What If Scenario. The Pandemic never happened, but the renovations at Her Majesty’s eventually did. During that time, they put together a concert-like production of Phantom like they did with Les Mis in 2019. Who would you have cast in each part? Feel free to include Ensemble & Understudies
I think I answered something very similar before where I said that I'd love to have had an international celebration, with recent, fan-favorite, or long-running members from productions all over the world given an opportunity to perform and do, like, one song each, along with the then-current cast at the time. So I guess it might be something like:
Phantom: Josh Piterman (London), Ben Crawford (Broadway), Derrick Davis (national tour), Osamu Takai (Japan), Alexander Goebel (Vienna), Colm Wilkinson (Toronto), Peter Karrie (Canadian tour), Peter Joback (Stockholm), Ian Jon Bourg (Germany), Anthony Warlow (Australia), Henk Poort (Scheveningen), Juan Navarro (Mexico City), Hans Peter Janssens (Antwerp), Tomas Ambt Kofod (Copenhagen), Hong Kwang Ho (Seoul), Juan Carlos Barona (Madrid), Sandor Sasvari (Budapest), Saulo Vasconcelos (Sao Paulo), Damian Aleksander (Poland), Carlos Vittori (Buenos Aires), Marian Vojtko (Prague), Stephen Brandt Hansen (Estonia), Ivan Ozhogin (Moscow), Ilkka Hamalainen (Helsinki), Adrian Nour (Bucharest), Nikola Bulatovic (Belgrade), Vladimir Grudkov (Sofia), Jonathan Roxmouth (World Tour), Espen Grjotheim (Oslo), Ben Forster (Greece), Killian Donnelly (UK Tour)
Christine: Kelly Mathieson (London), Meghan Picerno (Broadway), Emma Grimsley (national tour), Sae Yamamoto (Japan), Luzia Nistler (Vienna), Rebecca Caine (Toronto), Teresa DeZarn (Canadian tour), Emmi Christensson (Stockholm), Valerie Link (Germany), Ana Marina (Australia), Joke de Kruijf (Scheveningen), Irasema Terrazas (Mexico City), Inneke van Klinken (Antwerp), Sibylle Glosted (Copenhagen), Kim So Hyun (Seoul), Julia Moller (Madrid), Barbara Fonyo (Budapest), Lina Mendes (Sao Paulo), Edyta Krzemien (Poland), Claudia Cota (Buenos Aires), Monika Sommerova (Prague), Maria Listra (Estonia), Tamara Kotova (Moscow), Sofie Asplund (Helsinki), Irina Baiant (Bucharest), Mirjana Matic (Belgrade), Vesela Delcheva (Sofia), Claire Lyon (World Tour), Astrid Giske (Oslo), Amy Manford (Greece), Holly-Anne Hull (UK Tour)
Raoul: Danny Whitehead (London), John Riddle (Broadway), Michael Maliakel (national tour), Kanji Ishimaru (Japan), Thorsten Tinney (Vienna), Laird Mackintosh (Toronto), Kip Wilborne (Canadian tour), Anton Zetterholm (Stockholm), Nicky Wuchinger (Germany), Alexander Lewis (Australia), Peter de Smet (Scheveningen), someone who's not Jose Joel (Mexico City), Michael Shawn Lewis (Antwerp), Christian Lund (Copenhagen), Son Jun Ho (Seoul), Armando Pita (Madrid), Zoltan Miller (Budapest), Nando Prado (Sao Paulo), Marcin Mrozinski (Poland), Nicholas Martinelli (Buenos Aires), Tomas Vanek (Prague), Koit Toome (Estonia), Evgeny Zaycev (Moscow), John Martin Bengtsson (Helsinki), Florin Ristei (Bucharest), Slaven Doslo (Belgrade), Denko Prodanov (Sofia), Matt Leisy (World Tour), Carl Lindquist (Oslo), Nadim Naaman (Greece), Rhys Whitfield (UK Tour)
Is that way too many cast members? Probably! Are there even enough scenes for each of them to perform together? Unlikely! Did I give up doing supporting, ensemble, and understudies because it was too exhausting? Definitely! Do I even know who some of these people are or if they want to come back at all? Not really!
