What kinda parents do you think Max and Roxanne would be, you mentieond they'd have more kid?

I think Roxanne would be fairly attentive but Max would be more hands-off, not in a neglectful way but just trying to give his kids the space he wished he'd had.

Do you have any new headcanons for older Pistol, I did read "poor Pistolkins" BTW? Like what she was doing in the movies or how she reacts to being an aunt?

I haven't really thought too much about it but basically, she physically takes after her mother, but unlike her, is too much of a free spirit to settle down, in addition to occasionally engaging in underhanded behaviors that mirror Pete. She loves playing with Max and PJ's kids, but ironically ends up much closer to Max's despite not being related by blood. She is also still close with Pete.

During the events of An Extremely Goofy Movie, she'd be about 12 years old and going through a tumultuous puberty. Peg would be there to guide her from her similar experiences.

Disney wiki was proposing that the Pete living next to young Max and Goofy in Once Upon A Christmas's Goofy segment was a different Pete from the one in Spoonerville, noting this Pete's reddish coloration?

Also I'm guessing the writers felt the short wouldn't have the Goof Troop feel if Pete didn't show up, even if it is kinda of a continuity headache?

Or maybe they wanted to base it on Goof Troop but thought Pete having virtuous family members would undermine his not believing in Santa Claus. Sidenote, that's probably one of the best executions of the "Santa objectively exists but some people still don't believe in him" premise.

Oh yeah, good point about many of the anthros in the Goof Troop series having perfectly humanoid faces that the skull could perfectly belong too.

I think snouts and ears in their universe are like how some people have connected ear-lobes and other s do not.

Also were there ever any pig-nose anthros in Goof Troop, I don't think so, but I wanted to make sure.

No pig noses, but there was a human nose once (but that was a continuity error).

In Great Egg-Spectations, Pistol was telling Pete that PJ was keeping a wild dinosaur in his room and to force the door open to see it. When Pete opened the door, he found nothing and politely explained to Pistol, she must've been imagining the dinosaur.

When Pistol pointed out the window, Pete saw PJ with Max and Bubbles the dinosaur disguised as a pool toy, he explained to Pistol it was just her brother and Max playing with a toy, waved down to them and asked if he could join and show them his belly flop, of course they split there to avoid revealing Bubbles.

Pete was grouchier when he found the dinosaur eating his favorite chair, though he never seemed to realize Max and PJ tricked him. Oddly after Bubbles mom breathed fire on him and made him faint, everyone, including PJ, seemed to think he'd forget Bubbles and her mom once he awoke.

Could be because that's one of PJ's sillier appearances, or maybe a cheeky reference to the show's negative continuity.

I think the animators snuck in the paddle trophy case in Mazur's office to show his stance on o children, but my headcanon is Mazur misses corporal punishment such as spanking, especially in schools.

Mazur's logic is that "spare the rod, spoil the child" and that physical punishment results in a successful and well adjusted, citing his own youth as proof it turns unruly youth into responsible adults.

Sounds pretty close to my own idea.

Kinda of a small thing, but in the mafia episode (Goof Fellas), I did notice Pete did say they should call the police when he saw mobsters trying to drown a man, so guess that's a small point in his favor.

Also random thought, but did he seem friendlier to PJ in Great egg-spectations?

Pete may be a lot of things, but he doesn't like people dying! At least in this universe.

I don't recall them having much notable interaction in Great Egg-Spectations.

Disney wiki proposes that the Pete in Once Upon a christmas could be a different Pete, which isn't impossible I suppose, Your thoughts?

Well, there are two versions of Pete in that movie, the one who is neighbors with Goofy and Max (similar to Goof Troop), and the one who is Mickey's boss. At the very least those are two separate continuities.

My headcanon is a college graduated adult with a succesful job and family, Pj would longer be afraid of Pete.

As for Pete, similar to how he came to appreciate Goofy move by the time of movies, I headcanon he'd eventually come to really miss his son after having him gone and eventually call PJ begging him to come and visit.

PJ would eventually agree, though only after making Pete apologize for the horrible parenting he did and seeing he was really sorry. Also he'd have Goofy and perhaps Peg (assuming she's still with Pete) during visits to supervise Pete when he's with PJ and his family.

Agreed with Pete's post-AEGM arc, I think the third paragraph is a sweet idea.

I noticed Goofy's motorcycle in Queasy Rider has human-ish skull symbols on it, just kinda of an interesting observation.

Some of the characters have relatively flat faces that could be more humanoid without noses or ears, interestingly. Such as Bradley and some background characters. Honestly, the evolutionary trees in this universe boggle the mind.

How do you think Pete would treat any grandchildren?

For PJ's first/only son, he would try to insist that he was Pete III despite that definitely not being his name, and otherwise try to impose his values on the children. I imagine Pistol would remain childless and PJ would try to keep them away from him as much as possible.

Do you have any thoughts on Principal Mazur's trophy case of Paddles? One of the paddles even have spikes on it!

Probably mostly used as a scare tactic, but he could have used them in the past. Or just fantasizes about it.

Random thought, but do you think Pete would have any opinions on Principal Mazur or vice a versa?

I think, despite agreeing about Max at the beginning of the movie and having similar temperaments, they would absolutely despise each other. Pete would think Mazur was a stuffy old bore and Mazur would think Pete was the exact kind of person that he thought Max would turn into (which Pete wouldn't have the self-awareness to realize, or he'd just be too hypocritical to care).

What do you think of MIckey's once upon a Christmas's Goofy and Max segment, do you consider it canon to Goof Troop?

I consider it to be a close-but-inexact canon since Pete doesn't have a kid Max's age (or a wife for that matter).

My personal headcanon for what happened to Bradley, PJ and the Gammas: Bradley was suspended from College and kicked out of the gammas. Whilst he wasn't arrested, he also got in trouble with his father as the latter had to pay for damages caused by the Gammas.

Finally Bradley was made to to do community service around the college. Whilst he isn't entirely remorseful and definitely not redeemed, Bradley is thinking to himself "you know, maybe cheating and nearly getting people killed in the X-games wasn't the right decision".

Tank wasn't punished for throwing Bradley into Chuck's Blimp as the race organizers allowed due to Bradley nearly getting Tank killed (they are glaring at Bradley when Tank advances on him) and that Tank wasn't trying to kill Bradley; just humiliate and hurt him with cartoon injuries (Tank almost being killed in the fire was not cartoon violence and could've actually killed him).

The other Gammas are reluctant about Tank's new leadership and new stance of playing fair and friendly instead of cheating, some of them miss Bradley and the old days where the fraternity could bully others.

Excellent aftermath ideas!

If you were doing an ancestors episode, either an original one or a pre-existing one, what kinda role would you give Max and PJ; note they don't have to be related to Goofy, Pete (and Peg's) characters?

The obvious change I would make would be to make PJ one of Goofin' Hood's Melancholy Men, if not the main one. I was disappointed that wasn't actually true in the episode.

Regarding others, we could have Max in some sidekick roles.

Looking at some artwork, what do you think Goofy, Peg and Pete were like in High school, do you think they could've held a movie or special?

From what I've seen, Goofy and Peg were probably pretty similar in temperament, but less responsible and, in Peg's case, more likely to give into temptation. Pete, on the other hand, is implied to have been MORE attentive and caring in the past.