here’s a health to the company and one to my lass 🎶

HOW CHIBNALL PISSED ME OFF

I have been away from Tumblr for years, but here I am now. The reason for my return is simple: Chibnall pissed me off and Facebook is not the right place for a a rant like the one you are going to read. Posting it on twitter would make more sense, you say? Probably. But I have no time to count words. I will start with why I had high expectantions on Chibanl and then I will explain how he shuttered every single one of them. 

1. When I heard Chibnall was coming after Moffat I was happy. I have always had that twisted relationship with Doctor Who where I loved the adventures, the adrenaline, the jokes, the discoveries, the aliens, but I also loved the feels and angst that came with the Companions and the Master. I had seen Broadchurch, so I “knew” Chibnall, I was sure enough he would not mess around. I was so wrong

2. Female!Doctor. Not a fan. Nu-uh. I have never felt the need for a female Doctor. There were plenty of great female characters in Doctor Who, both in the Classic era and the New era. Every single one of them had their own personality, their own skills and flaws. It was great, because they were actually people. Doctor Who was the first show that I watched where I didn’t get annoyed by female characters. They were strong in their own ways, and that didn’t mean being a super killing machine without special fighting skills. They were real and they were fundamental. Without them the Doctor lost his moral compass and we saw that more than once. So no, I didn’t need a female Doctor, I was alreay represented by amazing women in the show who were not less important than him. Moreover, I have no problem feeling represented by a man, I mean... men are still people, they have feelings and I am capable of understanding that. It’s called empathy. I am not so stupid that I cannot relate to a character only because they don’t have my genitalia. 

3. Lack of imagination. Another problem I have with a female Doctor is the same I have when authors remake characters, when they change gender or ethnicity to a character to give people representation. It’s insulting. You are basically saying that you are not capable of creating a new character for that minority (being women, an ethnic group or disabled people) without using a pre-existing character. It means that in your head, to detach yourself from the negative stereotypes, you need a white male model because you are not able to imagine a minority character without those flaws on your own.

4. Companions: Graham was fun compared to Ryan and Yaz, but if we compare the Companions to the older ones, the new ones lose. And lose real bad. They left me nothing. They characterization is non-existent, they follow the Doctor and that’s it. Ryan should have disability but it appears only when the screenwriter remembers. Meh. I don’t have much to say about them, they really didn’t left any impression on me. I was not fond of Martha and I can list reasons why, I couldn’t stand Clara and I can go on 30 minutes saying why. These new ones are just... meh.

5. The Doctor. I didn’t see him... her... them. Let’s start with a note: I saw Jodie in Broadchurch and I didn’t like her there, so when I found out she was going to be the new Doctor, I was not amazed. If it had to be a woman, I would have preferred someone else, but anyway. This Doctor didn’t have any special features, it just looked like an hyped 10 or 11, but without their depth. Kind is an adjective, not a character trait. I feel that her character was not studied enough, she didn’t have enough depth. It got better with the beginning of this new season but honestly? You can’t be able to write a character properly only when they face their nemesis. 

6. The episodes. Oh. My. God. The first season of this new Doctor was a series of episodes that looked like they jumped out of the 60s. Teaching people through an entertainment show doesn’t mean you have to take the show, make an episode on whatever the problem you want to discuss is and make some sort of documentary about it. It means you try to explain to people through fun, adventures, analogies... those who watch DW now are not 6 years old. They know that if you show them a genocide on another planet with segregation, spaceships etc, you are telling them not to be racist assholes. They do not need Rosa Parks to give them a lecture. Episode in which appears a villain with an unkown objective and we don’t see ever again, but ok. 

7. The cherry on top. The timeless children. What. The. Actual. Fuck. So Chibnall just decided to take 60 years of TV show and toss it into the garbage can, right? That was the purpose, right? Because otherwise I don’t see it. So the Doctor is a creature from another planet, not Gallifrey, who can regenerate. The Gallifreyan see them, think “oh nice” and go all Frankenstein on them. Noice. I have just a teeny tiny itsy bitsy problem with that. And for one I mean so many that they are more than the leaves on the trees in the Amazon forest. You are nullifying “End of time”, “This is Gallifrey”, the 50th anniversary... moreover Clara saw their past, she would have seen that something was off. They can’t remember? Fine. But it’s still there, it’s not like they transplanted their brain. 

8. The name of the Doctor. The big secret. The name that must never be spoken. The name that was keeping the universe together... and they revealed it like that. Brendan? Really? The name of the Doctor was a legend, you were not supposed to name them for real! Brendan? SERIOUSLY?

