I read your post about wrong turn and I think what you wrote is just plain of confusing and just writes off the whole premise Jen shots Luis out of mercy knowing he is basically disoriented from the world, yes he is eating another human as she looks at him, these people are being thown down there with their eyes out being there for idk how long, but being without light, sight and resources disorients you from the world, the humans they eat are most likely those who did not survive and a way for them to survive, so no they do not make them immidietly become "less human" as you call it, they been down there for a time we do not know and we never get to find out how much Luis have changed more than that he was eating another human, but we can see that the others are way more disoriented, could she pull him out sure, but how do you help someone who most likely is in so much pain and who is now living on cannibalism to a regular life? she did what she thought was best, if she left him there he would get even more disoriented by time, so she helped him, stop taking movies out of context to be a social warrior

1. "your post is confusing" your response to me is all one single run-on sentence, don't try to have the highroad with me on 'confusing'

2. your ask is an anon this makes me think you arent comfortable exposing yourself as having the opinion that 'blind traumatized people should be killed because living like that is worse than death'. Come off anon and attach that to your online persona, otherwise pee your pants

3. "theyve been down there for I dont know how long" 5 weeks. You didn't pay any attention to the movie but you think you know more about it than me?

4. "being without light, sight and resources disorients you from the world" awful lotta irl blind people in the world would be pretty mad at you for thinking that they are inherently insane and should be killed because 'living without the light drives you insane'. You are referring to the specific convo i had at that time by quoting the person i argued with, so ive already refuted this. pee your pants

5. "they do not make them immidietly become "less human" as you call it" i was referring to the way the movie presented them as grunting and crawling and frightening which culminated in the movies hero killing them without speaking to them, as though they were animals incapable of responding or understanding her. I was specifically upset at the director for using the camera in a way that dehumanized them. You'll find that most blind people dont crawl on all fours and eat without the use of their still-functioning hands (specifically referring to the one that ate the guard, hunched over like a dog). These are directorial and acting decisions. Read my post again with critical thinking skills. i wasn't judging the blind characters, i was mad at the director

6. "she pull him out sure, but how do you help someone who most likely is in so much pain and who is now living on cannibalism to a regular life" by taking them to help. hes not a zombie, hes a blind man. we didn't take all the surviving members of Flight 571 out behind a shed and shoot them after they ate their friends to survive, we put them into therapy, what the hell is wrong with you?? 'is so much pain' you think people with chronic pain should die? hes probably in pain because of his untreated wounds, but she never spoke to him, he didnt ASK to be killed, its a decision she (and you) are making FOR him.

7. "if she left him there he would get even more disoriented by time" read my post again, i said to save him, you fucking twit. There are options between 'shoot him in the head' and 'leave him in a hole to slowly starve and succumb to disease'. This wasn't a zombie movie, its not the post apocalypse. Its modern day west virginia. There is a hospital within a 2 hour drive of the hole he is currently in. DC is about 6 hours away. If you cant save him right now you can send help after you get to safety. a bunch of rapists with pointy sticks and spike traps arent gonna last very long once the govt figures out they are kidnapping, raping, and torturing anyone that wanders through (they had at least 10 people in that cave)

8. "to be a social warrior"

pee your pants