Robin be like "I love my friends so much :) I think I will commit murder now"

I'm thinking of reading Kencyrath, but I'm not sure whether i'll like it. What do you like about the series? Who would you recommend it for?

OKAY SO, first, the people I would recommend it to:

Anyone who read or watched more than half a book/four episodes of Game of Thrones--the Kencyrath has a similar list of trigger warnings, but commits much harder to the fantasy angle, and in my opinion deals more directly with the ethical problems raised by those trigger warnings

People who like those posts picking apart the minutiae of how high fantasy worlds work--the Kencyrath is one of the only series I’m familiar with that answers the question of “okay great you have a warrior race, so how does that actually work” with “it kind of doesn’t, everyone is starving half the time because we’re all warriors and our land can barely grow food, so if our mercenaries don’t get paid, we don’t eat”

People who like a mix of “low fantasy” moral questions (the first book is kind of like...hm, Lies of Locke Lamora?) with classic “high fantasy” political machinations and battles of good vs evil and such--the Kencyrath HAVE a grand sweeping destiny more or less on their doorstep, but they’ve sort of fallen down on the job about it

People who like books that deal with trauma recovery--Jame, the main character, spends most of her time trying to drag herself (and, ideally, her brother, cousin, and entire race) out of the cycle of abuse that they’ve all lived through, and every character has, to some extent, a trauma that shapes their actions one way or another

People who don’t mind a big cast as long as there are a couple main characters to focus on--the Kencyrath ends up being a pretty expansive cast, with a lot of schemes running at any given time, but it always revolves around Jame and her twin brother Tori

People who like complex societal worldbuilding and Loyalty Stuff--the Kendar/Highborn dynamic (warrior class/ruling class) is so wonderfully messed up and I love how seriously the books take both the advantages and massive pitfalls of that kind of society

People who listened to TAZ Balance and thought that the Hunger was really cool and terrifying and wanted a whole book series about the sequence where the world is fighting it

Anyone who ever read a standard high fantasy book with a Rambunctious Young Lady as the lead and went “this is fine, but if you’re going to spend 250 pages telling me that this girl is wild and uncontrollable, I would like to see her go completely feral, please”--Jame’s brain plays Yakety Sax 24/7 and you can TELL, so if you ever wanted a book where the Unladylike Lead Character goes genuinely apeshit, but also learns how to make friends and respect the value of traditionally feminine work even if it’s not for her

People I would recommend NOT read the Kencyrath:

Anyone who knows they are triggered by written discussion of assault, abuse, sexism, coercion, torture, flashbacks, racism, murder, or basically any other major trigger warning--I personally think the books deal with things pretty well, and they’re never grimdark, but they deal with a lot of incredibly heavy material, including child abuse, sexual assault, coercion, and torture.  If you know you have a major trigger that really messes you up when you read about it, please exercise caution and feel free to contact me for more details.  Also, if you have a specific trigger and want a different book recommendation, I have them on tap.  

Anyone who struggles to read or connect with “problematic” characters--pretty much every character in this series will EVENTUALLY do something you don’t like, including Jame.  The books go very hard on “who you are is defined by how you handle making an irreparable mistake,” so be prepared for that.  If this is your hard stop but everything else is fine, I would recommend the Imperial Radch series by Ann Leckie (spaceships and war crimes and found family), or something by Robin McKinley (mostly fantasy), especially the Damar books or Sunshine!

Anyone for whom incest between twins is a hard stop--the primary romantic relationship is Jame/Tori, and while I would consider it easily the healthiest relationship in the series, that’s the ship and you should be aware of it.  If this is your hard stop but everything else is fine, I would recommend the Captive Prince series by CS Pacat (political scheming and romance) or the Winternight trilogy by Katherine Arden (fairy tale fantasy)!

The stuff I like about the series:

Jame.  I love that she’s allowed to be completely unhinged.  I love that she faces consequences for her actions.  I love her determination to slit reality open and lay it all out like a scientist in her search for the truth.  I love her willingness to face unpleasant realities, and I love the times when she can’t bear them and has to figure out how to deal.  I love every second she spends trying to figure out how honor works, and whether it’s even possible for a Highborn to be honorable, and how she can save her people without sacrificing who she is.  I love to watch people pick a fight with her and immediately learn the error of her ways.

Tori.  I know I pick on him a lot, and he deserves to be picked on, but Tori is really one of my favorite characters.  He struggles a lot more than Jame to move past their father’s abuse, and he makes a lot of genuinely harmful choices in the depths of that struggle, but I love watching the times where he wins.  It makes me frustrated beyond words when he caves to what he was taught, but I’m always elated when he can push past that and reveal the deeply loyal, sincerely honorable, incredibly good person that he became in spite of their father.  He’s a good leader, despite everyone’s best efforts, and I love to see him fight for his people.  Love to see him consider HIMSELF one of “his people” someday.

Kindrie.  I won’t say too much about him, except that I didn’t actually like him that much when I first read the books, for basically the exact reasons Jame didn’t like him much at first--he’s someone doing trauma recovery in the exact opposite way that I was comfortable with.  But god I love him so much, he is doing his best and his best is so much better than anyone would expect, from his past.  Truly the best boy in the Kencyrath, wise beyond his years and just insane enough to get into the disasters where he’s most needed.