9. Doctor and Master. They were friends since they were kids. They grew up together. They studied together. They went on adventures together. They lost friends together. They grew apart and they kept fighting each other... but they were best enemies. Ok, a couple of times one really killed/let the other die, but go back to the beginning and count those times. They were two faces of the same coin, getting on each other nerves and saving each other over and over again. For the Doctor, the Master was the only other Time Lord in the universe for so long he was willing to pardon a genocide to save him (more than once). Their relationship was based on the fact that in a way they were complementary: the Master has no restraints, while the Doctor tries to be good when they both have done so many terrible things (including genocide, eh Doctor? You are not so innocent, honey). Their relationship was beautiful and painful. And it went down the drain. You are telling me that the Doctor is a superior being, they are not equals anymore, they are not two faces of the same coin, they are not even the same species so what are we talking about? And the coldness of the Doctor while she lets him die? Who the hell are you?

TL;DR Chibnall took a character I loved from a show I loved and torn it apart. The season and the characters were not written as I expected, I mean that they were 2D version of themselves, no depth there. Nothing interesting. I think he tried too much all at once: female Doctor, 3 companions, one shot episodes. Man, pick one thing you want to change and stick with it. You already have to run a show you have never run before, so you have to understand how to make it work. 4 characters are difficult to handle all at once and at the same time give them all the right space, depth and characterization in seasons that have less than 15 episodes each.

I am so pissed. I didn’t appreciate Jodie, but in a little corner of my mind I had always tought I would come back to Doctor Who once she was gone, but that’s not possible anymore. Funny thing is, this show made me meet the majority of my friends, the people with whom I started hanging our 6 years ago. We would have never met without DW probably. I kind of feel robbed now.

10 Questions Tag

Tagged by @kclenhartnovels

The Rules: answer these ten questions, create ten of you own, then tag ten people.

1. What is your OC’s biggest pet peeve?

Dawn hates unnecessary rudeness. Be nice unless you have a reason not to be.

2. What book that you’ve read did you wish you had written, or think you could have written better? I wish I could rewrite everything after the 3rd Maximum Ride book.

3. Which OC is smarter than you? What research did you have to do because of it? Mygre. I haven't had to do any research for it yet, and luckily I write sci-fi so most of it can just be technobabble with just a grounding in real science.

4. If you were doing immersive research for your book, where/when would you have to travel? Space/in the future. Believe me, I wish I could.

5. Which character is most like you? All of them have some bit or piece of me somewhere in them. Tobias and I share our overthinking tendencies, though. The most self-insert character I ever had was Aaliyah's predecessor before time passed and she developed into her own, different character. We do share several similarities, though. Sierra (OC from new WIP Ordinary) has a similar struggle to what I've had to deal with (inner struggle, not dealing with aliens who don't understand fiction).

6. What is your favorite scented candle and why? This is an interesting question! I tend to like "cleaner," natural scents- anything to do with trees, flowers, the ocean.

7. Do you have a bookshelf or library? What’s your ideal library look like? I barely even have a bookshelf rn (my apartment is v small)- I literally just have a piece of cardboard from my TV stand (that happened to fit perfectly) in my closet that supports my books. I would really like someday to have a house where I'll have a single bookshelf at the end of the hall that's actually a secret door to an awesome library filled with books and has a reading nook in a window.

8. Who is your biggest tumblr fan of your writing? Uh idk? I haven't shared that much writing haha but everyone is very supportive!

9. What tv show/movie has influenced your writing the most? Or, which series do you wish you could help write?

I'm influenced by almost everything I watch. I have definitely noticed my writing evolve after getting into a certain show. Firefly influenced Star Stuff a lot during the earlier days of writing it, but as it has evolved it's brought in a lot of other influences and I'm sure in the new rewrite there will be a lot less Firefly in it. Killjoys has had a big impact on how I want to portray my character's relationships (esp. friendship). And is the reason why I want a sassy talking ship somewhere. Also I tweaked Star Stuff's plot after watching 9 (really good movie 10/10 recommend) because I realized I needed to raise the stakes for better emotional investment. And it kind of helped fill a small plot hole.

I have definitely wished I could rewrite some Doctor Who episodes/storylines. But not going to lie I would love to have a hand in either DW or a Star Trek series someday.

10. How do you feel about fanfiction of your work?

I would be so flattered if someone loved my characters/world enough to write fanfic of it I would cry

See this post for tagging/questions