Suit Valuation and Court Fee: A Comprehensive Legal Guide
Introduction
The Suit Valuation and Court Fee Payment are pivotal aspects of civil litigation in India. They determine the jurisdiction of the court, the amount of stamp duty, and the adequacy of the relief sought. The valuation of a suit depends on the nature of the relief claimed and the subject matter involved. The payment of court fee is governed by the Court Fees Act, 1870, and the rules made by the State Governments. This article delves into the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC), and the Court Fees Act, 1870, along with landmark judgments that have shaped the legal landscape in this regard.
Legal Framework: Provisions in the CPC and Court Fees Act
Section 7(4)© of the Court Fees Act, 1870
This section stipulates that for a relief for declaration and consequential relief, ad valorem court fees, i.e., as per the value of the suit property, are to be paid. The value of the suit property is determined by its market value or by any other mode prescribed by law.
Article 17 of Schedule II, Court Fees Act, 1870
In cases where only declaratory relief is sought, without any consequential relief affecting any property or right, a fixed court fee of Rs 250 is applicable.
Section 3 of the Suit Valuation Act, 1887
This section empowers the State Government to make rules for determining the value of land for jurisdictional purposes. The rules may prescribe different modes of valuation for different classes of suits or areas.
Section 8 of the Suit Valuation Act, 1887
This section specifies that in certain cases, such as suits for accounts, partition, administration, injunctions, etc., the valuation of the suit for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction shall be the same.
Landmark Judgments
Srihari Hanumandas Totala v. Hemant Vithal Kamat & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 4665/2021
This case clarified the scope and applicability of Order VII Rule 14(3) of the CPC, which deals with documents not in possession or power of the plaintiff. The Court held that this rule does not apply to documents which are public records or which can be easily accessed by due diligence. It also held that a plaint cannot be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) on account of non-production or non-listing of such documents1.
State Of Punjab vs Dev Brat Sharma & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 292/2022
This case held that under Section 7(i) of the Court Fees Act, 1870, ad valorem court fees would be payable on the amount claimed if the suit is a money suit for compensation and damages. It also held that it is only with respect to suits specified in clause (iv) of Section 7 that the plaintiff has the liberty of stating in the plaint the amount at which relief is valued2.
Agra Diocesan Trust Association vs Anil David And Ors., Civil Appeal No. 1722/2020
The Supreme Court of India in Agra Diocesan Trust Association vs Anil David And Ors., Civil Appeal No. 1722/2020, held that a suit for cancellation of sale deed and permanent injunction is not a suit for declaration with consequential relief under Section 7(iv)© of the Court Fees Act, 1870. It also held that such a suit has to be valued as per Section 7(v) read with Section 25(1)(b)(ii)(a)(ii) of the Uttar Pradesh Court Fees (Amendment) Act, 1976, which provides for valuation based on thirty times of annual rent or revenue.
The Supreme Court relied on its earlier decision in Shantaben v. State of Gujarat3, where it was held that a suit for cancellation of sale deed is not a suit for declaration with consequential relief, but a suit for specific performance of contract. The Court also observed that the plaintiff was not a party to the sale deed and therefore, he could not seek its cancellation on the ground of fraud or misrepresentation. The Court further noted that the plaintiff had not challenged the validity of the sale deed, but only sought its cancellation as it affected his rights over the property. Therefore, the Court concluded that the suit was essentially one for specific performance of contract and hence, it had to be valued as per Section 7(v) read with Section 25(1)(b)(ii)(a)(ii) of the Uttar Pradesh Court Fees (Amendment) Act, 1976.
Conclusion
The valuation of a suit and the payment of court fees are governed by specific legal provisions and judicial precedents. Proper compliance ensures the smooth conduct of civil litigation and avoids unnecessary objections or delays.
References
- Srihari Hanumandas Totala v. Hemant Vithal Kamat & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 4665/202111
- State Of Punjab vs Dev Brat Sharma & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 292/202222
- Agra Diocesan Trust Association vs Anil David And Ors., Civil Appeal No. 1722/202043
Provisions of Law
Provisions of Law
Sr. No.
