Fanfic I wrote for The Coffin of Andy and Leyley. Originally posted on Reddit, then Ao3.
---
Being able to be openly affectionate with Ashley was one advantage to quarantine, Andrew had to admit. Even when their parents lived with them, their mom was always giving them disgusted looks, or making snide comments to them. Now he didn’t have to watch over himself, trying to be cautious about every interaction they had. He could interact with his sister without feeling judged about it. Everything felt natural, and he could be himself.
This changed after they started having sex.
He became much more self conscious, in a way that he never was before. Even buying condoms had become an ordeal. In his past life, he would just pick some up when he got cigarettes. He didn’t care who saw him, because he didn’t care if anyone knew that he was getting laid. It was different now.
He tried not to go to the same place twice, and never went with Ashley, lest someone realize how similar they look and make the connection. Each trip had him on the brink of an anxiety attack. They had discussed other options, but getting a prescription for the birth control pill would start a paper trail, and the consequences of pulling out were too dire. So instead Andrew dealt with the fear and shame of being found out every time he went to the pharmacy. He also stocked up on pregnancy tests out of paranoia; It got to the point where Ashley was used to just taking one every few days as a matter of routine.
“You know how that’s not how it works, right?” she said the third time, as she handed him the test with one blue line. “It doesn’t show you the moment you get pregnant, it only shows after a few weeks.”
“It’s either this or your demon trinket, and I’m not sacrificing anyone else if I can avoid it,” he said. He checked the box to confirm that yes, a single line meant ‘not pregnant’.
While She didn't mind at first, it got tiresome after a while. So she stole a pen from the front desk while Andrew was out. When it was time to take another test, she drew an extra line on it.
“Hey An-dy,” Ashley sang to him, holding out a test with two blue lines on it.
Andrew puked. Violently.
“What the fuck, Andy?” Ashley screamed.
“You're pregnant?? How did this happen? We were so careful! Ashley. I don't think we can do this.”
“Well, then it's a good thing I'm not actually pregnant, Asshole. It was a joke. I drew on the extra line.”
It took a minute for Andrew to register what she had said.
“What? What the fuck, Ashley, why would you do that to me??”
“I didn't think it would make you puke! Did you ever puke after having sex with one of your floozies??”
“It's not the sex, Ashley, it's the thought of having a baby!”
“You think I'd be a bad mother.”
“No, I think it's a bad idea to have a child when both parents are unemployed, on the run, and oh yeah, they’re siblings!!!”
“It's not like anyone knows”
“Really, Ashley? You think that no one ever looks at us and sees how similar we are? Which features we share? The same mannerisms we have? That’s bullshit.”
“Is that why you never show affection to me in public? That you won’t kiss me or hold my hand? You’re afraid some stranger will judge you?”
“If they notice us enough to judge us, they notice us enough to report us, Ashley.”
“We’ve been out in public a lot without anyone saying anything!”
“Not while we were fucking! Going out in public is hell. All I think about is people seeing through me, realizing I'm the freak that fucks my sister. And when I'm alone with you, I feel better. I feel happy. I feel like I’m home. I reinforce that they’re right .”
“Oh, so I make you a freak?” She yelled, more angry than hurt.
“Ashley. Leyley .” he said gently. He embraced her and kissed her hair. “You don’t make me a freak. You make me happy. I can’t live without you. But I don’t know how much longer we can go on like this. It seems inevitable that we’re either going to get caught and arrested, or killed, or something else, but we’re going to be separated, and I don’t know what I will do with myself if that happens. I don’t want to lose you.”
“And I don’t want you to leave me.”
He closed his eyes and held her tighter.
“What do we do, Leyley? To be free?”
“Let's ask the trinket,” Ashley suggested. “We still have one vision on this thing.”
It seemed like such a big ask. Up until this point, the trinket had primarily worked when it wanted to. But it was right about the hitman, it had been right about them sleeping together, so he agreed to give it a shot.They slept together that night with his arms wrapped around her, holding the trinket between their hands.
Robbing the pharmacy was easier than it had any right to be, but that was the advantage of having demons on your side. The place was remote and had only one pharmacist, so when they went in Andrew simply locked the door behind him while Ashley held the gun to the pharmacist.
“Don't be stupid about this, and you can live,” she said. The pharmacist nodded. “We want sectional. All of it.”
“Sectional? Is that what it’s called, Ashley?”
“ Leyley . And yeah, something like that.”
“Something like that? Seconal, Ley. It’s Seconal.” He shot Leyley a look, but she only smiled and blew him a kiss in return.
The pharmacist brought them their entire stock of pills, which wasn’t a lot, but would be enough. The Graves then bound and gagged the pharmacist and left him behind the counter, a rare act of mercy for them.
In the car, Ashley popped open one of the beers they had bought earlier and handed it to Andrew.
“Not while I'm driving!” He said, and tried to wave it away.
“What do you care? The vision showed we’d arrive safely.”
“I need to be able to chisel properly.”
“Why? Does it matter how nice it looks?”
