Hey I'd like to say this, Charlie has never explicitly said he is uncomfortable with the shipping/sexual fan works. (Only that his GF Grace doesn't really like them) Charlie heavily encourages shipping in the JRWI podcast, and has canonically had sex in said podcast with an npc- he isn't new to all this stuff lol he just never seen the insane amount of fan work coming from this SMP. Let's not make assumptions until Charlie himself explicitly says something about it.

basing what i say here off of this clip: https://clips.twitch.tv/AlluringKindBoarCeilingCat-qGlXgOmqD3s1JiH5

1. i dont know how to tell you that even when its "just" charlies girlfriend who has been stated to be actively uncomfortable you should still care because shes a human person and yes even her opinion matters here. because you should care about other people

2. charlie did not explicitly say "i am uncomfortable and people should stop making slimeriana porn" no but he does call the porn the weirdest fanart thats been made of him (and he doesnt say Of His Characters, he says Of Him. i wont say that this suddenly means the qsmp characters arent characters, they are, but i feel that makes it clear that this is different from jwri. which should have been obvious anyways?)

3. going off of 2, while weird is often used as a positive thing on tumblr, i certainly hope that you interact with people in the real world enough to know that charlie doesnt necessarily mean it positively here (especially made clear by how mariana mentions that he likes it, which.. clearly means he got the impression that charlie Doesnt)

4. the most i will admit here is that yes it wasnt an explicit boundary and i misspoke there. however i still think that people should be more considerate about the content that they make. grace is uncomfortable and charlie doesnt seem very comfortable himself based off basic use of context clues. from what i can tell i think one of his mods is going to ask for clarification so hopefully we can get a clarification but as far as what we have goes yeah i am fully within my right to say what I Feel is the correct course of action based off what has been said so far. thats not speaking for charlie thats just saying what i think. good day i hope debating about the morals of minecraft porn with some 17yr old on the internet was better than like idk going outside and feeling the sun on your face