The Kendar.  Instead of making this post 4k with individual bullet points about every Kendar I love, here is a brief litany.  I love Marc because he’s the only stable person in the Kencyrath.  I love Brier because she’s doing her best and it would be okay if everyone (including her) admitted that she doesn’t always know what that actually means.  I love Burr and Rue because their rabid determination to turn Tori and Jame (Confirmed Feral Cats) into real nobility will never NOT be funny to me.  I love Sheth Sharp-tongue because he’s the only person with his shit so together that not even Jame can ruffle him.  I love the Randir Kendar who didn’t move, at the start of Bound in Blood.  The Kendar are the most nuanced take on the concept of an eternally loyal warrior caste I’ve ever seen and I love them.

The Villains.  I believe I have established that I love a nuanced villain.  The Master is a pretty straight up and down villain figure, the voice of the darkness, John Hunger or Saruman or whatever else you might like to compare him to, but no one else is that simple.  I love the Dreamweaver, who didn’t know what she was doing and paid for it anyway.  I love Tyrandis, who knew what he was doing and did it and spent his eternity trying to fix it without breaking a single rule.  I do NOT love Caldane, but he’s a kind of viscerally real, slimy evil that is exceptionally well executed.  Likewise, I would like Rawneth to die, painfully, in short order, but godDAMN watching her chessboard unfold over the course of the books is hypnotic. The villains in this are GOOD, folks, and I like them.

I really need to wrap this up, so my last pick for what I like is Overpowered Characters.  I complain a lot about media that panics over powerful characters, and responds by taking that power away, or having unstable worldbuilding that means the character is weak when the narrative demands it.  The Kencyrath doesn’t do that.  Jame is bonkers powerful from day one, and pretty much maintains that level through the series.  Instead of focusing on characters building their power, like leveling in DnD, the Kencyrath focuses on the question of using power.  Jame’s power in the first book is terrifying not just because she’s insanely strong, but because she has no idea how to use it.  Likewise, Tori is determined pretty quickly to be at the same level that she is, but he’s in such deep denial that he’s as likely to kill himself as do anything useful.  It’s just very SATISFYING, okay, to have a series actually do interesting things with OP characters.  Sure, in a weird way Jame seems less like a magical nuke in book 8 than in book 1, but it’s because she’s not just throwing power around like someone playing darts blindfolded.  And watching her figure out how to harness her power into something useful is so gratifying.

Reaction of Joker: this is my prequel to The Dark Knight and I don’t need you telling me its not, I need you to write a fanfic

The only non-spoiler thing I can immediately think of is “Every Joker deserves a dance number.”

Okay, on to a non-chronological blurt of my feelings disgusted as a review.

1) Right off the bat: THOMAS WAYNE IS NOT A VILLAIN. He is, however, the father of Batman and acted exactly as any red-blooded Wayne does. That punch was so sharp, my vision flickered and I thought it was Batman punching Joker.

2) lol, Bruce was so catatonic. I’ve interpreted Bruce Wayne as being a special needs kid since I was a kid and I kinda wanted that kid to say he had a condition in much of the same way Arthur has to apologize with “I have a condition.”

3) Last Wayne comment, I’m sorry, but its them, is that many of you have wondered if Suicide Squad counts as a Batman movie. After watching Batman v Superman and Joker, we can now say, no, it does not. Because Bruce Wayne’s parents didn’t die in front of a theater showing of Zorro in Suicide Squad. You may, in your ignorance and naivety say that Batman and Robin and Batman Forever didn’t feature this. Which, frankly, proves my point. If they wanted to be true Batman movies, they would have atleast had a picture of Thomas and Martha pre-shot-to-death like The Lego Batman Movie. There is no point to ANY story set in Gotham City if Thomas and Martha aren’t shot in it.

4) Anyway, 10/10 movie. Go watch it. Watch it again. You haven’t watched it enough times. The Clown Prince of Crime is... the King Lear/Macbeth of the modern age. It’s like... “You think you are a good actor, capable of depth and range, able to make an audience feel for you even as you spiral into depravity? Oh, then let me see the clip of you playing as the Joker.”

5) 1981 looked awful. I’m so happy to have been raised in the 90s.

6) This really was a comedy. Joker found true community, belonging and a sense of purpose. ... In Arkham. That’s beautiful. (Dear god, you wouldn’t believe how many people cheered in my theater at every dramatic “upswing”. Like, literally howling with released tension when Arthur shot the city boys.)

7) After about the 3rd hallucination of “Black Harley” i began to actually think she was real, probably only because once his stand up was confirmed as real, I started to think she was, too. LOL, NVM, no one loves you, Arthur. I wonder if how many people are going to go apeshit because three black women died in this movie. ... ... Oh, wait, the first social worker didn’t die.

8) Once Arthur got into the habit of killing, NBC’s Hannibal Lector started speaking in my head, “Honestly, you’d be far healthier if you killed him.”

9) I want a sequel of this, but I don’t want one, but I do, but I don’t... But I do... 

10) In the smallest recesses of my mind, I was scared the movie really was going to make them brothers. I was fearful for my batjokes fangirls.

11) I don’t care how little it makes sense, in my fevered daydreams, this is canonically a prequel with Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy and Ledger!Joker is the modern copycat killer of a madman from 1981. And BvS/SS are now the 20-year future story of a middle-aged Batman enduring his Robin being kidnapped and tortured into being the 3rd Joker. I’m sorry... but if WB didn’t want me to do this, they should not have made “Joker is significantly older than Bruce” “Joker is the same age as Bruce” and “Joker is significantly younger than Bruce” movies all in a fucking row. 

THIS IS THE WORLD, NOW. Because the Joker lives to torment Bruce Wayne and will continue to do so, even when he dies. Because that adorable little blank face needs to SMILE.