“You know what? Fuck it, you're right.” Andrew took the can from her and took a swig.
They had a good buzz going by the time they arrived at their destination. Ashley was initially against the idea, but Andrew convinced her that if it was in the vision, they should do it that way. Plus, since their parents' bodies were missing, there was no actual grave. No Coffin. Just a tombstone with the word GRAVES on it, with their parents names and dates of birth below it.
Andrew chipped away at their names and dates of birth as best he could until it only had “GRAVES” on it. It looked alright, considering how much alcohol he had. Ashley laid out a blanket over the area in front of the tombstone, and they sat down on it.
“Okay,” Andrew said, as he poured the pills into two piles. “I guess it doesn’t matter how much we take? So we’ll each take half. Then lie down and stay on your back.”
“On my back so we can go out with a bang?” Leyley teased.
“I'm serious, Leyley. If you puke everything up, it won't work.”
“Being on my back will stop me from puking?” she asked. She took the pills and followed it with some more beer.
“Yes,” Andrew lied. The reality was that if either of them threw up while on their back, they would choke on it; being on their sides meant they might survive the ordeal.
“Leyley?”
“Mm?”
“In your vision, what was death like?”
“Peaceful,” Leyley said. “It was just us, here, then a feeling of warmth and heaviness. I woke up from the vision with a sense of peace.”
“I hope that means hell is nice,” Andrew said. “Look up at the stars with me.”
“Very romantic.”
“It is, actually. Author Mary Shelley supposedly lost her virginity on her moms grave. Romeo and Juliet died in her family’s crypt.”
“You always knew how to bring the romance,” Leyley said, her voice somewhat unsteady. Romantic, not romance, Andrew almost corrected, but now wasn't the time. He was starting to feel dizzy and didn't want those to be his last words to her.
“I love you, Leyley.”
Leyley didn’t respond, and Andrew didn’t want to risk moving his head to look at her. Instead, he reached his hand out to hold hers. He felt his muscles grow weaker and weaker, and he couldn't keep his eyes open. As his breathing started to slow, he felt himself overcome with a sense of peace and calm.
3 notes
·
View notes
19 years ago I couldn't fall asleep either, I was in a hospital with my then wife, in the morning she would arrive......my Callista.
I had, had her name picked out for years, even before Katana was born, but of course Katana being named anything else would have been wrong, no,. The Prettiest One...that name would have to wait.
She was so beautiful, form the moment she came into the world, just so damn beautiful. I remember I was beyond excited, beyond happy, I was just filled with so much joy and hope for the future, happy that Sheena had a daughter. Happy that my family seemed to be headed for.....a bright future.
And now 19 years later I cannot fall asleep again, for all the opposite reasons. I was a good dad, better than good, I remember doing her hair in the summer, or before school during the school year and I remember taking her to the library in the summer for story days, when I was unemployed during the first separation, and got to spend all day everyday taking care of her.
And even 3 years later after the actual final divorce, I was still a good dad, maybe better than good. I would drive from Milwaukee to eustisford early in the morning to see her or the other kids get awards only to turn around and drive an hour back knowing I had to work that day. And I drove up there on days I didn't have them to see cheerleader practices or cheerleader performances or science fairs and all of that.
And then about 4 5 years after the divorce was final, I kind of just snapped I had some sort of a breakdown I stopped seeing my kids I was unable to keep a job for very long I've screwed up a lot of opportunities I didn't know how to fix myself, and I didn't know why it took that long for me to break, that should have happened like right after the divorce.
And I'm not going to put blame on anyone but myself, but my ex-wife did kind of help the breakdown, 5 years of back and forth and up and down and giving me false hope that maybe we had reconciliation and the future ahead of us only to always pull the rug out from under me. And I don't know maybe someday my kids will look back and understand what was going on understand just this year nonsense of it, but if they do it'll probably just make them like me even less cuz they'll probably just wonder why I kept falling for it. And they never will realize that they were the reason I kept falling for it, that I just wanted them back in my life full time. But the decisions that I made any emotional pain that I went through that 5 years ended up with me going off the rails to the point that I never see them, and I don't think they have any desire to ever see me again.
I miss my little girl, I miss her so much the tears started probably early Saturday afternoon and they have continued all the way through till now 1:00 in the morning. And I'm having a hard time falling asleep, because part of me doesn't want to wake up again, but also because every time I close my eyes I see her. So I don't want to close my eyes and it's hard to fall asleep with your eyes open.
My heart is so terribly broken and I feel so utterly alone, and I'm getting very tired of it. Every one I love leaves me everyone, and I'm getting very tired of just keeping my head up.
I won't hear from her today even though I will try to reach out with a happy birthday but I know I will get no reply. So I guess I'll just say this to put it out there, happy birthday calista, I love you, I have never stopped loving you and I never will. I think about you everyday, you are in my heart and my head everyday, I miss you, and I am so sorry that I failed you. And I have come to the conclusion that I will never be forgiven, but maybe I don't deserve to.
1 note
·
View note