But you have to admit - it's a huge and very international cast!
6 notes
·
View notes
I was wondering why they don't cast older actors to play the Phantom? By older I mean like 40s that's the age I think Erik is in the book. One of the reasons I love the original is bc the actors had these unique characteristics, very much like in Lenoux's Phantom. Everything now seems so generic.
There have definitely been a lot of older Phantom’s! Some in their 40′s or 50′s. Some were in their 40′s when cast, and then finished in their 50′s. To name a few:
Robert Guillaume, 63(ish)
Flemming Enevold: 57
Sandor Sasvari: 57
Hugh Panaro, around 35 during his first run in 1999, 37-38 for his second, about 40 for the third, and 50 when he played his final show
Peter Karrie, around 45 when he began in London and about 55 when he did his final show
Brent Barrett, 51
Preben Kristensen, 56
Brad Little, about 32 when he first started and 50 when he finished
Michael Crawford: about 44 in 1986 and 49 when he finished
Howard McGillin: about 46 when he started and 56 when he finished
Ted Keegan, about 38 when he first began in 1999, and about 59 now (he is still an u/s on Broadway)
And there are definitely more. But I will say that I notice that while the description will say 30-40′s, there is a tendecny in recent years to cast younger Phantom’s. As the leads at least. There were definitely younger Phantom’s back in the day, but it seemed like there were a few more that were understudies versus principals. Nowadays, it seems like late 20′s is possible, but 30′s is the average. I understand why, the role is vocally and physically challenging, and some actors in their 40-50′s might not want to go through all of that night after night. Not all, but some. Also, there has always been this sort of charm or ‘sexiness’ surrounded around the ALW Phantom. And I think in recent years with people like Ramin, we have seen a shift in them casting younger, more ‘attractive’ Phantom’s. Even though half their face is covered for the entire show.
But I don’t necessarily think that age equals how unique or good a performance is. Sure, being older means the actor likely has more experience that they can apply to the role, but a good actor who auditioned and was cast in a role should be able to do it well no matter if they are 28 or 38. And if we look at the Phantom, he is an outcast of society, who faces rejection and heartbreak. Granted most people aren’t outcasted the way the Phantom was, but a lot of people at some point feel left out and get their heartbroken. Especially in your teenage years and 20′s. So theoretically, a Phantom u/s of 29 might have the same personal experience as some who is 40. If they are a good actor and the creatives thought they could do the role justice, then they probably can.
Now on the subject of the generic, that might not entirely be all on the actor. I have definitely seen older and younger Phantom’s give amazing performances and throw in some unique things to make the role more their own. Ted Keegan and Jonathan Roxmouth for example. But Broadway and the US tend to have more of a mold that they want their actors to follow, whereas the UK, World Tours, foreign productions will give them more freedom. So the same person might be more static on Broadway, but then throw in a bunch of new things if they went to London or Brazil. I figure the US does that for a few reasons: it being the productions Hal would see the most, consistency, audience expectations, etc. So sometimes an actor is a bit more restricted and it makes them seem generic, sometimes it’s an off day, sometimes you just get someone who has been there a while and seems bored (Kyle Barisich). And honestly it’s not always a bad thing because even with the actors following more of a mold that means you’ll likely always see either a solid or great show, whereas in other places that cast more outside the box and give more freedom you might get a really great show or a bad one. But I don’t think age is the big factor there.
13 notes
·
View notes
Ah, thank you for directing me to that. Forgive me for not even thinking to check there. Though I am looking for performances that can be found on YouTube (admittedly partially for convenience) and video quality isn't exactly a concern.
