Yeah but what if Catnap's pupils did that thing cat's eyes do, like, get wide and focused everytime he tickles one of the Smiling Critters and his tail did that slow wagging around and he got so relaxed with the playful chase and game that he started to purr while destroying his friends w tickles because he loves to hear their laugh so much that sometimes he even gets so distracted by it + their cute reactions and don't realize that he stopped tickling and started doing biscuits before catching himself and increasing his attack so his friends won't tease him.

What if he immediately snuggles with them when he is over and they're still laying on the floor giggling their heads off, creating the perfection situation to a nap and nice cuddles. What if that is the reason they start looking for him after a nightmare or a difficult night

And what about him also purring when the smiling critters get their revenge and they realize that when the tickles are soft and light enough he ALSO starts doing biscuits and his laughter begins mixing w his purr when they tease him so what then