Provision / Section of Law
Exact text of the Provision / Section of Law
1
Section 7(4)©, Court Fees Act, 1870
“In suits for a declaratory decree and consequential relief, fee shall be computed on the amount at which the relief sought is valued in the plaint or memorandum of appeal.”
2
Article 17, Schedule II, Court Fees Act, 1870
“Fixed court fee of Rs 250 shall be applicable for declaratory relief.”
3
Section 3, Suit Valuation Act, 1887
“Power of the State Government to make Rules determining value of land for jurisdictional purposes.”
4
Section 8, Suit Valuation Act, 1887
“Valuation of the suit for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction shall be the same.”
5
Order VII Rule 14(3), CPC, 1908
“Where any document relied on is not in the possession or power of the plaintiff, he shall, as far as possible, state in whose possession or power it is.”
6
Order VII Rule 11(d), CPC, 1908
“The plaint shall be rejected where the suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law.”
7
Section 7(i), Court Fees Act, 1870
“In suits for money (including suits for damages or compensation, or arrears of maintenance, of annuities, or of other sums payable periodically) - according to the amount claimed.”
8
Section 7(iv), Court Fees Act, 1870
“In suits - (a) for movable property of no market-value; (b) to enforce a right to share in any property on the ground that it is joint family property; © for a declaratory decree and consequential relief - according to the amount at which the relief sought is valued in the plaint or memorandum of appeal. In all such suits the plaintiff shall state the amount at which he values the relief sought: Provided that minimum court-fee in respect of such suits shall be fifteen rupees.”
9
Section 7(v), Court Fees Act, 1870
“In suits for the possession of land, houses and gardens - according to the value of the subject-matter; and such value shall be deemed to be - where the subject-matter is land, and - (a) where the land forms part of an estate paying annual revenue to Government, or forms part of an estate paying revenue to Government but not at a fixed rate; or forms part of an estate paying no revenue to Government but paying a fixed sum annually to a superior landlord; according to one-fifth of the revenue payable by such estate or part thereof respectively; (b) where the land forms part of an estate paying revenue to Government but not at a fixed rate; or forms part of an estate paying no revenue to Government but paying a fixed sum annually to a superior landlord; according to one-fifth of such revenue or fixed sum respectively; © where the land pays no such revenue or fixed sum - according to one-fifth of the net profits accruing from such land during the year next before the date of presenting the plaint; (d) where rent is paid by a tenant with special rights - according to one-fifth of such rent;”
10
Section 25(1)(b)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii)(a)(ii) (a) (ii) (a) (ii) (a) (ii) (a) (ii) (a) (ii) (a) (ii), Court Fees Act, 1870
“In suits for possession under section seven paragraph five clause (d), thirty times such rent.”
Learn more:
- casemine.com
- indianemployees.com
- vlex.in
- advocatetanmoy.com
Read the full article
0 notes
Best Comedy South Indian Movies Dubbed in Hindi list
If we talk about the present time, the craze for comedy South Indian movies has increased. Not only comedy, action, romance, drama, historical epic films have been given by South Industry. We have come up with a list of top comedy South Indian movies which are dubbed in Hindi as well. If we talk about the story of South Indian movie, then the movie of South Industry is very famous for it.
Top Comedy South Indian Movies Dubbed in Hindi list
South stars like Allu Arjun, Joseph Vijay, Mahesh Babu, Raghava Lawrence, Rajinikanth who have made many people laugh in the film. Who can forget the legendary comedians like Brahmanandam, Vadivelu, Goundamani, Senthil, Santhanam, Prithvi Raj, Brahmachari and how they made us laugh with their comic timing in the films.
1. Thamizh Padam (2010)
Credit: YNOT Studios YouTube Image: ScreenShot
Director & Writer:- C.S. Amudhan
Star-cast:- Shiva, Disha Pandey, Venniradai Moorthy
Budget:- 1.8 Cr
Collection:- 7 Cr
IMDb:- 6.4/10
Plot
"The story revolves around Shiva, a confident and comical protagonist, and navigates a world full of over-the-top characters and situations typical of Tamil cinema. He pokes fun at everything from hero worship to melodrama, but at the same time pursues romantic feelings and confronts over-the-top villains. The film playfully deconstructs and satirizes the stereotypical elements of Tamil cinema through clever satire and humor, making it a hilarious and entertaining parody."