No problem, and since you’ve specified that you were looking specifically for YouTube, I can give a fuller answer, since that’s different than videos uploaded to MEGA accounts and such. I’m sometimes hesitant to link to YouTube videos though, since those accounts can get taken down fairly quickly, so what you might get in a couple of months is a post full of dead links, but here’s a couple that seem to have stayed online for a while:
1985, Sydmonton: Colm Wilkinson, Sarah Brightman, Clive Carter
1987, London: Michael Crawford, Rebecca Caine, Steve Barton
1988, Broadway: Michael Crawford, Sarah Brightman, Steve Barton
1988, Broadway: Michael Crawford, Dale Kristien, Steve Barton
1988, Tokyo: Masachika Ichimura, Ryoko Nomura, Yuichiro Yamaguchi
1988, Vienna: Alexander Goebel, Luzia Nistler, Alfred Pfeifer (proshot clips)
1989, Broadway: Cris Groenendaal, Rebecca Luker, Steve Barton
1989, Los Angeles: Michael Crawford, Dale Kristien, Steve Barton
1990, Los Angeles: Michael Crawford, Mary D’Arcy, Reece Holland
1990/1991/1992/1994/1995, Toronto/Canadian Tour: Todd Noel / Jeff Hyslop / Colm Wilkinson / Cris Groenendaael / Peter Karrie, Susan Cuthbert / Teresa DeZarn / Patti Cohenour, Byron Nease / David Rogers
1991, Vienna: Ernst-Dieter Suttheimer, Colleen Besett, Timothy Breese
1991, Stockholm: Mikael Samuelsson, Inger Olsson Moberg, Bengt Nordfors
1992/1993, US Tour: Kevin Gray, Dodie Pettit/Teri Bibb, Keith Buterbaugh/Nat Chandler (highlight videos)
1993, Vienna: Alexander Goebel, Luzia Nistler, Thorsten Tinney
1993, Los Angeles: Davis Gaines, Dale Kristien, Michael Piontek
1993, Scheveningen: Henk Poort, Joke de Kruijf, Peter de Smet
1994, Sapporo: Eiji Akutagawa, Hisako Hanaoka, Kanji Ishimaru
1995, London: Ethan Freeman, Jill Washington, Simon Bowman
1995, Broadway: Davis Gaines, Tracy Shayne, Ciaran Sheehan
1998, Broadway: Thomas James O’Leary, Sandra Joseph, Gary Mauer
1998, Toronto: Peter Karrie, Elizabeth DeGrazia, David Rodgers
1999, Toronto: Paul Stanley, Melissa Dye, Laird Mackintosh
1999; Broadway: Howard McGillin, Adrienne McEwan, Gary Mauer
2000, Mexico City: Saulo Vasconcelos, Irasema Terrazas, Jose Joel
2000, London: Scott Davies, Meredith Braun, Matthew Cammelle
2000, Hamburg: Ian Jon Bourg, Alison Kelly, Kyle Gonyea
2001, Hamburg: Ian Jon Bourg, Olivia Safe, Kyle Gonyea
2002, Madrid: Juan Carlos Barona, Julia Moller, Zenon Recalde
2003, Stuttgart: Roy Weissensteiner, Marion Wilmer, Carsten Lepper
2003, Budapest: Sandor Sasvari, Andrea Maho, Gabor Bot
2003, Broadway: Howard McGillin, Adrienne McEwan, Jim Weitzer
2003, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Julie Hanson, Jim Weitzer
2003, US Tour: Brad Little, Lisa Vroman, Tim Martin Gleason
2004, US Tour: Brad Little, Rebecca Pitcher, Tim Martin Gleason
2004, Stuttgart: Thomas Schulze, Maike Switzer, Carsten Lepper
2005, London: John Owen-Jones, Rachel Barrell, Oliver Thornton
2005, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Julie Hanson, John Cudia
2005, Broadway: James Romick, Marie Danvers, John Cudia
2005, Broadway: Tim Martin Gleason, Susan Owen, Stephen Buntrock
2005, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Sandra Joseph, Tim Martin Gleason
2005, Essen: Thomas Borchert, Anne Gorner, Nikolaj A. Brucker
