Hot take but I think Aaron Dessner is given too much credit like I love Would've Could've Should've but what makes it is her songwriting the production is actually really washed out and not even in a raw way but in a badly produced way.
This is her dgaf album in the best and worst way it's refreshingly raw and unapologetic yet gives in to her worst impulses/is too unrefined to really be considered good
I actually vibe more with Tortured Poets than Midnights but it really is her worst album quality wise the re recordings have emboldened her to just vomit out whatever with no refinement whatsoever