick.
“No man is ever going to touch you the way I do, do you understand?” He asked, fingers ghosting over your spot before he pressed down, rubbing exactly where you needed him to. “I asked you a question.”
You nodded, biting down on your lip as the sensation elicited a moan out of you, “Say it, I wanna hear you say it.”
“No man is gonna touch me the way that you do.”
“Good good, you want me inside?” He asked, dragging his fingers up and down you at an agonising pace.
“Please.”
“Ask again.” He used your own line against you, remembering vividly the words from the party, and how could he forget when the night was on repeat for him ever since. He’d fisted his cock to that imagine of the two of you so many times that he’d lost count, but it was nothing compared to the real thing.
“Please ‘Ren.”
He moved your underwear to the side, deciding that he would get you to keep that on too while he pushed one finger into you. You gripped the sheets a little harder, whining at the now pressure. “If you want my cock then you’re gonna beg for it, you know that right?” He began pumping his finger before adding another, caging you under his body to make sure he was the only thing you could look at. “I want to be nice to you y/n I do, but you make it so hard for me, so hard.”
He moves his thumb to your clit, only lightly because he wants to keep you like this, you can’t cum yet, not after what you tried to pull earlier. “Slutting yourself out to another guy like this, you make me sick.”
“Y-You’re the one with a girlfriend.” You said between heavy breathing and moans, he was such a hypocrite, that was simply Eren for you. “I’d never fuck her like I’ll fuck you but you’re prepared to give another guy all this? He doesn’t deserve you.”
You whined in pleasure, your pussy clenching around his fingers, he caught that, of course he did. “Want another?” He asked, you nodded while running your hand down his body, he shivered at your touch.
“Then don’t fight me, you’re too tight.” Again, the same reaction. He wasn’t finding it difficult to please you at all, in fact, Eren was beyond amazing with words. Slowly he adds a third, making sure he didn’t hurt you. As much as you hadn’t behaved preferably tonight and didn’t deserve such treatment there’s no way his massive cock could fuck you without getting you wet enough first, he couldn’t risk you being in pain, even if he wasn’t happy with you.
Once he was in comfortable his fingers began to pick up the pace, so much that you would probably hear it from underneath you if it wasn’t for all your moaning. Eren could tell you were close, you were getting louder, clenching around him tighter, the expression on your face was enough to let him know too, so he just stopped.
“What? ‘Ren I’m so close.” You whined pleading with him but he didn’t care, laughing at your desperation instead.
“You’re not cumming on anything but my cock today but I already told you, first say you belong to me and I’ll give it to you.” He pushed your underwear back into position, rubbing against you from the outside now, enough that you wouldn’t cum but still feel good as your slick formed a dark patch.
“Please.”
“Say it.”
“I belong to you.” It was enough to make pre-cum leak out of his tip, his pants were uncomfortably tight now. In all honesty the moment he walked through your front door it had started but you were the only girl who could get him so unbelievably hard.
“Again.” He leaned in closer, wanting to hear it loud and clear so that he could remember it well enough.
“I belong to you ‘Ren.”
“Yeah you do so you know what? I’m gonna cum wherever I want, starting with right here.” His fingers ghosted over your slit before his attention was brought back to your face, “Then that pretty mouth of yours, you’re gonna take my cock in it yeah?”
You nodded, eager to do anything to please him because you knew that you were in for the night of your life. “And then your tits, fuck I love your tits. And if you’re feeling up to it your ass, but you will be feeling up to it, right baby?”
“Yes ‘Ren.” You were already working on unbuckling his belt, you needed him inside you absolutely more than you’ve ever needed anything on this planet.
“Good, you’re so good. You’re gonna make what you did tonight up to me.” He watched you pull down his pants before going straight for his boxers, he could almost laugh at your desperation.
His cock sprung free and you couldn’t help but gape a little, sure he’d fucked you before but you’d hardly gotten a look, it’s not like the counter was too mobile and by the time you’d gotten to the bedroom? Well, you can hardly keep your eyes open. “I can’t take that.” You gaped a little.
“You can, and you will, you did it last time.” His hands move to your waist before they’re back on your underwear, “You ready baby?”
You took a deep breath before nodding, he rearranged his grip on you to be more firm with one hand as he held his cock on the other, pushing it into you slowly. You were making it difficult for him at first you were pushing him out and he didn’t get why, unless you were just this tight.
