Tumgik
#bc i really respect and appreciate the way that John doesn’t see negative feelings as the antithesis to healing
starbuck · 1 year
Text
I remember back when The Mountain Goats No Children was a meme on here seeing a post that went “I hope you live, i hope we both live,” and it making me SO angry…
And this was before I had ever even listened to the song (or anything by TMG for that matter), but now, knowing that John wrote the song, and specifically the line “I hope you die, I hope we both die” in response to radio overplay of the sugary sweet I Hope You Dance, I feel even more vindicated, because like.
Yes. Ultimately my overall life philosophy is that I hope we all live… I would hope that goes without saying. But No Children isn’t a life philosophy. It’s about how sometimes everything sucks and you feel like shit and trapped and hopeless and angry and I HOPE YOU DIE, I HOPE WE BOTH DIE!!!!!!!!! And who can’t relate to that? Who has NEVER felt like that in their lives??????
I feel a little silly accusing what was ultimately just a joke meme post of Toxic Positivity, but that was the vibe I was getting from it, which is why it made me mad. As though it was sticking up its nose at a song it clearly had no understanding of and going “well I hope we both LIVE 😇😇” and like. Fuck you lol. It’s okay to feel negative emotions. It’s okay to be angry.
#tmg#the mountain goats#tagging bc i feel strongly about this lol… i’m sure i’m not the first to say this#but like. you know. if negative songs aren’t your thing then that’s cool - i respect that#but they still have a right to exist#it’s like people saying that stories with tragic endings shouldn’t exist… that non-hopeful stories should not exist#they can’t understand how people could get catharsis from that too#and it’s okay to not understand! there are plenty of things people enjoy that i’ll never understand#but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t exist#or need to be sanitized#idk… my personal experience with No Children is that i avoided listening to it for the LONGEST time bc i thought it’d just be edgy bullshit#but then i FINALLY listened to it and i was like ‘oh yeah - i’ve been there’#and i’ve been a Mountain Goats fan ever since#bc i really respect and appreciate the way that John doesn’t see negative feelings as the antithesis to healing#there are a lot of artists out there who are like ‘yeah i made a lot of negative songs when i was in a bad place but now i’m getting better#so i’m gonna make happy peppy songs now!’ and like. hey - good for them! more power to them!#but i like the acknowledgment that experiencing those darker feelings doesn’t mean you’re a terrible person or backsliding#it’s okay to just *FEEL*#and it’s okay to sing ‘No Children’ at the top of your lungs in your house all alone#you might even feel BETTER afterwards!#don’t know until you try it!!
74 notes · View notes
Text
This or That Tag
I was tagged by @itsahuman Thanks!! Rules: answer all of the questions, add one question of your own at the end, and then tag as many people as there are questions! 1. Coke or Pepsi? 
Coke 
2. Disney or Dreamworks? 
Hmmm I genuinely love both but I have to say Disney 
3. Coffee or Tea? 
I can’t stand coffee so tea all the way 
4. Books or Movies? 
I could make a strong argument for both but at this point in my life I’m going to say movies. I watch so many when I procrastinate and I love talking about them 
5. Windows or Mac? 
The only laptop I’ve ever had is a mac so yeah 
6. DC or Marvel? 
As much as I freaking love batman, I know way more about Marvel so I’ve gotta go with them 
7. Xbox or Playstation? 
It’s been years since I’ve played with any kind of gaming console so idk PlayStation I guess? 
8. Dragon Age or Mass Effect? 
I don’t know what this means… 
9. Night Owl or Early Riser? 
100% night owl. I am NOT a morning person and never have been 
10. Cards or Chess? 
Hmmm I always forget how to play card games and have to have them explained to me all the time but they’re really fun. I also love chess but I think I’ll go with cards because there are more options 
11. Chocolate or Vanilla? 
Chocolate!! 
