no bc she thought he was going to be okay. like even in the deleted scene she asks if they should go get jack (and the doctor lies). like there was never a possibility for her where jack was dead she just couldn't comprehend it. she couldn't comprehend it so hard she brought him back forever. do you think she ever asked. do you think the doctor ever told her. at the end of s4 she's surprised when he comes back to life. do you think jack was angry. how can you watch someone be permanently brought back to life by a god and then never tell the god they died in the first place. like. the doctor never telling rose what happened to him always gets me. you knew she brought me back forever and she didn't and you never told her?
EXACTLY. shaking you by the shoulders anon. she thought he was fine, she thought he stayed back and helped clean everything up and then the next time she sees him he dies in front of her. he thought she was dead too !!! he spent the period in between the battle of canary wharf and utopia believing that she was dead. & then the next and last time that they see each other they don't even interact onscreen........ will never forgive the tenth doctor for breaking up the polycule
20 notes
·
View notes
Deleted Scene: The Wife, The Alien, And Me
"Mr Lewis, Dr Smith is here for Rose. Her parents are away for work today."
"Thank you, Mrs Price. Send him in."
Rose looked up and smiled as The Doctor walked in.
Thank god! Mum would make a scene.
She winced as the smile pulled at her split lip.
"Dr Smith, I'm Mr Lewis, the headmaster."
"John Smith, Rose's Godfather. Where-"
The Doctor cut himself off, hand half out to shake the Heads, and his eyes fixed on Rose.
She tried to send him a reassuring look, but the dribble of blood coming from the corner of her mouth probably scuppered that.
"What happened?" He demanded, walking straight past the Head and other parents, cupping her face with gentle hands.
"I'm ok."
"Look at me," his voice was firm, and he had a serious look on his face that Rose had never seen before. She realised with a start that it was a dad-face.
I wonder if he's been a father before.
"Who did this?" His voice was quiet and calm and dangerous, and the Head stepped forward to cut in, but Louisa got there first.
"They started it! We were just defending ourselves!"
"Hello Miss Louisa," the Doctor said kindly, casting his eye over her blackening eye and split knuckles. They were a sharp contrast to Rose's unmarked hands, telling him exactly who they'd hit first. "Are you ok?"
"I'm fine, Dr John," she reassured him with a defiant smile, tilting her head up proudly, "at least I had a chance to swing back."
"I can see that," he murmured, raising Rose's unmarked hands to his lips. He spun towards Jamie and Connor, "what's to be done about them?"
"Dr Smith-"
"I don't want a fuss," Rose cut in, and the Doctor spun back towards her. He put two fingers under her chin and raised her head up to look him in the face.
"There's nothing I wouldn't do for you, Blossom. So if you think I'm not about to pull a Donna Nobel, and descend, you've got another thing coming. And so do they."
Oh god, there's two of them.
Rose nodded, and looked over the Doctor's shoulder at the now very pale face of the Headmaster.
I bet he wished it had been Dad here after all.
47 notes
·
View notes