You began to whine a little, he could feel your nails digging into his skin but paid it no mind, if anything he liked it, the fact that there would be something left on him after your night together. “I know I know.” He coaxed you, grabbing your face with one hand slowly, “Does it hurt?”
“Mhmm.” You turned your face away from him, you were between the point of pain and pleasure right now. Never in a million years did you think you would curse Eren Jaeger for having such a big dick but never in a million years did you think you’d be fucking him either.
“Then I’m sorry about this.” You furrowed your eyebrows at him, unsure what he meant until he began pounding into you at an ungodly pace. He’d hardly given you the time to adjust, he wanted to, he really did, but he couldn’t hold back, he was drunk on you.
“Shit ‘Ren.” You managed between moans, digging into him even harder, he caught your surprise at first, but the louder he got he could tell you liked it when he was like this, just a tiny bit rough with you.
“Sorry babe I just can’t hold back, I’ve been thinking about fucking you all week, all my life.” His lips moved to your neck once again, he’d realised how much you loved that. Right now you could barely even respond with him hitting all the right spots like this. His hand moved towards your breast, rubbing on your nipple lightly but it was enough to make you clench all around him.
“Fuck baby don’t do that you’ll make me cum.” He slowed down his pace, he was going to get everything he wanted tonight that was for sure, but he wanted you in missionary a little longer, you were way too beautiful for him to let you up without a fight.
“I want you to cum, cum in me ‘Ren, please.” You pleaded with him, he almost gaped for a little bit before recollecting himself and giving you a deep chuckle. You got him there, you really did.
“Stop that.” He put his hand over your mouth to stop you from speaking, he knew you were doing it on purpose, you weren’t going to take this away from him, not on his watch. If you said one more word he was sure he’d shoot the biggest load ever inside of you.
“Please.” He could hear your muffled begging even through the way you kept muttering his name as his dick rutted up you relentlessly.
“Be a good girl and take these in your mouth and I’ll think about it.” He slid his fingers in your mouth, already imagining the image of your pretty lips wrapped around his cock. He was going to lose it he was sure of it, you were going to make him lose it. He watched intently as you sucked on his fingers, the entire sight was lewd, erotic even. He was in love.
You grabbed his fingers, sucking and pulling them out until it made a pop sound. “Please daddy.” That was it, it was over for him. The familiar feeling built up inside him and the fact that you were clenching around him with what was now your own orgasm wasn’t helping either. You were practically sucking him in, he was sure that you wanted him to breed you because he couldn’t pull out now if he wanted to.
He groaned as he shot squirts of cum down you, watching as you moaned in overstimulation as he continued rutting into you. He wasn’t going to stop until you got every single drop of him.
“Too much ‘Ren.” You moved your head to the side, he could feel your body shaking under him but he didn’t care this was your fault. He brought his fingers to your clit deciding that he wanted to make you cum again in the span of a few seconds and he did exactly that regardless of the fact that you tried to push him away with your hand.
Another wave had washed over you and you were louder than ever before, you were convinced that Eren made you cum harder and harder each-time, it was like he was learning your body and adding more to make the experience better for you and you could admit he was doing it well.
He buried his head in your neck, slowing down until he completely stopped and regained himself. That was the largest load he’d ever shot in his life and he could feel it dripping out from inside you onto his dick without even looking.
“You bitch.” You could feel his low vibration against your neck though you couldn’t respond, you were already two fucked out for that, the overstimulation having its way with you. “You made me cum.” He grabbed your face with one hand, “You know what comes next right?”
He grabbed your body, flipping you over so that you were on top of him now. He placed a chaste kiss on your lips, you didn’t know how he did it, how he was so rough with his words but sweet with his actions. You grabbed his hair, tugging on it while the two of you made out. He was so pretty like this with his hair down, fucking you like his life depended on it. Those thoughts didn’t last long though, how could they when Eren was suddenly pushing you towards the other side of the bed. He grabbed you then, placing you gently on the ground so that you were on your knees. “I’m gonna fuck your face baby, you’d like that wouldn’t you?”
“Yes ‘Ren.” You stabilised yourself on his thigh, his cock was already hanging down, hitting the side of your face. “Make sure you keep all of that inside you or else I’ll stop.” You couldn’t even respond because he didn’t even take a second before shoving his dick in your mouth. He wasn’t joking when he said that he would fuck your face.