2. Soodhu Kavvum (2013)
Image: Twitter Credit: @gowthaman_96
Director:- Nalan Kumarasamy
Star-cast:- Vijay Sethupathi, Bobby Simha, Ashok Selvan, Ramesh Thilak
Budget:- 2 Cr
Collection:- 35 Cr
IMDb:- 8.3/10
Plot
"Led by Das (played by Vijay Sethupathi), this incompetent group decides to kidnap the son of a politician, believing it to be an easy way to get some quick money. However, their plans are derailed when the victim's family surprisingly endorses the kidnapping, resulting in a chaotic and unpredictable roller coaster ride full of humor, suspense and unexpected twists and turns. really entertaining."
3. Premam (2015)
Director:- Alphonse Puthren
Star-cast:- Nivin Pauly, Sai Pallavi
Budget:- 4 Cr
Collection:- 76 Cr
IMDb:- 8.3/10
Plot
"The film beautifully captures his romantic encounters with three women: Mary (Anupama Parameswaran), Malal (Sai Pallavi) and Celine (Madonna Sebastian), each of whom had a profound impact on his life. Set against the picturesque backdrop of a college campus and the seaside town of Aluva, the film explores the nuances of the lessons of love, friendship, and heartbreak."
4. Bangalore Days
Image Credit: Hotstar
Director:- Anjali Menon
Star-cast:- Nivin Pauly, Nazriya Nazim, Dulquer Salmaan, Fahadh Faasil, Isha Talwar, Parvathy Thiruvothu, Nithya Menen
Budget:- 8 Cr
Collection:- 45 Cr
IMDb:- 8.3/10
Plot
"Each character embarks on a personal journey. Divya tries to balance her married life and career aspirations, Krishnan explores her passion for photography and love, and Arjun chases her dream of becoming a cyclist. Their individual struggles and triumphs are intertwined with themes of family, friendship, love and achieving dreams, making 'Bangalore Days' a touching and relatable coming-of-age story."
5. Dhee/Sabse Badi Hera Pheri
Director:- Srinu Vytla
Writter:- Kona Venkat, Gopimohan
Star-cast:- Vishnu Manchu, Genelia D'Souza, Srihari, Brahmanandam
Budget:- 5 Cr
IMDb:- 7.2/10
Plot
"An irresponsible man is hired by his father to work as an accountant for a local hooligan hero. After he learns that the hooligan's sister is being threatened by another local hooligan hero, he loves her sister and plans to marry her and kill the hooligan."
6. Don Seenu/Sabse Bada Don
Image Credit: @RaviTejaFan_AP
Director:- Gopichand Malineni
Writter:- Gopichand Malineni, Kona Venkat
Star-cast:- Ravi Teja, Srihari, Shriya Saran, Anjana Sukhani
Budget:- 30 Cr
IMDb:- 6.1/10
Plot
"To become known as a gang leader, a man must woo a dangerous gangster's sister. The film is a roller coaster of laughter, romance, and action, with Seenu's comical attempts to infiltrate the crime world leading to interesting situations, and Ravi Teja's nimbleness showcasing his comedic timing and charisma. It's a great movie experience."
7. Race Gurram/Lucky: The Racer
Image Credit: Goldmines Cineplex
Director:- Surender Reddy
Writter:- Deepak Raj, Vikram Siri, Vakkantham Vamsi
Star-cast:- Allu Arjun, Shruti Haasan, Shaam, Ravi Kishan
Budget:- 52 Cr
Collection:- 101 Cr
IMDb:- 7.3/10
Plot
"Ram is a carefree and energetic young man who aspires to become a police officer, while Lakshman is a polite and disciplined police officer. The plot revolves around their conflicts and adventures as they work together to defeat the notorious and powerful criminal Shankar (played by Ravi Kishan)."
8. Aagadu
Director:- Sreenu Vaitla
Writter:- Sreenu Vaitla, Upendra Madhav
Star-cast:- Mahesh Babu, Tamannaah, Sonu Sood, Shruti Haasan, Brahmanandam
Budget:- 65 Cr
IMDb:- 5.3/10
Plot
"When Mahesh Babu is transferred to a small town, he meets Damodar, a corrupt and powerful politician, played by Sonu Sood, who has a strong hold on the town and its people. Shankar takes up the challenge of bringing justice to Damodar while dealing with several ridiculous and action-packed situations with the help of an eccentric police team, making 'Aagaadu' a humorous and thrilling police drama."