12. Vans or Converse? 
I refused to wear any shoes that weren’t converse from like 7-10th grade 
13. Lavellan, Trevelyan, Cadash, or Adaar? 
What 
14. Paragon or Renegade? 
Honestly I am so sorry I don’t know what any of these things mean 
15. Star Wars or Star Trek? 
Star Wars! That last scene in Rogue One with darth Vader still has me shook 
16. One episode per week or binge watch? 
I guess kind of in between now? I’ve definitely done my fair share of bingeing but now I try to do an episode per day 
17. Gandalf or Obi-Wan? 
Love ‘em both but I have to say Gandalf 
18. Heroes or Villains? 
Really depends. Like I love Magneto and he’s considered a villain plus I have respect for darth Vader and deadpool who is kind of inbetween guy. But I really love batman and Spider-Man and wolverine so…all? 
19. John Williams or Hans Zimmer? 
Zimmer 
20. Disneyland/World or Six Flags? 
I have never been to Disney world but I have been to Disneyland a few times since I’m from California so I’ll have to say there 
21. Forest or Sea? 
I love the ocean but like…I can’t swim, so forest because it’s calm and refreshing and camping is fun 
22. Flying or Reading Minds? 
I do love mind powers but I think I’d rather have flying just because it sounds fun and there are somethings people think that are better left unheard by others 
23. Twin Peaks or Northern Exposure? 
Neither 
24. Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings? 
Love love love both but I think my blog is pretty obvious in stating my love for Harry Potter 
25. You’re banished to a deserted island, which Benedict Cumberbatch character would you choose to take with you? 
Oh god…seeing as I’ve only ever seen him in like three things I guess Sherlock. He’s insufferable but at least living on the island would be interesting 
26. Train or cruise ship? 
Trains are pretty neat. I don’t really like boats 
27. Brian Cox or Neil deGrasse Tyson? 
Neil deGrasse Tyson bc idk who Brian Cox is 
28. Art museum or science museum? 
Art museum for sure. I’m a sucker for any kind of art and I love spending time by myself ag museums 
29. Irish Pub or Night Club? 
I don’t think I’ve ever been to a night club but it really doesn’t sound like my scene. And an Irish pub specifically sounds a little intense and I like to keep my drinking light so neither really, but if I had to choose I guess the pub 
30. Aang or Korra? 
I still haven’t seen Korra but I guess Aang just because that’s like one of the best cartoons ever created and it was a defining piece of my childhood 
31. Swimming in a pool or lake? 
Again, I can’t swim but I think I’d much rather prefer a pool. It just feels cleaner and more contained (no slimy things touching my legs in the dark) 
32. Classic music or classic literature? 
Classic literature. I’m a huge English nerd 
33. Oxford comma or no oxford comma? 
Don’t really care I guess but I’m a journalism student and they told us not to use it so out of habit I don’t 
34. Digital or Paper books? 
Paper. I really appreciate the convenience of digital and am not opposed to them at all bc I do have an e-reader, but I like tactile books so I can get a few for the pages and the for and the weight of it all. I like stroking the cover and smelling the pages and hearing them turn and all that jazz. Again, I’m a total book nerd 
35. Rainy or Sunny days? 
Rainy days. I was born in the summer so it seems like I should prefer sunny but I live for the sound of the rain on windows and the feeling of those negative ions in the air 
36. Fantasy or Science Fiction? 
Definitely both. As long as there’s some sort of mystery involved, I’m in. 
37. Flowers or Succulents 
Both are wonderful and realistically I should probably take care of a succulent before I take care of a flower, but I think I do prefer flowers. 
38. Berestain or Berestein 
Betestein and no one can tell me otherwise 39. Peace or happiness? Happiness, because peace sounds more like acceptance and being content. I want my life to be a little more than that if I’m lucky
My question: Indoors or outdoors?
I’m not tagging 39 people lol but please do this if you want to and I will definitely read it :)
1 note · View note