He had a firm grip on your head, abusing your throat as much as he wanted. And when the tears began brimming in your eyes? Well that was his favourite part of course. This was the perfect look for him, if you were going to cry for anyone or anything it better be because he’s shoving his dick down your throat.
He grabbed his phone, he couldn’t resist. There’s no way he would let himself forget this moment, he needed to replay it over and over, for when he was fisting his own cock thinking of you. There was already a ring of his cum as your head bopped up and down, his balls slapping against you as he shoved the phone in your face. “Look into the camera baby, need to see you.”
Your eyes flickered upwards and he wished he could burn this into his mind, “Fuck just like that.” Your mascara was running down your face, tears pricking the side, your makeup completely ruined of course and the most fucked out expression he had ever seen. And it was all because of him.
“You’re perfect you know that? Fucking perfect.” He ended the video, tossing it somewhere on the bed so he could pull you off him, giving you a minor breather. “Touch yourself.” He commanded, seeing how you were rubbing your thighs together to get off.
He could see the shy expression on your face so he grabbed your jaw with his right hand, “Please baby? I wanna see, need to see you.”
Slowly you brought your hand to your clit, rubbing it on softly with little moans. He didn’t know he could get harder than he was right now, this was insane, you were insanely perfect. He brought his hand to his own cock, stroking it while he watched you. “Shit keep going.” He put his dick back in your mouth, less harsh than last time so he could still feel the moans from your own fingers vibrating down his dick.
Your lips, tongue, face and moans combined were enough to send him over the edge. You watched as his head tipped back as his orgasm washed over him, he pulled his dick out and fisted it so that he could cum all over your face. You laughed to yourself a little, opening up your mouth so that he could tap his tip against your lips for the remainder but he didn’t stop there, no, he didn’t care that your face was covered in cum, he needed more.
He kept fisting his cock into overstimulation so he had another load reserved just for your tits, he was gonna make good on his promise from earlier. White covered your nipples, the warm feeling was enough to get you to grip his thighs. “Fuck y/n, I swear your my favourite girl in the entire world, you hear me? The world.” He gets you to your feet, pushing you back onto the bed.
He begins worshipping your body, kissing every part of you that he could find, making his way down towards your inner thigh, licking up some of the slick that was dripping down your thighs. This was the moment he was waiting for, for you to be wet enough for him to do this. He flipped you around so that your back was to him. He ran his hands down your body, like he was drinking in the sight once again.
“Are you okay with this?” He asked while grabbing his cock, getting ready to push it inside your ass. You nodded but it wasn’t enough for him, “Need to hear you say it.”
“I’m okay with it ‘Ren.”
“Good because I’m going to defile you in every way possible, there’s not going to be a single part of you I haven’t cummed in.” He grabs your throat while inserting himself inside. He wasn’t as rough as he was before, he couldn’t be if he wanted to you were just so fucking tight there, it was impossible for him. He moved his fingers to your clit, “Relax for me babe, loosen up.” You did as he said so he could push in further, a satisfied moan coming out of his mouth before he began moving, both hands on your hips.
You were moaning uncontrollably, how couldn’t you be? He moved to insert a finger in your pussy, while completely ramming himself up your ass. You were going to lose your mind, you couldn’t even think, and could hardly breathe with his hand around your throat. You felt stuffed, the only thing that could make this better is if you had another dick in your mouth.
“Who else has been in here?”
“No one.
“That’s right, all mine.” The sensation of his left hand roaming up and down your body, his right fingering you and his cock up your ass drove you over the edge quickly in a way you had never felt before. You couldn’t even open your mouth to tell him you were about to cum, you could barely move. It was almost like you were half-conscious but you could feel the mess you were making below you and you had no doubt Eren was cumming too considering the hot liquid trialing down your ass. “Fuck baby did you just squirt?” He moved back a little to basque in all your glory before a grin returned to his face.
“You know what this means right? You’ve got to do it again for me, want a better view this time.” And like usual, he always got what he wanted.
A/N: It took me like two days to write this??? I have no clue why I found it so difficult but thank you for the request & all the support on part 1 of favourite girl I’m feeling so much more inspired to write again, the things you guys say mean the world to me.
Thank you for everything & requests for Eren Jaeger are open.
2K notes
·
View notes