2005, Essen: Thomas Borchert, Sandra Danyella, Nikolaj A. Brucker
2006, London: Earl Carpenter, Rachel Barrell, David Shannon
2006, London: Matthew Cammelle, Rachel Barrell, David Shannon
2006; Essen: Ethan Freeman, Anne Gorner, Nikolaj A. Brucker
2006, Sao Paulo: Saulo Vasconcelos, Kiara Sasso, Nando Prado (audience recording)
2006, Sao Paulo: Saulo Vasconcelos, Kiara Sasso, Nando Prado (monitor video)
2006, US Tour: Gary Mauer, Elizabeth Southard, Jim Weitzer
2006, US Tour: John Cudia, Jennifer Hope Wills, Adam Monley
2006, Essen: Uwe Kroger, Beatrix Reiterer, Lucius Wolter
2006, Broadway: Howard McGillin, Rebecca Pitcher, Michael Shawn Lewis
2007, Broadway: Gary Mauer, Jennifer Hope Wills, Jason Mills
2008, World Tour: Simon Pryce, Ana Marina, Alexander Lewis
2008, Broadway: Howard McGillin, Elizabeth Loyacano, Jeremy Stolle
2008, Las Vegas: Anthony Crivello, Kristi Holden, Andrew Ragone
2008, Poland: Tomasz Steciuk, Kaja Mianowana, Lukasz Talik
2008, London: Ramin Karimloo, Gina Beck, Simon Bailey
2009; Australia: Anthony Warlow, Ana Marina, Alexander Lewis
2010, London: David Shannon, Gina Beck, Simon Bailey
2012, London: Marcus Lovett, Anna O’Byrne, Simon Thomas (highlights)
2012, UK Tour: Earl Carpenter, Olivia Brereton, Earl Carpenter
2012, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Samantha Hill, Kyle Barisich
2013, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Sierra Boggess, Kyle Barisich
2013, Broadway: Peter Joback, Marni Raab, Kyle Barisich
2014, World Tour: Brad Little, Claire Lyon, Anthony Downing
2014, Broadway: Jeremy Stolle, Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays
2014, Broadway: Paul A. Schaefer, Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays
2014; US Tour: Cooper Grodin, Julia Udine, Ben Jacoby
2014, US Tour: Cooper Grodin, Grace Morgan, Ben Jacoby
2014, Broadway: Greg Mills, Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays
2014, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Elizabeth Welch, Jeremy Hays
2014, Broadway: Hugh Panaro, Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays
2014, Broadway: Norm Lewis, Sierra Boggess, Jeremy Hays
2014, Broadway: Norm Lewis, Kaley Ann Voorhees, Jeremy Hays
2014, Broadway: Laird Mackintosh, Kaley Ann Voorhees, Jeremy Hays
2014, Hamburg: David Arnsperger, Valerie Link, Nicky Wuchinger
2014, Hamburg: David Arnsperger, Lauri Brons, Nicky Wuchinger
2015, Hamburg: Mathias Edenborn, Daniela Braun, Nicky Wuchinger
2015, US Tour: Chris Mann, Katie Travis, Storm Lineberger
2016, Moscow: Andrey Shkoldychenko, Elena Bahtiyarova, Evgeny Zaytsev
2016, Moscow: Ivan Ozhogin, Tamara Kotova, Rinat Albikov
2016, Broadway: Laird Mackintosh, Julia Udine, Jeremy Hays
2017, Stockholm: Peter Joback, Emmi Christensson, Anton Zetterholm
2017, Gothenburg: Fred Johanson, Sofie Asplund, John Martin Bengtsson (Act 1 only)
2018, Broadway: Ben Crawford, Ali Ewoldt, Jay Armstrong Johnson
2019, Copenhagen: Tomas Ambt Kofod, Sibylle Glosted, Christian Lund
2019, Sao Paulo: Fred Silveira, Lina Mendes, Henrique Moretzsohn
2019, Sao Paulo: Fred Silveira, Giulia Nadruz, Henrique Moretzsohn
2019, Sao Paulo: Thiago Arancam, Darua Goes, Fred Silveira
2019, Sao Paulo: Thiago Arancam, Giulia Nadruz, Fred Silveira
587 notes
·
View notes