9. Beeruva
Image: Screenshot Credit: Premium Digiplex Movies
Director:- Kanmani
Writter:- Kanmani
Star-cast:- Sundeep Kishan, Surbhi, Mukesh Rishi
Budget:- 65 Cr
IMDb:- 5.9/10
Plot
"The story depicts the life of Sandeep, played by Sandeep Kishan, a carefree and fun-loving young man who comes into possession of a mysterious bierva (a pendant-like ornament) by chance. This Birva has the ability to exchange one person's soul with another and chaos ensues when Sandeep's soul is accidentally swapped with that of the son of a ruthless mafia don played by Ajay."
10. Goli Soda
credit: Youtube B4U Kadak Image: Screenshot
Director:- Vijay Milton
Writter:- Pandiraj, Vijay Milton
Star-cast:- Kishore, Sree Raam, Pandi, Murugesh, Seetha, Chandini
Budget:- 2 Cr
IMDb:- 7.7/10
Plot
"The story is set in Chennai's famous Koyambedu market. The film is a story about his four adolescent boys (Pasanga team of Kishore, Sreeram, Pandey and Mrugesh) whose lives revolve around the wholesale vegetable and fruit market in Chennai, Asia's largest. They are orphans brought up in the market and given strange names like Chittapa, Kuttimani, Puri and Setu. Your world revolves around this market. They have no other identity. The boys are taken care of by Archi (Sujata), a motherly vegetable wholesaler. This market is controlled by Naidu alias NKB, who rules with an iron fist. One day, the boys come into conflict with the NKB and things take a turn for the worse."
11. Pandavulu Pandavulu Tummeda/Sabse Badi Hera Pheri 3
image: Twitter Credit: Tollywood This Day
Director & Writter:- Sriwass
Star-cast:- Vishnu Manchu, Manoj Manchu, Hansika Motwani, Pranitha Subhash, Mohan Babu, Raveena Tandon
Budget:- 15 Cr
Collection: 16 Cr
IMDb:- 5.5/10
Plot
"When Naidu confronts his son's rival group to end an argument, he meets their mother Satya, torn apart by a twist of fate. After learning Naidu and Satya's secret, Honey is kidnapped by Suyodhana Goud, her father's biggest rival. This unfortunate event brings Naidu, Satya and their sons together, but they have to devise an ingenious escape plan for Honey."
12. Chal Mohan Ranga/A AA 2
image: Youtube screenshot Credit: Aditya Movies
Director & Writter:- Krishna Chaitanya
Star-cast:- Nithiin, Megha Akash, Ashu Reddy
Budget:- 15 Cr
Collection: 19 Cr
IMDb:- 5.8/10
Plot
"The film revolves around Mohan Ranga, an ambitious young man played by Nithiin. Mohan Ranga goes to America to pursue his dreams but returns to India after a series of misfortunes. When he returns home, he meets Megha Subrahmanyam, played by Megha Akash, whom he admired as a child. When they reunite, their love story takes center stage, but various challenges and misunderstandings threaten to tear them apart. The film depicts their journey to rekindle their love while overcoming comical and heartwarming circumstances."
Read More
- From Sunny Deol to Utkarsh Sharma: What to Expect from Gadar 2 Teaser?
- Scam 2003: The Telgi Story Teaser, release date, Star-cast, and Update
- Which Ott platform does Gadar 2 release?
- Ponniyin Selvan 2 OTT Release Date on Mani Ratnam’s birthday
- Exploring the Intense Persona of 'Big Daddy' Shiva Rajkumar in Ghost Movie
- Love, Death, and Horror: 1920 Horrors of the Heart
- Dream Girl 2 vs. King Of Kotha Box Office Collection
- Gadar 2 Box Office Collections in 23 days
- Kushi movie review, Reaction and box office collection
- Gadar 2 is going to break the box office collection record of Bahubali 2
Read the full article
0 notes