#dont get me wrong i appreciate the wikia bc its useful but also. the point of me looking at it is | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

paigemathews · 2 years

Text

@plutoconjunctascendant replied to your post “The Charmed wikia is like. a really cool resource...”:

okay and here's the thing: it's literally not stated in tdmd that paige is a gemini, phoebe just says there's a cluster of planets in gemini, meaning wyatt was born with a gemini stellium & this has Nothing to do with paige >:/

I don’t know shit about horoscopes or astrology, nor what a stellium even is so I bow to your superior wisdom on that one (the only thing I know is that I’m an Aries :) )

I think that the Gemini thing is based off of this conversation, which sounds like Paige was supposed to be a Gemini if you don’t know anything about astrology (aka me)

Phoebe: Have you been experiencing uncontrollable emotional mood swings in the last week?

Paige: Am I that transparent?

Phoebe: No, but read your horoscope. Jupiter, Mars and Saturn are all in Gemini.

But also that is my point exactly!! They just casually have that "In the episode The Day the Magic Died, Phoebe stated that Paige is a Gemini.“ when a) she’s not b) this isn’t a source despite being referenced as one and c) they outright have her first trivia point that she’s a Leo!! Pick a continuity please!!

SPEAKING of birthdays though, would y’all like to know where they got the date for Piper and Phoebe’s birthdays? The Warren Family Tree. Which casually has Penny give birth to Patty before she turns 14, like no!! Don’t reference that!!

#plutoconjuctascendant #charmed #abi speaks #at this point i have legitimately decided that i will fuck up what i choose bc i'm not bothering to figure out what's technically canon #canon lost its timeline rights anyway with witchstock so.#dont get me wrong i appreciate the wikia bc its useful but also. the point of me looking at it is #so that i DON'T have to pick through the show to find what's canon and what's not

2 notes · View notes